Accepting "Direct to.." when filed /A

I can't provide a specific FAR that says you shall use electronic navigation.
There aren't any. There are rules of certification of electronic equipment if you use it, but no rule actually requiring you to use electronic equipment.
Examples often used are going direct in uncontrolled airspace where electronic equipment isn't available. Of course, this doesn't require a clearance, but you do have to file. Another real life small airplane example is in getting off of a vor airway direct to a beacon, and the beacon is just a little bit out of range. DR until you pick up the beacon. Ever done that? Well, you can plan to do that. IFR.

We used to triangulate 2 vor's continuously to go direct. That was b4 radr and such. But it's still legal.


Understood.. and triangulation of VORs is understood as well.

I'm going on previous experience in an IFR environment in a /A aircraft. On an arrival we were turned off, then later told to "proceed to direct to fix XXXXX". At that particular point of origin, there was no charted NAVAID based reference to the fix. Our standard reply was "unable, /A". Did it all the time.

I think that's where my belief that DR was impossible in an IFR environment came up.
 
Understood.. and triangulation of VORs is understood as well.

I'm going on previous experience in an IFR environment in a /A aircraft. On an arrival we were turned off, then later told to "proceed to direct to fix XXXXX". At that particular point of origin, there was no charted NAVAID based reference to the fix. Our standard reply was "unable, /A". Did it all the time.

I think that's where my belief that DR was impossible in an IFR environment came up.

As previously stated, up until a few years ago, the military was big on teaching fix-to-fix navigation. However the FAA has recently came down that it's not an accurate enough means to navigate point to point in a DR sense for IFR nav these days.
 
As previously stated, up until a few years ago, the military was big on teaching fix-to-fix navigation. However the FAA has recently came down that it's not an accurate enough means to navigate point to point in a DR sense for IFR nav these days.

You know,

I think if we were better at it, that might not have happened. It kind of got to the point where the only ones who were practicing it were guys in pilot training (i.e. guys who were not very good at it). The IP's were pretty descent at it, in general, but the airplanes still wandered around because guys would let their students go too far. Too many guys were late to intervene because they wanted to give their students a chance to demonstrate the skill.

In most of the rest of the fleet, there were capabilities that made it a redundant skill (INS, GPS, a navigator, all of the above), which means that once folks left pilot training they never practiced it again except when they lost equipment.

The result? Well, no one was very good at it because no one practiced it. I don't know that the method itself was inaccurate... I think it was just that we were not that great at it (most of us). In five years of tanker flying before going back to teach pilot training, I only had to do it once (when an FMS queer-tron made the system go Tango Uniform for a half hour in Korea).

Of course, now that we're in the era of GATM and MNPS airspace, and RNP and all that, I can see that it is not accurate enough for those areas... but I think as a method it is still accurate enough for "regular" IFR flying, if we're proficient. Of course, as you point out it is illegal, so I wouldn't do it anyway unless I were suffering a problem. Kind of a shame that we don't really teach it anymore, though.
 
You can't dead reackon IFR until you show it in an IFR certified panel. You can't assure terrain clearances IFR without charts you can plot on. Chicken or egg- pick one.

avweb.com/news/system/183203-1.html

"In certain mountainous areas, airways are established beyond usable navaid limits and a gap is shown on the chart where dead-reckoning or some other form of navigation is needed."

I think I have beaten this subject to death, but if you still think you can't DR IFR, here is yet another independant source.

I actually was thinking the debate would be over by now.
 
avweb.com/news/system/183203-1.html

"In certain mountainous areas, airways are established beyond usable navaid limits and a gap is shown on the chart where dead-reckoning or some other form of navigation is needed."

I think I have beaten this subject to death, but if you still think you can't DR IFR, here is yet another independant source.

I actually was thinking the debate would be over by now.

Bear with us. Some of us (me especially) can be thick skulled. It might help if you consider us students rather than debate opponents. I'm certainly not trying to 'win' anything in this particular thread. :beer:

FWIW, I'm looking at IFR nav with renewed interest in the technicalities. A little back-to-basics never hurts.
 
I think I have beaten this subject to death, but if you still think you can't DR IFR, here is yet another independant source.

I actually was thinking the debate would be over by now.

Another example (that I do somewhat frequently) is flying through the KTPA Bravo on an IFR clearance. The clearance is typically "9/27 transition, report KTPA RWY in sight" then after passing it "resume own navigation direct..." And I'm not usually /G...

I guess you could argue that clearance is really via RV's, but I don't think so.
 
Back
Top