Airlines in a downward spiral - Regionals being cut?????

It's always better to pull your own number than to have someone pull it for you!

Something I keep telling myself in the wonderful world of business........."In today's working world there is no loyalty, keep that resume updated and owe no one anything!"

Good luck with your endeavour (SP)!
 
Another JC success story!:)


Unfortunately I DID put down the deposit at ATP and then decided at the last minute to keep my day job/train at the FBO. I suppose I will save 20k or so in the long run. Right now I'm renting 172 M models for $78 WET and 172SPs for $91WET. Not too bad.
 
Unfortunately I DID put down the deposit at ATP and then decided at the last minute to keep my day job/train at the FBO. I suppose I will save 20k or so in the long run. Right now I'm renting 172 M models for $78 WET and 172SPs for $91WET. Not too bad.

That sucks :(, I remember reading your post about that when I was just researching different schools and not a JC member yet. By the way how is the local FBO thing going for you thus far? When did you start and how far in are you?
 
"How many "different environments" does your FBO offer"

Well, Bob, I'll tell ya....

First of all, how many types does ATP offer? 172 and Seminole. That's if you leave out the Citation and flight sims. How many airplanes did I fly when I was at an FBO. 150, 152, 172, 182, 206, 210, PA28-140, PA32-260, Mooney M20C, Aeronca Sedan (tailwheel), Cessna 310, 402, and AC690 Aero Commander. I logged legal time in each of these types before my commercial single. While the syllabus may have been loose, I'll suggest that there is learning to be done outside following a strict syllabus.

Other things I did at an FBO. Operations out of 1800 foot runway in a 152, cross country in a Cessna 310, ferrying a new 172 solo back from ICT, single pilot single engine IMC, and sitting right seat (unloggable but educational) 135 IFR ops over the Cascades in the winter.

You can find some great experience outside the bubble. I think going that route make you a better pilot, overall.
 
vladi34,

PLEASE take the advice you've been given here and do NOT go to ATP! Unless of course you have the money handed to you, which obviously isn't the case. Why?

Well I did their program a few years ago. The price was much much cheaper then. I financed a total of $50k for the PPL and ACPP. After I deferred payments on the loan for almost a year (because as a CFI, you don't make SQUAT!), I acrued like $8k in interest. Not to mention with the economy spinning in the crapper, my interest rate on the KEY BANK loan went from 6% to 8.9%.

I'm flying for a good Airline now, but dude, $550/month payments are KILLING me! Read that again!! I might make $23,000 this year. **Might** I'm married, have a house but no kids yet. I ran up so much credit card debt as a CFI and as an FO at Colgan because more than HALF of my monthly salary goes to pay the school loan. What I was left with, just couldn't pay car insurance and buy food. Had no choice but to take the credit card roller coaster.

I'm not even going to add up what I have in debt, but let me tell you that it is NOT fun. Try not being able to sleep at night because you just got the first half of your monthly guarantee you cleared $460 - thats for half of the month. That doesn't even cover the school loan.

ATP sold me on their program back then and don't get me wrong, its a good school. But the truth is, NOBODY CARES!!! :D Seriously, not a single interviewer asked a thing about ATP. Just whether or not I busted a checkride. I could have gotten to where I am today for $30,000 LESS. I can not tell you how hard it is to make it in this career with a heavy debt load.

I calculated that I won't have my debt paid off, assuming I upgrade to the left seat in 2 years (which that probably won't happen), until 2018 at the earliest and thats assuming I am making more then double payments on the loan when I get to Captain pay. I'm making VERY little headway on what these Airlines are paying.

Think long and hard about how you're going to pay for the training dude, because I didn't. I figured I'd do the fast track, be at an Airline within 6 months, upgrade within 1 1/2 years and be paying down my debt. Didn't happen and I was foolish to plan like that. I just got starry-eyed and ATP sold me their load of crap. Don't do it!
 
I'll put my "crappy" ma and pa FBO flight time and experience against any major academy pilot any day.

I agree with you on your point about major academy's exposing and preparing their students to scheduled airline flying from day one, and in many regards that is a good thing. The one potential flaw that I do see though is that these schools, or should I say instructors are recylced products...I'm sure ATP and the other major schools have a great syllabus to follow, but considering nearly all the instructors were a product of the same environment, I fear that these guys and girls never see outside that syllabus because no one actually has many other experiences.

I'm not saying that "ma and pa" FBO is crappy. I'm saying that the quality is highly variable, and largely dependent on the motivation of the student and the instructor.

Don't get me wrong, I think that an FBO can do a better job getting someone ready for "the real world." I think they often do. I got my private from an FBO, and I felt like I had a much different perspective of flying when I got to my "pilot mill."

The problem is, from a hiring perspective, it is hard to know if this FBO trained individual is of the well trained variety, or not, in the short span of time we have to evaluate them. We get a known quantity from some of the major flight schools, and on average they do better in the initial training.

Again, I don't think you can tell a difference after a few thousand hours of flying.

G
 
Where do you see anyone with 3000 hours out of the academy? The academies just sift the students through the program and kick them out with pieces of paper that says they could fly while retaining all of their life savings :) And that guy with several thousands hours who can't talk to atc, that must have been an extreme case of someone who flew a crop duster for thousands of hours and then decided to go airline.
Anyway, my point is...250 hours might or might not mean much because it could have been a quality time or just burning holes in the sky. Now, I know academies have a program and every hour is pretty much aimed at doing something constructive, but that doesn't mean that someone coming from ma and pa fbo was only burning holes in the sky and didn't learn anything. There is no telling if academy folks or fbo folks are better, that's why there are checkrides and different kinds of tests to filter the candidates. You can't just say "oh, this guy is better, he's from atp" that's bull. There are better schools and worse schools just as there are students with better learning abilities and the ones that are slower, any generalization is just coming from one's personal experience such as yours :)

You missed the point. I meant by the 3000 hour comment that someone's background cannot be distinguished after a few thousand hours of experience at an airline.

And we do have data at our company that shows that, in general, people from Embry Riddle, and the like, do better in initial training. That doesn't mean they are better pilots, it just means that they are generally better prepared for the sort of training that goes on at the airline.

And I NEVER said that you can look at someone and say, "oh, this guy is better, he's from ATP." That is bull. But, you can look at the overall hiring data over a two year period, and see that people from "pilot mills" had fewer extra simulator sessions, fewer hours of initial operating experience training, and fewer checkride busts in initial training. That is all I'm saying.

I'm talking about averages here guys.
 
"How many "different environments" does your FBO offer"

Well, Bob, I'll tell ya....

First of all, how many types does ATP offer? 172 and Seminole. That's if you leave out the Citation and flight sims. How many airplanes did I fly when I was at an FBO. 150, 152, 172, 182, 206, 210, PA28-140, PA32-260, Mooney M20C, Aeronca Sedan (tailwheel), Cessna 310, 402, and AC690 Aero Commander. I logged legal time in each of these types before my commercial single. While the syllabus may have been loose, I'll suggest that there is learning to be done outside following a strict syllabus.

Other things I did at an FBO. Operations out of 1800 foot runway in a 152, cross country in a Cessna 310, ferrying a new 172 solo back from ICT, single pilot single engine IMC, and sitting right seat (unloggable but educational) 135 IFR ops over the Cascades in the winter.

You can find some great experience outside the bubble. I think going that route make you a better pilot, overall.


Agreed. There is much better potential at an FBO to become a better pilot, with better variety of training etc.

Just be sure to get a GOOD instructor, and be sure to keep a structured way of flying.
 
Agreed. There is much better potential at an FBO to become a better pilot, with better variety of training etc.

Just be sure to get a GOOD instructor, and be sure to keep a structured way of flying.

I think the difference in training between an FBO and "select" academies can be significant in different ways.

An FBO may provide you with more aeronautical experience. Good old stick and rudder throw it in the short grass strip skills.

Whereas an Academy will usually provide you with more aeronautical knowledge. Some FBO's (not ALL) have limited or no structure, including ground school. They may be teaching more of a General aviation type syllabus. The Academy on the other hand, will teach you things geared towards flying as a profession, and include things such as strict checklist usage, airline procedures etc.

Excluding price, I would choose an academy getting into this career. They are training you from day one on how to be an Airline pilot. Upon graduating from these academies, you may lack (depending on your instructor) some of the aviation experience that an FBO pilot has. What gets you farther? What is more important?

For Airline (121) ground school and training purposes, the academy perpares you better. You have been used to an accelerated learning environment structured about procedures and checklist usage. What happens if you fail to follow a checklist as an Airline pilot? You're going to get nailed.

I had the opportunity to teach both academy students and FBO trained students. My FBO trained students had better stick and rudder skills. They had finesse and overall they were better aviators. Checklist usage and adherence to policy and procedure was an issue. Regulations and in depth aeronautical knowledge of the ATC environment, IFR environment and more advanced aeronautical terms were lacking.

Academy students were a bit weaker on stick and rudder skills, but were very sharp on IFR procedures, Radio usage, checklist usage and procedure adherence as well.

This is not to say that FBO students are any less or any better then Academy pilots. They have different strengths and weaknesses, both of which will be developed further as they progress.

I think this explains why academy grads. typically have better performance in 121 ground school and flying the numbers. FBO students are used to seat of the pants, stick and rudder stuff. Airline flying is by the numbers. This concept is easier for those who have been trained to that concept from day one.

Both FBO and Academy pilots will have struggles to overcome during training. A strength of the FBO pilot may be the weakness of the Academy pilot.

With the current state of the economy, I say choose a training facility based on PRICE, availability and quality of equipment and instructors. Your Airline interview will succeed or fail based on many factors outside of where you trained. If you exhibit an in-depth knowledge, present an image of professionalism and maturity and have nothing hiding in your backround, it doesn't matter where you did your training.

When you start 121 ground school, you are on the same playing field as everyone else. You either sink or you swim.
 
Honestly? If you struggle through a part 121 ground school it has nothing to do with how you prepared, and has everything to do with you simply not being that smart and/or not knowing how to study. It doesn't matter where you come from before you get there, they gear the programs at regional airlines to get you through assuming you have very little base knowledge.

I majored in philosophy and flew at FBO's for all my training and I thought while going through 135 and 121 ground schools that if you can't hack the ground/systems portion of the training, you simply don't know how to study and might be a tiny bit dim. I think having a four year degree prepares you a lot better to get through ground school than any academy will.
 
Honestly? If you struggle through a part 121 ground school it has nothing to do with how you prepared, and has everything to do with you simply not being that smart and/or not knowing how to study. It doesn't matter where you come from before you get there, they gear the programs at regional airlines to get you through assuming you have very little base knowledge.

I majored in philosophy and flew at FBO's for all my training and I thought while going through 135 and 121 ground schools that if you can't hack the ground/systems portion of the training, you simply don't know how to study and might be a tiny bit dim. I think having a four year degree prepares you a lot better to get through ground school than any academy will.
:yeahthat: We had a good conversation in ATL about this.
 
Honestly? If you struggle through a part 121 ground school it has nothing to do with how you prepared, and has everything to do with you simply not being that smart and/or not knowing how to study. It doesn't matter where you come from before you get there, they gear the programs at regional airlines to get you through assuming you have very little base knowledge.

We had an Embry Riddle grad who BARELY made it through training. He had two busts on his sim....but, didn't mind sharing that he was an ERAU grad to everyone...including his instructors.

We had a guy who did all of his training at an FBO (much like I did) and barely made it through training. He simply didn't apply himself until it was almost time to take the written.

Both are now flying the EMB in the Northeast.

That said, we had an ATP guy who was as sharp as a tack. He breezed through. Did fine. Left for Skywest after 6 months and last I heard, is doing very well there.

I was an FBO guy through and through. I did very well in training. Never scored lower than 90% on my tests. Did very well in the sim (after getting used to it) and got through training with zero busts.

In short: what I'm saying here is that it all depends on the individual - NOT where he or she trained.

This argument is tired. It used to raise it's ugly head almost daily about 6 to 7 years ago, but finally stopped almost entirely.... until now.

I can tell you that the majority of captains I've flown with dispise the big academy grads. Not for their stick and rudder skills, but for their attitudes. Seems that most feel entitled to the left seat within months of completing IOE.

But.....what do I know? I'm just a FBO guy with 2 years of Part 121, jet experience. (which, when compared to many on this site is miniscule....but compared to some others, is huge....) :rolleyes:
 
NOT all doom and gloom...huh? :) In all seriousness though I think you make some great points and pose some good questions. And fortunately I already have the answers for all off them :rawk:. Before I made my final decision my wife and I (and the kids on a few occasions, they are only 4 and 6 afterall) spent days going over different scenarios, planning for the worst and hoping for the average type of a thing. I think we now have about a 1/3 of a notebook filled up with just our budget plan... And I can really say that I have the BEST and most supportive wife and family in the whole world. They know we are in for some tough times ahead (my 6 year old even offered me his piggy bank to pay for school :D), but I know that they are behind this 150%, otherwise I would not even dream of doing it. And I did some research on the downsides of this career and did not sugar coat anything in our disscusions. As far as reduction in pay I am not new to this field, the company I work for now downsized about 60% of their employees in the last year and I was one of the lucky few that got to take a 25% pay cut instead... I am not ready to give up on this, and will continue to hope for the best, the only other choice I really have is stay here in my office and wait till my number is called, and I would sure rather be up in the clouds even if that means I am only flying around a photographer...

Sorry, didn't mean to be all "doom and gloom"...it is just VERY common for folks to not ask the hard questions. It really looks like you have all your ducks in a row and will be successful in your choices. I think it's AWESOME that you have shared ALL the ups and downs w/ your family. Good on you!!! I also have to say although I am not a big fan of children, the gesture of giving up their piggy bank chokes me up a little. :)

It kinda looks like this thread has turned into another FBO vs. Academy argument, so I am stepping out. Again, excellent job informing yourself and your family.
 
We had an Embry Riddle grad who BARELY made it through training. He had two busts on his sim....but, didn't mind sharing that he was an ERAU grad to everyone...including his instructors.

We had a guy who did all of his training at an FBO (much like I did) and barely made it through training. He simply didn't apply himself until it was almost time to take the written.

Both are now flying the EMB in the Northeast.

That said, we had an ATP guy who was as sharp as a tack. He breezed through. Did fine. Left for Skywest after 6 months and last I heard, is doing very well there.

I was an FBO guy through and through. I did very well in training. Never scored lower than 90% on my tests. Did very well in the sim (after getting used to it) and got through training with zero busts.

In short: what I'm saying here is that it all depends on the individual - NOT where he or she trained.

This argument is tired. It used to raise it's ugly head almost daily about 6 to 7 years ago, but finally stopped almost entirely.... until now.

I can tell you that the majority of captains I've flown with dispise the big academy grads. Not for their stick and rudder skills, but for their attitudes. Seems that most feel entitled to the left seat within months of completing IOE.

But.....what do I know? I'm just a FBO guy with 2 years of Part 121, jet experience. (which, when compared to many on this site is miniscule....but compared to some others, is huge....) :rolleyes:

I agree. It largely depends on the individual. But, you must remember that the instructor is seen as a god when you have almost no flight time. If he/she doesn't instill good habits of checklist usage, and usage of the ATC environment, then that will carry over into their student's flying habits like wildfire.

The major difference in the FBO vs part 141 school is that the 141 school has to have a set syllabus, and the instructor has to stick to it. Also, the 141 school normally has a flight standards department to keep the instructors in line. FBOs have a few instructors, all of whom are different, and all teach completely differently.

Just look for good flying habits, and you'll be fine. Get out there in the ATC system! Don't fly VFR from point to point, avoiding ATC.

G
 
Back
Top