Agreed. There is much better potential at an FBO to become a better pilot, with better variety of training etc.
Just be sure to get a GOOD instructor, and be sure to keep a structured way of flying.
I think the difference in training between an FBO and "select" academies can be significant in different ways.
An FBO may provide you with more aeronautical
experience. Good old stick and rudder throw it in the short grass strip skills.
Whereas an Academy will usually provide you with more aeronautical
knowledge. Some FBO's (not ALL) have limited or no structure, including ground school. They may be teaching more of a General aviation type syllabus. The Academy on the other hand, will teach you things geared towards flying as a profession, and include things such as strict checklist usage, airline procedures etc.
Excluding price, I would choose an academy getting into this career. They are training you from day one on how to be an Airline pilot. Upon graduating from these academies, you may lack (depending on your instructor) some of the aviation experience that an FBO pilot has. What gets you farther? What is more important?
For Airline (121) ground school and training purposes, the academy perpares you better. You have been used to an accelerated learning environment structured about procedures and checklist usage. What happens if you fail to follow a checklist as an Airline pilot? You're going to get nailed.
I had the opportunity to teach both academy students and FBO trained students. My FBO trained students had better stick and rudder skills. They had finesse and overall they were better aviators. Checklist usage and adherence to policy and procedure was an issue. Regulations and in depth aeronautical knowledge of the ATC environment, IFR environment and more advanced aeronautical terms were lacking.
Academy students were a bit weaker on stick and rudder skills, but were very sharp on IFR procedures, Radio usage, checklist usage and procedure adherence as well.
This is not to say that FBO students are any less or any better then Academy pilots. They have different strengths and weaknesses, both of which will be developed further as they progress.
I think this explains why academy grads. typically have better performance in 121 ground school and flying the numbers. FBO students are used to seat of the pants, stick and rudder stuff. Airline flying
is by the numbers. This concept is easier for those who have been trained to that concept from day one.
Both FBO and Academy pilots will have struggles to overcome during training. A strength of the FBO pilot may be the weakness of the Academy pilot.
With the current state of the economy, I say choose a training facility based on PRICE, availability and quality of equipment and instructors. Your Airline interview will succeed or fail based on many factors outside of where you trained. If you exhibit an in-depth knowledge, present an image of professionalism and maturity and have nothing hiding in your backround, it doesn't matter where you did your training.
When you start 121 ground school, you are on the same playing field as everyone else. You either sink or you swim.