American air carriers need to learn from Asia (sad)

Price plays a part, but I think it is now a small piece in the larger puzzle.

Most travelers have their patterns dictated to them because of their travel agreements their employer has. My wife had to travel for work a few weeks ago and she was able to book a nonstop even though it wasn't the cheapest. Some companies even book airline tickets because their parent company owns a large share in said airline, or they have 'common interests' with their board of directors. For others we also have the frequent flyer portion of it.

I already explained that. A given city pair will only support a certain price point.

I.
Are.
Confused.
 
Just to make it clear as well, yes, there have been many of US Carriers accidents because of a breakdown of CRM. However, we as a US culture, strive for change and an enhancement of our CRM practices.

Full agreement here. I just couldn't hold back on the political sidebar poke. :)
 
So why is the price that low to begin with, if the route will support higher? Why was there an even lower priced option available that she chose not to go with. I wasn't aware that airlines were in the business of charity.

Also, will corporations pay whatever it costs to get their employees from point A to point B, regardless of "what the market will bear". I'm guessing the answer starts with y and ends in es.
 
So why is the price that low to begin with, if the route will support higher? Why was there an even lower priced option available that she chose not to go with. I wasn't aware that airlines were in the business of charity.

The airline business is a business based upon market share. Once you lose it, it's incredibly difficult to get it back. And losing that market share will cost you even more money than taking a loss on a specific route, because the system is based upon feeding high profit routes from lower (or no) profit routes. Hence fare wars, a result of deregulation.

Also, will corporations pay whatever it costs to get their employees from point A to point B, regardless of "what the market will bear". I'm guessing the answer starts with y and ends in es.

You guess wrong. We saw after 9/11 what companies are really willing to do. When they go into cost saving mode, they shift to teleconferencing, video conferencing, and other means to accomplish business without air travel. When prices stay below a certain point, they prefer in-person meetings.

Sorry, but this really is basic economics. A given product, not only air travel, only supports a given price point.
 
IMO, it's one of the pitfalls of a Union/Seniority based job. They usually work in favor for the employee, not so much for the customer.
It assumes (possibly incorrectly) that all the interchangeable parts have the same level of skill, dedication etc. to the job. At a baseline level, that might be true, but yeah.

I still prefer it, even at 50% in my base.
 
The airline business is a business based upon market share. Once you lose it, it's incredibly difficult to get it back. And losing that market share will cost you even more money than taking a loss on a specific route, because the system is based upon feeding high profit routes from lower (or no) profit routes. Hence fare wars, a result of deregulation.



You guess wrong. We saw after 9/11 what companies are really willing to do. When they go into cost saving mode, they shift to teleconferencing, video conferencing, and other means to accomplish business without air travel. When prices stay below a certain point, they prefer in-person meetings.

Sorry, but this really is basic economics. A given product, not only air travel, only supports a given price point.


True! Over the last 20 years between Boeing and GE I've seen a lot of changes in coprorate travel. It used to be book whatever you wanted. Boeing policy was Business Class for all international and 1st for US connecting segments on International. Heck my Saudi tickets were $12k four times a year.

Then it went to pick lowest airfare, but that was easy to game as you just changed departure times around until the numbers fit with the policy.

Here's its lowest airfare, but with a certain dollar amount over you can play with, again, with the dozens of airfares between any city pair based on date and time you can usually force the policy to fit your airline choice.

Latest changes though is we went from a 10 hour rule (any flights of 10 hours or more were Business / First to your Butt is in coach no matter what now. They also want you to drive between places that are 6 hours or so apart. The last one seems kind of odd when you total rental car costs, fuel, and my salary for two days of travel (inbound and outbound), it completey wipes out the saving, actually costs more and instead of being productive, they pay me very handsomely to be a cab driver.....oh well :)
 
You guess wrong. We saw after 9/11 what companies are really willing to do. When they go into cost saving mode, they shift to teleconferencing, video conferencing, and other means to accomplish business without air travel. When prices stay below a certain point, they prefer in-person meetings.

Sorry, but this really is basic economics. A given product, not only air travel, only supports a given price point.
Erm, we're also talking about the same guys who will buy large, expensive, environment-destroying corporate airplanes to haul one person around too, post-9/11. But your analysis is correct for the peons.
 
IMO, it's one of the pitfalls of a Union/Seniority based job. They usually work in favor for the employee, not so much for the customer.

Yeah. I understand that the international flights are usually held by the senior flight attendants, but they can still smile and be polite and courteous. AA has some of the most disgruntled people that you wouldn't even want to ask them for anything. I got better service on Korean Air in economy than I ever did in business class at AA.

I guess its more of a culture thing. In America just having the job is not good enough reason to give good service and act like a professional.
 
Back to the OP, god forbid the glideslope at your destination goes down for maintenance. Not the ILS mind you... the GLIDESLOPE!!!
 
Their service may be better, but statistics show that American crews have better CRM and are less likely to crash into a seawall short of the runway. I'll take miserable old AA f/a's who play angry birds, but work with competent pilots over the Asian alternative any day of the week.
 
That's nice, but their safety cultures are lagging decades behind US Carriers. Doubt it will ever be on par with US Carriers due to vast cultural differences engrained in their society.

Also, US Carriers are enhancing their international (and domestic) products so any service gap is quickly being closed.

I agree their CRM has some catching up to do, but I think it will be a while before the service gap closes in America. It is way too far apart right now. Like someone else said, unions and seniority will kill that.
 
Their service may be better, but statistics show that American crews have better CRM and are less likely to crash into a seawall short of the runway. I'll take miserable old AA f/a's who play angry birds, but work with competent pilots over the Asian alternative any day of the week.



What we need is a Hybrid alternative. Keep the American Crews and F/A's, but force them to sit in the back playing angry birds (kind of a bit of British Irony there) unless a safety event is happening.

Bring on the Hooter gals for service and Trivia night :)
 
Back to the OP, god forbid the glideslope at your destination goes down for maintenance. Not the ILS mind you... the GLIDESLOPE!!!
Their service may be better, but statistics show that American crews have better CRM and are less likely to crash into a seawall short of the runway. I'll take miserable old AA f/a's who play angry birds, but work with competent pilots over the Asian alternative any day of the week.

Ok, I get it, safety and CRM....

Obviously there was a huge lapse in CRM on the Asiana flight, but what about the dumbass that plowed the Colgan aircraft in the ground or Air France? I know the air france pilots get much more training than US pilots.


I was posting about the actual service as a consumer.
 
Back
Top