Airlines in a downward spiral - Regionals being cut?????

I REALLY wish that doing this without getting into debt was a possibility for me.... But you all also make a good point, huge debt + no job = major problems. For all of you in the industry, does it matter to the people doing the hiering what school you came from? In other words if you graduated from ATP or some local FBO. I know i hear a lot of people saying that it does not, but I'm not sure how this can be. In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?
Also I hear about having to purchase insurance. What is that all about, would the schools not provide you with this?

You are getting your licenses ultimately by someone who is approved by the FAA, a designated examiner. The standards to get a commercial license are exactly the same, whether you go to Joe Bob's Flight School, or ATP. That's why it doesn't matter.
 
Renters insurance would be needed, not sure if its needed at the big academies.
Some say the school you come from doesn't count, I'm sure there are others that can better answer that, I'm just regurgitating what others have said. Coming from the non-aviation corporate side of things myself I'd have to say that some tactics in aviation aren't what we're used to.
 
getting a job should be no problem.
:banghead: please don't tell me they guaranteed you a job.......

they are marketing their product, like others have already said, they aren't going to tell you anything negative to spook you away from them gaining another $100K student.

I think you might want to continue your research and decide whether you really want and/or need to go the fast track route.

keep in mind that altho they say 5 months (60 days PPL, 90 days others), it can take substantially longer than that based on the amount of instructors they have, maintenance of planes, weather and all sorts of other factors....AND....if you pay them in large chunks and they go out of business, you are SOL, seriously!!
 
I would personally fly on the side while still doing your current job if you are able. Leaving one unstable job for another with debt probably isn't very prudent.

:yeahthat:

I agree. If you're going into a career field which is unstable and initially low paying, any debt is very dangerous. Especially with a family to support.
 
For all of you in the industry, does it matter to the people doing the hiering what school you came from? In other words if you graduated from ATP or some local FBO. I know i hear a lot of people saying that it does not, but I'm not sure how this can be. In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?
the pilot world looks at this differently than other "office like" fields...

instead of the company caring where you got your qualifications, degree, what in etc etc....it's really more about the pilots caring...here's what i mean....

take your harvard grad and mold him into a pilot who got his PPL from a little mom and pop shop, got their CFI, MEI, Commercial etc and instructed, did aerial mapping or any other type of JOB (made $$ for hours gained) for THREE-FOUR years before even applying to the "bigger" guys (cargo, corporate, regional, etc)... i.e. they got their experience by building it - slowly - eventually knowing everything there is to know backwards and forwards.

take your community college guy and mold him into a fast track pilot who got his PPL, CFI, MEI, Commercial etc in about ONE year....instead of making $$ (keeping debt low(er)) and learning everything and MORE (backwards and forwards), he/she shelled out a ton of dough to get to the top faster, guaranteed interview or not.

put those two pilots next to eachother... who would you rather fly with? who do you think would actually be more *confident* when flying 50 passengers from one destination to the next dealing with weather, ATC calls, sick pax, FAs calling all the time (too hot, too cold, bumpy, terrorist on board) and various *emergencies*....and when you think of that, think of the captain on the ship.... is he a partner or team mate or is he the teacher? Remember, pilots are paid (or should be) for their SKILL when it comes to an emergency that can kill you and everyone on board.

That's really how pilots are..hmmm how would i classify it....i think "graded" would be a ok term....so pilots are essentially "graded" by other pilots. The companies don't really care where you got your quals from (unless you kill a bunch of people). essentially, the capts know they're going to be teaching a pilot who came out of a "mill" vs one who took their time to know exactly how to react in any situation possible.

does that kinda make sense? :o

now granted, i'm not saying you can't take the fast approach or that the fast track is wrong or anything, i'm just changing your harvard/community college example into something more useful for this type of field. I don't want to get into any arguements about right/wrong ways of doing things... it's just an example.
 
In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?

Nope not really true for the most part. As was stated above, everyone is given their licenses from the FAA and they have certain standards you must meet. What matters most is your flight time, the kind of experience you have. You can have a great instructor or a bad one at any school you go to.

There are plenty of boneheads that come out of every flight school, just like there are some outstanding pilots that come out of them too. I'm an advocate of NOT rushing training. Although I totally understand the idea of wanting to get things done quickly.

Peronally I went to FlightSafety in Vero, and I think I got pretty good training there. Has it given me an advantage in my job hunts? Not a whole lot, it helped me get the CFI job I had, that's it. And that was because the guy that hired me liked the school. It made no difference for getting hired at the freight place I was at, nor did it mean anything at the last charter place I was at, nor the one I'm about to go to work for. But ALL those places cared about the flight time I had.

There are sooo many places that advertise that they have the best training and are the "Harvard of the skies" but it ultimately comes down to you. A good instructor is extremely important, so find someone you click with and learn well from. And realize your flight certificates and ratings are just a license to learn. So learning should not stop after you get them, or reach your goal.

I don't mean to bash any schools, everyone has their own route that they choose. What works for one person may not work for another.
 
Yeah it does not seem as if we need to be running for the hills just yet jeez.

American Eagle, Trans States, Pinnacle, Piedmont, PSA, Colgan, Horizon, Air Whiskey, and Republic...All still hiring.

There still some majors hiring. There are still some majors planning to hire. There are still plenty of freight gigs. CFI jobs, decent paying CFI jobs, are a dime a dozen.

I'll agree the hiring frenzy of last year is not here this year, but it does not seem as if the shutters have closed quite yet. Plus don't scare me! I just quiit my job to get my CFI and instruct full time. I doubt I'll be ready to even think about a regional until the end of the summer!
 
I understand people wanting to get on as quickly as possible but there comes a point where you have to think about your quality of life. Is it really worth it to move to a new town, without the means to afford decent housing in a good area where you know nobody for 20k? I personally do not think so, but others may be different. Find a company you will be happy working for that has a domicile you want and keep flying until you reach their mins. Don't worry about what the industry is doing, just focus on your goal.

Hopefully Air Whiskey is still hiring in a year for the PHL domicile. If not, I will continue to work as a CFI until they are or a good flying job comes about in the Philadelphia area. I am not about to uproot my life for a job that pays sub poverty wages. Until I get seniority and the ability to live that accompanies it I do not see myself moving.

Also, since we are in a rescission I think now is the time to work towards a new career. Eventually hiring will pick up, not that it is exactly slow at the moment, and when it does you will have all the training and experience you need to jump right in and ride the wave.
 
As the price of fuel has spiked in the past 3 or so months, here is a synopsis of what has happened in aviation.

I'd like to comment on a few of the items on the list as I believe that some of them were going to happen regardless of the price of fuel.

Expressjet stopped hiring

ExpressJet has not taken delivery of a new airplane in several years. That means if the company stays the same size, then the hiring should equal attrition. But, three new bases opened in a very short amount of time. That's three new bases at a company that only had three bases to begin with. Those new bases have to have a pool of pilots sitting reserve, in addition to the ones that are going to be flying the lines out of those airports. Had these bases not opened, ExpressJet would have been hiring for attrition-only at least a year and a half ago.

Skywest stopped hiring

I'm not sure about the net growth at Skywest but if it has stopped (big RJs replacing little RJs perhaps? Not sure) then it was just a matter of time because if a fleet is not growing then hiring for attrition is all that is needed.

Delta stopped hiring

Everything I have read indicates they are going to go ahead with nearly the same plan as was originally drawn out, which is slow it down for the summer then a bit more in the fall. Additionally I have read at numerous sources that with the planned airframe retirements and deliveries at Delta will result in a net gain of airplanes and especially pilots since a larger percentage of the deliveries are ultra long-haul airplanes than the percentage of retiring airplanes (more short haul).

ASA stopped hiring

Is ASA receiving any additional airplanes? If not, see Skywest and ExpressJet. No need to be hiring any more than attrition, and if block hours from big-daddy mainline are going to come back a bit, no need to hire at all for a few months.

FedEx stopped hiring

Age 65 effects FedEx more than the passenger carriers. There are a bunch of over-60 pilots sitting sideways waiting for the rule to change and those pilots are permitted to go back up to the left seat until they hit the age of 65. That means very little attrition for a while. Additionally, the B-757 is about to start flying at FedEx and as we all know it only needs two pilots. The plane that is going to be phased out eventually, the B-727, needs three pilots. If the replacement plan is 1:1 for 727->757, then if there's 1500 727 pilots today, only 1000 757 pilots will be needed. (please, if Seagull, Boom Boom or any other FDX person can enhance this info then go ahead)

UPS has stopped hiring

A lot of the same as my FedEx statement. Any flight engineer over the age of 60 can bid captain and fly 'til 65. And as with FedEx, UPS has a three pilot airplane that is being phased out. The B-747-100/200 requires three pilots but the -400 is on the way and only needs two pilots for flights less then 8 hours. Furthermore, the DC-8s are going to be gone by 2011 and that is being replaced by a two pilot airplane, the B-767.

Northwest is grounding 24 DC-9 aircraft

Northwest had planned on being down to 68 DC-9s by the end of 2008. Their plan has not changed in the past few months and they are going to start receiving 787s next fall.

Regional flying has been cut substantially

50 seat flying is turning into 70-90 seat flying but overall the regionals are flying as much now as they were a year ago. One year from now, I think it will be less than it is now overall but not in 70+ seat area.

Skybus cut back almost 50% of their routes

Hallelujah!

I'm not trying to "pile-on" here and pick apart the whole list but I do think that some things were bound to happen even if oil had stayed at $60 or thereabouts.

The best advice I can give if you want to enter the airline industry is to not have a large amount of debt! Why would you even consider a $100,000 loan??? You can get all your licenses and ratings at your local FBO for $35,000. If I were you, I would do one of two things. I would either save up close to $35,000, then start flight training. Or I would get a decent amount saved up and continue to work while getting your flight training. But whatever you do, DO NOT take out a massive loan on the premise that the airline industry will provide a stable job that will allow you to pay back your massive debt.

I agree with all of that. Some loans are fine; $30,000 worth will not result in enormous loan payments but 100K sure would.
 
"if you graduated from ATP or some local FBO. I know i hear a lot of people saying that it does not, but I'm not sure how this can be. In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?"

ATP is simply a place to get the ratings fast at a premium price. Don't think of it as "Harvard". You're reading too much into their website. You could easily end up a better pilot by taking your time at an FBO. But you say you don't have the time. So I guess it's a tough choice.

Moving up in the biz has nothing to do with where you trained. It's about hours, ratings, and experience levels.
 
First off, I think the best advice is not to panic. If you really want to have a career in aviation, you will make it. The aviation industry is really cyclical.

Here's the deal. The industry is heading for the downward part of the cycle. The price of fuel is just out of control. For every $1 increase in the price of oil, a large company like United loses $60 million a year in extra fuel costs. So when oil goes from $60/barrel to $110/barrel over a 1 year period, a large airline like United loses $3 BILLION dollars. It is a very big deal.

As the price of fuel has spiked in the past 3 or so months, here is a synopsis of what has happened in aviation.

Expressjet stopped hiring
Skywest stopped hiring
United stopped hiring
Delta stopped hiring
ASA stopped hiring
FedEx stopped hiring
UPS has stopped hiring
Expressjet is offering pilots unpaid leave of absences
United is grounding 15-20 737 aircraft
Delta is grounding 10? mainline aircraft
Northwest is grounding 24 DC-9 aircraft
Regional flying has been cut substantially
Comair, Skywest, Expressjet, ASA, Mesa, and others have had their regional contracted flying hours cut
Aloha Airlines filed for bankruptcy (again)
Skybus cut back almost 50% of their routes
Froniter sold 4 aircraft
Jetblue sold 6 aircraft

If it is not apparent from the above info, the price of oil has a major effect on the airline industry. And we are heading into an economic recession. Alan Greenspan has been quoted as saying this recession might be the most severe since World War 2. So the answer to your question is YES, the airline industry is definitely in turbulent times. But that will eventually change.

The best advice I can give if you want to enter the airline industry is to not have a large amount of debt! Why would you even consider a $100,000 loan??? You can get all your licenses and ratings at your local FBO for $35,000. If I were you, I would do one of two things. I would either save up close to $35,000, then start flight training. Or I would get a decent amount saved up and continue to work while getting your flight training. But whatever you do, DO NOT take out a massive loan on the premise that the airline industry will provide a stable job that will allow you to pay back your massive debt.

Save enough money for flight training. Then enter the industry with little to no debt, and have a backup plan. Then if the economy turns south, the price of oil continues to rise, and you find yourself out of a job, you can survive without having a massive monthly debt payment to pay.

ASA is still hiring. We just reduced our monthly goals. I expect that we'll hire around 10 per month for the remainder of the year. We are currently interviewing two days per week, Wednesday and Thursday.

We may still freeze hiring, if we parked airplanes, but it appears that we will just have a reduction, not a complete stoppage. Check the website for updates, though we haven't updated it yet since we slowed hiring.
 
"if you graduated from ATP or some local FBO. I know i hear a lot of people saying that it does not, but I'm not sure how this can be. In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?"

ATP is simply a place to get the ratings fast at a premium price. Don't think of it as "Harvard". You're reading too much into their website. You could easily end up a better pilot by taking your time at an FBO. But you say you don't have the time. So I guess it's a tough choice.

Moving up in the biz has nothing to do with where you trained. It's about hours, ratings, and experience levels.

Hi Don. Overall, I agree with you that an FBO pilot can get the same training that someone would get at a major flight school. But there are a few reasons that companies look favorably upon the major schools vs. mom and pop FBO.

1. Major schools are more structured, in general, and provide a more consistent product that is less dependent upon individual motivation. Instructors teach students that are goal oriented to getting into the airlines, not just being a private pilot, so structure is taught from the beginning. (Yes, it should be taught anyway, but it often isn't.)

2. Major schools provide more tailored training directed at airline-type operations, and that helps low-time individuals do better in training at the airlines. When you are hiring a low-time pilot (I just interviewed a 300 hour pilot!), that guy has to be on top of his game to make it through training. The major schools, for whatever reason, produce people who have historically done better in training if they are low time.

3. Students are at FBO's to get a private certificates, for the most part. They don't know any professional pilots, and aren't surrounded by people with the goal of being in the industry.

4. Instructors at FBOs are highly variable. Some are awesome. Some aren't. Instructors at major universities are generally standardized once a year, and are at least ON AVERAGE, a more known quantity.

There is no doubt in my mind that if you have a 3000 hour pilot from an FBO, and a 3000 hour pilot from a school like ATP, or whatever, that you will not see a bit of difference in them. The difference is going to be in the 250 hour guy that started as a private pilot, and then said, "What the heck, I'll get an airline job." and the 250 hour guy that went to a major school, and from day one knew he was going to the right seat of an airliner. It is a mindset thing more than anything else.

We hired someone with several thousand hours recently that just about got washed out because all of his time was in non-complex airspace, not talking to ATC, and presumably not using checklists. He did fine flying the airplane, but all of the other stuff (getting ATIS, clearance, taxi communications, ramp communications, etc.) just overwhelmed him.

Re-reading your post, I see that you said moving up in the biz, and I agree 100% with that. Once you have your starting airline job, it is more about experience and hours than anything else. But sometimes it does matter at a regional if you don't have much experience and few hours.

My .02 anyway. :)
 
I'll put my "crappy" ma and pa FBO flight time and experience against any major academy pilot any day.

I agree with you on your point about major academy's exposing and preparing their students to scheduled airline flying from day one, and in many regards that is a good thing. The one potential flaw that I do see though is that these schools, or should I say instructors are recylced products...I'm sure ATP and the other major schools have a great syllabus to follow, but considering nearly all the instructors were a product of the same environment, I fear that these guys and girls never see outside that syllabus because no one actually has many other experiences.
 
Well, here are my thoughts. You have a wife and kid(s) at home. Here are a couple of questions to ask yourself: What kind of money does your wife make and is it enough to support us? Is your family going to be affected by initial low pay (22-25K a year) and the possibility of being furloughed? Will your wife resent the fact that you are on the road 3 or 4 days (or more) at a time? Will she support you if you need to move halfway across the country away from friends and family or will she mind you spending an extra 4-5-6 unpaid days away from home commuting? Does you family have the ENTIRE picture in front of them? I think almost everyone who has been involved in commercial aviation (airline flying especially) for more than 10 years has experienced being furloughed or a reduction of pay (having to change jobs) or at least been REALLY close to it. Are ALL of you ready to make that kind of commitment?

Chasing the dream is a HUGE deal. Money, time, family...it takes sacrifice on every member of your family. There are plenty of threads out there that discuss the FBO v. academy routes, but you need to sit down and figure out what is best for you and your family.

I also agree that we are on the downhill slide in regional hiring. Many people have said "if it gets bad, I'll just CFI until it gets better." Well, if hiring stops or slows to a crawl it all goes down hill. After 9/11 there wasn't a lot of training going on out there. What does that mean? Yep, keen competition for even those CFI jobs (and they generally pay crap, especially if the market is flooded with tons of unemployed CFIs).

I am not the doom and gloom kinda of person, but people who are new to the idea of commercial flying tend to look at the positive sides of it and just "gloss over" the negatives. You need to weigh the pros and cons and make the best decision that you can. Luckily this forum has LOTS of good advice and perspectives--and well there is some crap out there too, but if you spend more than a couple of hours browsing the forum, you'll see the ones that tend to post the "not as useful" information.
 
...but considering nearly all the instructors were a product of the same environment, I fear that these guys and girls never see outside that syllabus because no one actually has many other experiences.
How many "different environments" does your FBO offer... and how many different syllabi do you go off of at your FBO?

Just wondering... ;)

Bob
 
There is no doubt in my mind that if you have a 3000 hour pilot from an FBO, and a 3000 hour pilot from a school like ATP, or whatever, that you will not see a bit of difference in them. The difference is going to be in the 250 hour guy that started as a private pilot, and then said, "What the heck, I'll get an airline job." and the 250 hour guy that went to a major school, and from day one knew he was going to the right seat of an airliner. It is a mindset thing more than anything else.

We hired someone with several thousand hours recently that just about got washed out because all of his time was in non-complex airspace, not talking to ATC, and presumably not using checklists. He did fine flying the airplane, but all of the other stuff (getting ATIS, clearance, taxi communications, ramp communications, etc.) just overwhelmed him.

Where do you see anyone with 3000 hours out of the academy? The academies just sift the students through the program and kick them out with pieces of paper that says they could fly while retaining all of their life savings :) And that guy with several thousands hours who can't talk to atc, that must have been an extreme case of someone who flew a crop duster for thousands of hours and then decided to go airline.
Anyway, my point is...250 hours might or might not mean much because it could have been a quality time or just burning holes in the sky. Now, I know academies have a program and every hour is pretty much aimed at doing something constructive, but that doesn't mean that someone coming from ma and pa fbo was only burning holes in the sky and didn't learn anything. There is no telling if academy folks or fbo folks are better, that's why there are checkrides and different kinds of tests to filter the candidates. You can't just say "oh, this guy is better, he's from atp" that's bull. There are better schools and worse schools just as there are students with better learning abilities and the ones that are slower, any generalization is just coming from one's personal experience such as yours :)
 
I see your point. And going into this I actually thought about how going the fast track route might hurt my chances of actually absorbing everything there was to know about flight, but at the time I was told that this was the time to get into this industry "now" not "2 years from now", because of the hiring boom and such. Now that I see this is not the case anymore it may make sense to take my time... Looks like I got more to think about... Good thing that I did not plop dow the $1950 non refundable deposite on ATP like I was going to last week. :) Thanks
 
Well, here are my thoughts. You have a wife and kid(s) at home. Here are a couple of questions to ask yourself: What kind of money does your wife make and is it enough to support us? Is your family going to be affected by initial low pay (22-25K a year) and the possibility of being furloughed? Will your wife resent the fact that you are on the road 3 or 4 days (or more) at a time? Will she support you if you need to move halfway across the country away from friends and family or will she mind you spending an extra 4-5-6 unpaid days away from home commuting? Does you family have the ENTIRE picture in front of them? I think almost everyone who has been involved in commercial aviation (airline flying especially) for more than 10 years has experienced being furloughed or a reduction of pay (having to change jobs) or at least been REALLY close to it. Are ALL of you ready to make that kind of commitment?

NOT all doom and gloom...huh? :) In all seriousness though I think you make some great points and pose some good questions. And fortunately I already have the answers for all off them :rawk:. Before I made my final decision my wife and I (and the kids on a few occasions, they are only 4 and 6 afterall) spent days going over different scenarios, planning for the worst and hoping for the average type of a thing. I think we now have about a 1/3 of a notebook filled up with just our budget plan... And I can really say that I have the BEST and most supportive wife and family in the whole world. They know we are in for some tough times ahead (my 6 year old even offered me his piggy bank to pay for school :D), but I know that they are behind this 150%, otherwise I would not even dream of doing it. And I did some research on the downsides of this career and did not sugar coat anything in our disscusions. As far as reduction in pay I am not new to this field, the company I work for now downsized about 60% of their employees in the last year and I was one of the lucky few that got to take a 25% pay cut instead... I am not ready to give up on this, and will continue to hope for the best, the only other choice I really have is stay here in my office and wait till my number is called, and I would sure rather be up in the clouds even if that means I am only flying around a photographer...
 
Back
Top