American air carriers need to learn from Asia (sad)

Goonie

Never say die
I just returned from traveling to Korea and China and it was the first time I had ever flown on an Asian air carrier before.

I flew Korean Air DFW-ICN only because the ticket was actually cheaper than American for the same direct flight. The service was night and day from anything I have ever got from an AA flight or and American based air carrier. Of course its no secret they have strict flight attendant qualifications and they are all beautiful women, but it was much more than that. They actually smile and are always asking if you're comfortable or if you need anything. All the overseas flights I've done with AA they usually just turn the lights off and go in the back and play angry birds for hours until its meal time. God forbid you push the call button because you need something to drink.

Oh, the bonus was most of the passengers were all Korean so while I was sitting and anxiously looking down the aisle to see who was going to be my neighbor for the next 14 hours, I didn't have to sweat out the 350 pounder walking closer to my aisle thinking "please 8 pound baby jesus, no, not him".

They will be my first pick from now on.
 
That's nice, but their safety cultures are lagging decades behind US Carriers. Doubt it will ever be on par with US Carriers due to vast cultural differences engrained in their society.

Also, US Carriers are enhancing their international (and domestic) products so any service gap is quickly being closed.
 
That's nice, but their safety cultures are lagging decades behind US Carriers. Doubt it will ever be on par with US Carriers due to vast cultural differences engrained in their society.

Also, US Carriers are enhancing their international (and domestic) products so any service gap is quickly being closed.

Ultimately though, while those are all well and good things to have and accomplish, I still see the consumer going to "the cheapest", rightly or wrongly; simply because all of the above is either transparent to the consumer, or they just outside their concern.
 
Ultimately though, while those are all well and good things to have and accomplish, I still see the consumer going to "the cheapest", rightly or wrongly; simply because all of the above is either transparent to the consumer, or they just outside their concern.


Or you get ones like me that go for cheapest elite qualifying mile.....

Going to Manila, by way of GRR-ORD-PVG-HKG-MNL not because it was the cheapest, but it got me the cheapest Elite Status award miles. I'm sure I'll be cursing Buddha on that 14+ hour ORD-PVG leg though :)
 
Ultimately though, while those are all well and good things to have and accomplish, I still see the consumer going to "the cheapest", rightly or wrongly; simply because all of the above is either transparent to the consumer, or they just outside their concern.

Price plays a part, but I think it is now a small piece in the larger puzzle.

Most travelers have their patterns dictated to them because of their travel agreements their employer has. My wife had to travel for work a few weeks ago and she was able to book a nonstop even though it wasn't the cheapest. Some companies even book airline tickets because their parent company owns a large share in said airline, or they have 'common interests' with their board of directors. For others we also have the frequent flyer portion of it.

If someone lives in a large hub city, most likely they will take a nonstop flight over a cheaper, connecting option, even when traveling for leisure. A family of five going to Disney doesn't want to spend two hours more traveling to save $10.00 a ticket with young kids.
 
Last edited:
That's nice, but their safety cultures are lagging decades behind US Carriers. Doubt it will ever be on par with US Carriers due to vast cultural differences engrained in their society.

Also, US Carriers are enhancing their international (and domestic) products so any service gap is quickly being closed.
asiana-flight-214.jpg

</thread>
 
Not to mention our seniority and labor systems tend to breed a lot of senior momma (poppas) who simply don't give a...
 
Problem is, the same can be said with regards to the Asiana crash photo for any US carrier that has had an accident due to pilot/crew error, in terms of how the public views it. Fact remains that for every accident, there are tons of flights that complete just fine and with no event, whether asian or US carrier.The public simply doesn't notice, and really doesn't care. Again, neither right or wrong, just true.
 
Problem is, the same can be said with regards to the Asiana crash photo for any US carrier that has had an accident due to pilot/crew error, in terms of how the public views it. Fact remains that for every accident, there are tons of flights that complete just fine and with no event, whether asian or US carrier.The public simply doesn't notice, and really doesn't care. Again, neither right or wrong, just true.
Of course.

I have just enough confidence in our regulator that I believe we would have kicked such carriers out of the airspace already if there was a tremendous problem. That said, as you know, the absence of an accident does not imply that the operation is safe, and just because a flight happens to complete successfully with a lower level of safety doesn't mean that the holes will not EVENTUALLY line up as they did for Flight 214. (I think there's a problem. Actually I think there are problems domestically too, but I also think we're working hard to solve them. I sure do. I wholeheartedly embrace FOQA and ASAP along with TEM.)

Not to mention our seniority and labor systems tend to breed a lot of senior momma (poppas) who simply don't give a...
The thing about experience is that you get away with something for so long - and then you suddenly don't.
 
Problem is, the same can be said with regards to the Asiana crash photo for any US carrier that has had an accident due to pilot/crew error, in terms of how the public views it. Fact remains that for every accident, there are tons of flights that complete just fine and with no event, whether asian or US carrier.The public simply doesn't notice, and really doesn't care. Again, neither right or wrong, just true.

This website, while public, isn't like reddit. We know that there are cultural differences between US and Foreign Airlines which can cause more catastrophic failures in CRM because of the underlying societal factors. So when we are discussing the differences between US and Foreign Airlines, we as aviation enthusiasts, and professionals need to keep that in mind. We also need to educate the public about these differences.
 
This website, while public, isn't like reddit. We know that there are cultural differences between US and Foreign Airlines which can cause more catastrophic failures in CRM because of the underlying societal factors. So when we are discussing the differences between US and Foreign Airlines, we as aviation enthusiasts, and professionals need to keep that in mind. We also need to educate the public about these differences.
The truth of the matter is, when a perfectly airworthy airplane is flown into the ground on a clear and a million VFR day, there is something wrong with the people-ware.

(Pending official NTSB determinations of cause, but this is a true statement.)
 
The truth of the matter is, when a perfectly airworthy airplane is flown into the ground on a clear and a million VFR day, there is something wrong with the people-ware.

(Pending official NTSB determinations of cause, but this is a true statement.)

I would call it a break down of CRM.

Change the sentence to....'there is something wrong with the CRM'.....

:)
 
This website, while public, isn't like reddit. We know that there are cultural differences between US and Foreign Airlines which can cause more catastrophic failures in CRM because of the underlying societal factors. So when we are discussing the differences between US and Foreign Airlines, we as aviation enthusiasts, and professionals need to keep that in mind. We also need to educate the public about these differences.

I like the American exceptionalism, normally a far-right concept, that you display here.

:D

And I agree too.
 
I like the American exceptionalism, normally a far-right concept, that you display here.

:D

And I agree too.

Just to make it clear as well, yes, there have been many of US Carriers accidents because of a breakdown of CRM. However, we as a US culture, strive for change and an enhancement of our CRM practices.
 
Treating your customers with courtesy, respect and professionalism requires no more effort than treating them like the enemy.
 
Back
Top