"if you graduated from ATP or some local FBO. I know i hear a lot of people saying that it does not, but I'm not sure how this can be. In a non flying world if you graduated from Harvard or some local community college would have an insane differance on where you got hired, is this not true for the airline industry?"
ATP is simply a place to get the ratings fast at a premium price. Don't think of it as "Harvard". You're reading too much into their website. You could easily end up a better pilot by taking your time at an FBO. But you say you don't have the time. So I guess it's a tough choice.
Moving up in the biz has nothing to do with where you trained. It's about hours, ratings, and experience levels.
Hi Don. Overall, I agree with you that an FBO pilot
can get the same training that someone would get at a major flight school. But there are a few reasons that companies look favorably upon the major schools vs. mom and pop FBO.
1. Major schools are more structured, in general, and provide a more consistent product that is less dependent upon individual motivation. Instructors teach students that are goal oriented to getting into the airlines, not just being a private pilot, so structure is taught from the beginning. (Yes, it should be taught anyway, but it often isn't.)
2. Major schools provide more tailored training directed at airline-type operations, and that helps low-time individuals do better in training at the airlines. When you are hiring a low-time pilot (I just interviewed a 300 hour pilot!), that guy has to be on top of his game to make it through training. The major schools, for whatever reason, produce people who have historically done better in training if they are low time.
3. Students are at FBO's to get a private certificates, for the most part. They don't know any professional pilots, and aren't surrounded by people with the goal of being in the industry.
4. Instructors at FBOs are highly variable. Some are awesome. Some aren't. Instructors at major universities are generally standardized once a year, and are at least ON AVERAGE, a more known quantity.
There is no doubt in my mind that if you have a 3000 hour pilot from an FBO, and a 3000 hour pilot from a school like ATP, or whatever, that you will not see a bit of difference in them. The difference is going to be in the 250 hour guy that started as a private pilot, and then said, "What the heck, I'll get an airline job." and the 250 hour guy that went to a major school, and from day one knew he was going to the right seat of an airliner. It is a mindset thing more than anything else.
We hired someone with several thousand hours recently that just about got washed out because all of his time was in non-complex airspace, not talking to ATC, and presumably not using checklists. He did fine flying the airplane, but all of the other stuff (getting ATIS, clearance, taxi communications, ramp communications, etc.) just overwhelmed him.
Re-reading your post, I see that you said moving up in the biz, and I agree 100% with that. Once you have your starting airline job, it is more about experience and hours than anything else. But sometimes it does matter at a regional if you don't have much experience and few hours.
My .02 anyway.
