Accepting "Direct to.." when filed /A

We did this all the time /U. As long as we can reliably check our position with VORs once an hour, and remained within the service volumes of said VORs, then we can go direct. Heck, I even filed DIRECT unless going into some place like MDW. We just put in the remarks VFR GPS, and 99% of the time we were "Cleared as filed."

It was in our Ops Specs that we could navigate en route under Class II navigation. I didn't see anything wrong with that!
 
i think it goes back to my original post in this thread regarding going direct to a fix. MEA gap or not.
:beer:

With ya now. I just wasn't sure why RADAR was needed for an MEA gap. I'm all caught up now. Back to your originally scheduled debate.

-mini
 
I'm not doubting you, but could you please show me a an airway with a gap of up to 65 miles in a non radar environment that requires dead reckoning to a FIX? Again not doubting...I just would like to see how this is charted.

You can see how this is charted on the Jepps by opening the Indroduction page and turning to page 56. You can see the "MEA Gap" symbol on many airways out west and in Canada. These can extend up to 65 miles, and how wide the gap can be is dependant on altitude. The chart does not tell you how wide the gap is, only that it may be up to 65 miles up at higher altitudes.

As we all know, areas of radar coverage are not shown on charts, nor are the gap distances. So finding you a spot with a 65 mile gap and no radar coverage would be impossible for me to do.

Whether or not you are in an area of radar coverage is irrelevent. A previous poster had mentioned that you must either be on a radar vector, or receiving a nav aid. I mentioned a situation where Dead Reckoning is not only permitted, but often required.
 
I'm not doubting you, but could you please show me a an airway with a gap of up to 65 miles in a non radar environment that requires dead reckoning to a FIX? Again not doubting...I just would like to see how this is charted.

Now that I re-read your post, I see you are asking about dead reckoning to a FIX. If there is a bend in the airway that coincides with the MEA gap, you would be dead reckoning to a FIX. You would have to calculate when to turn using dead reckoning.

I can't show you one of these in a non radar environment for the previously mentioned reasons. Nor do I know if any of these currently exist in the US. It is an example of how you can legally dead reckon IFR to a fix.

An MEA gap usually does not occur where there is a bend in an airway. (read that to mean it MAY occur where there is a bend)

Again getting sidetracked. But the entire point of my post was to show that Deadreckoning is sometimes required, and permitted.
 
We did this all the time /U. As long as we can reliably check our position with VORs once an hour, and remained within the service volumes of said VORs, then we can go direct. Heck, I even filed DIRECT unless going into some place like MDW. We just put in the remarks VFR GPS, and 99% of the time we were "Cleared as filed."

It was in our Ops Specs that we could navigate en route under Class II navigation. I didn't see anything wrong with that!

That sounds about right to me.
 
Now that I re-read your post, I see you are asking about dead reckoning to a FIX. If there is a bend in the airway that coincides with the MEA gap, you would be dead reckoning to a FIX. You would have to calculate when to turn using dead reckoning.

I can't show you one of these in a non radar environment for the previously mentioned reasons. Nor do I know if any of these currently exist in the US. It is an example of how you can legally dead reckon IFR to a fix.

An MEA gap usually does not occur where there is a bend in an airway. (read that to mean it MAY occur where there is a bend)

Again getting sidetracked. But the entire point of my post was to show that Deadreckoning is sometimes required, and permitted.


I'm still not sold on this. Can you provide a reference in the FARs or a real world example?
 
I'm still not sold on this. Can you provide a reference in the FARs or a real world example?

What are you not sold on? The fact that you can legally Dead Reckon when IFR?

I already said I don't know of an MEA gap that has a bend. There are publications out there that say that a MEA gap USUALLY does not have a bend, that implies that it MAY have a bend in some locations.

Now if you want an example of an MEA gap that may require Dead Reckoning, I can find you several. That was the point of my previous post, to show where and when you may need to Dead Reckon when IFR.
 
What are you not sold on? The fact that you can legally Dead Reckon when IFR?

I already said I don't know of an MEA gap that has a bend. There are publications out there that say that a MEA gap USUALLY does not have a bend, that implies that it MAY have a bend in some locations.

Now if you want an example of an MEA gap that may require Dead Reckoning, I can find you several. That was the point of my previous post, to show where and when you may need to Dead Reckon when IFR.

That was my point- I'm not sold on the dead reckoning if IFR concept. To the best of my knowledge, this isn't something that's legal in the sense you seem to be conveying it. I'm asking for outside reference to clarify.

I know you gave a hypothetical example previously, but unless you can provide a real world illustration, that doesn't help me much.

To be blunt, I guess I'm asking you to "show me where it says that in the book." I don't agree, otherwise.
 
That was my point- I'm not sold on the dead reckoning if IFR concept. To the best of my knowledge, this isn't something that's legal in the sense you seem to be conveying it. I'm asking for outside reference to clarify.

I know you gave a hypothetical example previously, but unless you can provide a real world illustration, that doesn't help me much.

To be blunt, I guess I'm asking you to "show me where it says that in the book." I don't agree, otherwise.

Here are two independant sources...

1. http://www.whittsflying.com/web/page7.36IFR_Missed_Approaches.htm#IFR Dead Reckoning
IFR Dead Reckoning
FAR 61.65(b)(2) required instrument pilots to be instructed in DR.
--DR is required for non-radar transitions to final approach
--DR is required in doing holding patterns
--DR is required in a non-precision approach when a navaid does not define to missed approach point.
--DR can legally be used on an IFR flight that extends beyond the "service volume" (range) of a navaid.
--Such flight can be initiated by either pilot or controller.
--Radar monitoring will be provided.
--DR provides situational awareness which should be augmented by a time and distance log record of the flight.


2. Page 95. "Everything Explained for the Professional Pilot" by Richie Lengel
"It is legal to use dead reckoning for portions of any IFR flight."


In addition, as I explained before, going through an MEA gap without Rnav, by definition will require DR. Remember that GPS is a relatively new device. Aircraft used to DR through MEA gaps all the time before everybody had a GPS. There is nothing prohibiting you from going through an MEA gap without Rnav. You can find plenty of MEA gaps in Utah, Montana, much of Canada.
 
Here are two independant sources...

1. http://www.whittsflying.com/web/page7.36IFR_Missed_Approaches.htm#IFR Dead Reckoning
IFR Dead Reckoning
FAR 61.65(b)(2) required instrument pilots to be instructed in DR.
--DR is required for non-radar transitions to final approach
--DR is required in doing holding patterns
--DR is required in a non-precision approach when a navaid does not define to missed approach point.
--DR can legally be used on an IFR flight that extends beyond the "service volume" (range) of a navaid.
--Such flight can be initiated by either pilot or controller.
--Radar monitoring will be provided.
--DR provides situational awareness which should be augmented by a time and distance log record of the flight.


2. Page 95. "Everything Explained for the Professional Pilot" by Richie Lengel
"It is legal to use dead reckoning for portions of any IFR flight."


In addition, as I explained before, going through an MEA gap without Rnav, by definition will require DR. Remember that GPS is a relatively new device. Aircraft used to DR through MEA gaps all the time before everybody had a GPS. There is nothing prohibiting you from going through an MEA gap without Rnav. You can find plenty of MEA gaps in Utah, Montana, much of Canada.


Ahhhh. Well I'll be doggone.

I stand corrected. Never had to use this myself, obviously. Guess that's where the fallacy in my knowledge base crept in. I appreciate you taking the time to dig up all that data. Cheers. :beer:
 
Here are two independant sources...

1. http://www.whittsflying.com/web/page7.36IFR_Missed_Approaches.htm#IFR Dead Reckoning
IFR Dead Reckoning
FAR 61.65(b)(2) required instrument pilots to be instructed in DR.
--DR is required for non-radar transitions to final approach
--DR is required in doing holding patterns
--DR is required in a non-precision approach when a navaid does not define to missed approach point.
--DR can legally be used on an IFR flight that extends beyond the "service volume" (range) of a navaid.
--Such flight can be initiated by either pilot or controller.
--Radar monitoring will be provided.
--DR provides situational awareness which should be augmented by a time and distance log record of the flight.


2. Page 95. "Everything Explained for the Professional Pilot" by Richie Lengel
"It is legal to use dead reckoning for portions of any IFR flight."


In addition, as I explained before, going through an MEA gap without Rnav, by definition will require DR. Remember that GPS is a relatively new device. Aircraft used to DR through MEA gaps all the time before everybody had a GPS. There is nothing prohibiting you from going through an MEA gap without Rnav. You can find plenty of MEA gaps in Utah, Montana, much of Canada.

I saw the page in "everything explained for the professional pilot" while trying to answer this same question but could not find anything in the regs until you pointed it out! Thanks! I was on your side all along.

Here's what I do: never say unable to center- I've learned they don't like that. I ask them for a 'recommended heading' but usually give them a heading in the same transmission.

Center: Cleared direct XXX
Me (looking at my 396): N12345 requesting a heading of 080 (or whatever), direct when able.
Center: N12345 fly heading 080 cleared direct XXX when able.

Truth be told: I don't think the FAA or ATC gives a darn unless somehow you screw up to the point of being dangerous. Center guys do not care as long as you keep it easy for them.
 
You can't dead reackon IFR until you show it in an IFR certified panel. You can't assure terrain clearances IFR without charts you can plot on. Chicken or egg- pick one.
 
Ahhhh. Well I'll be doggone.

I stand corrected. Never had to use this myself, obviously. Guess that's where the fallacy in my knowledge base crept in. I appreciate you taking the time to dig up all that data. Cheers. :beer:
www.remember3407project.org

I'm starting to see why we need stiffer requirements for entry. Maybe for recurrent training as well or would you not support that?
 
You can't dead reackon IFR until you show it in an IFR certified panel. You can't assure terrain clearances IFR without charts you can plot on. Chicken or egg- pick one.

Good point. Perhaps that while Dead Reckoning can in fact be used for IFR nav there are cases when it's a potential pitfall. I've never used (or needed) pure DR without a navaid reference to the best of my knowledge.
 
You can't dead reackon IFR until you show it in an IFR certified panel. You can't assure terrain clearances IFR without charts you can plot on. Chicken or egg- pick one.

I hate to keep bringing up the MEA Gap example, but I use it because it is such a clear and cut example of using DR when flying IFR.

You are suggesting that anyone who has ever crossed an MEA Gap without Rnav, has done so illegally.
 
I hate to keep bringing up the MEA Gap example, but I use it because it is such a clear and cut example of using DR when flying IFR.

You are suggesting that anyone who has ever crossed an MEA Gap without Rnav, has done so illegally.

DR actually works pretty well if you fly your headings and speeds precisely.
 
I'm still not sold on this. Can you provide a reference in the FARs or a real world example?
I can't provide a specific FAR that says you shall use electronic navigation.
There aren't any. There are rules of certification of electronic equipment if you use it, but no rule actually requiring you to use electronic equipment.
Examples often used are going direct in uncontrolled airspace where electronic equipment isn't available. Of course, this doesn't require a clearance, but you do have to file. Another real life small airplane example is in getting off of a vor airway direct to a beacon, and the beacon is just a little bit out of range. DR until you pick up the beacon. Ever done that? Well, you can plan to do that. IFR.

We used to triangulate 2 vor's continuously to go direct. That was b4 radr and such. But it's still legal.
 
Back
Top