Accepting "Direct to.." when filed /A

I know this isn't really the same thing being solely /A. When I was doing my instrument rating, we filed /U or /A from time to time to try and simulate flying without the G1000000. Sometimes DTW Apprch would recognize our tail number, ignore that we're currently /U or /A and try to give us direct because he/she "knows we're /G." We just had to politely decline and ask for a routing using radials. PITA, but why cheat?
 
Not true at all...we often get DITCH well North of the radial and that night we were. I centered the CDI and we were on the 292.

I have to ask which runway were you using that night? The 292 radial puts you 3 miles NORTH of KPHL.

I have never seen a DITCH departure run north of the airport. It has to go south before it can go east. Otherwise you are going right into the arrivals if they are using the 27's or right into the departure path if they are using the 9's.

Again, I am not saying that you could go directly to DITCH from where you were, but usually the controller drops you off close enough to the 274 radial that you can.
 
I have to ask which runway were you using that night? The 292 radial puts you 3 miles NORTH of KPHL.

I have never seen a DITCH departure run north of the airport. It has to go south before it can go east. Otherwise you are going right into the arrivals if they are using the 27's or right into the departure path if they are using the 9's.

Again, I am not saying that you could go directly to DITCH from where you were, but usually the controller drops you off close enough to the 274 radial that you can.

:rolleyes: RWY 27L, left turn to 200 heading, then about 2 miles out we often get another left turn around to 030 vector for climb to 8 or 9 thousand. You don't seem to know the airspace that well. The CYN 274 radial if continued past ALBEK would be approximately 13 miles SOUTH of PHL... When we get that NE vector from Dep we are already NORTH of the radial...I've only done this about 1000 times in the Dash.

You're not around here a lot so let me give you some advice. Never apply your narrow window of experience to the experiences of others. Lots of different pilots here flying lots of different types for lots of different carriers. PHL TRACON does lots of different things depending on what you are flying and your type of operation. If you fly a jet, welcome to the world of turboprop operations...for us, non-standard is standard.
 
No. VFR or IFR or not, while you can get to that exact point in space, you're not doing it with panel installed, certified navigation equipment on board the aircraft. Without proper tolerance certification, accepting something as precise as 'direct to a FIX' becomes an approximation at least to some degree.

Accepting a direct routing to a fix with uncertified equipment sounds like it would walk all over a few FARs.
Thing is, the FARs are directed towards the equipment. IF you use electronic equipment to navigate by, it must meet certain electronic standards, but the FARs do not require you to use an electronic navigation device. If you file an airway, then you must have a current vor receiver, but if you file direct to point a, how you get there is your responsibility. You must stay within 4 nm either side of centerline of your cleared route. It is up to you, the pilot to accept or reject a direct clearance. Can you navigate it on a heading for a few miles?
 
:rolleyes: RWY 27L, left turn to 200 heading, then about 2 miles out we often get another left turn around to 030 vector for climb to 8 or 9 thousand. You don't seem to know the airspace that well. The CYN 274 radial if continued past ALBEK would be approximately 13 miles SOUTH of PHL... When we get that NE vector from Dep we are already NORTH of the radial...I've only done this about 1000 times in the Dash.

You're right. Could I see the Flight Aware ground track of this flight? I have never seen PHL vector someone up to the 292 radial before sending them to DITCH.
 
You have never seen it? Really...wow..my mistake, I must have been dreaming then. Imagine, the nerve of those pesky PHL TRACON guys doing something that smig has never seen before...what has the world come to.
 
Thing is, the FARs are directed towards the equipment. IF you use electronic equipment to navigate by, it must meet certain electronic standards, but the FARs do not require you to use an electronic navigation device. If you file an airway, then you must have a current vor receiver, but if you file direct to point a, how you get there is your responsibility. You must stay within 4 nm either side of centerline of your cleared route. It is up to you, the pilot to accept or reject a direct clearance. Can you navigate it on a heading for a few miles?
We're generally not talking about a few miles. My last direct to airport clearance while /U (not even /A) was about 125 miles. It's doubtful most of us could navigate that far by dead reckoning alone in any but the most perfect of conditions (unless, of course, most of us are Charles Lindbergh ;) ).

But the theory of those who say it's just fine to use a handheld GPS point to a similar (but not the same) concept as you do - that the only requirement with regard to equipment is about installed equipment. Other than that, as you say, "how you get there is your responsibility." And a handheld isn't installed.

That's not my view of it. Just presenting the argument that is being made by some others.
 
I have had the similar problem in the 727 with an inop UNS-1. The controllers were very annoyed we couldn't do direct to a point 400 miles in front of us. All I did was asked them for heading and direct when able. They finally seemed happy with that and adjusted our heading as needed until we were within range of the VOR.

IMO you were technically correct in not accepting the clearance. Chances are if you were only a degree or two off the airway you could slide over to airway and find the fix. The only problem happens is if seperation was lost or FAA started looking and questioned how you went direct to an intersection without RNAV.
 
You have never seen it? Really...wow..my mistake, I must have been dreaming then. Imagine, the nerve of those pesky PHL TRACON guys doing something that smig has never seen before...what has the world come to.

Nope, never. But I will when you show me the flight aware ground track.
 
We're generally not talking about a few miles. My last direct to airport clearance while /U (not even /A) was about 125 miles. It's doubtful most of us could navigate that far by dead reckoning alone in any but the most perfect of conditions (unless, of course, most of us are Charles Lindbergh ;) ).

I guess this is why we don't have navigators on airplanes anymore! (the Colonel at my first unit in the USAF was a navigator)

Anyway, it is certainly possible to navigate point-to-point accurately without RNAV. We all did it getting even PPL's pre-GPS. I could find my position on a sectional with just a single VOR receiver in about 15 seconds back then. I think these skills have just fallen into disuse for most of us.

I remember thinking how cool it was having LORAN when I learned how to fly ;)
 
Thing is, the FARs are directed towards the equipment. IF you use electronic equipment to navigate by, it must meet certain electronic standards, but the FARs do not require you to use an electronic navigation device. If you file an airway, then you must have a current vor receiver, but if you file direct to point a, how you get there is your responsibility. You must stay within 4 nm either side of centerline of your cleared route. It is up to you, the pilot to accept or reject a direct clearance. Can you navigate it on a heading for a few miles?

Right.. but direct to a point by pilotage, i.e., with no electronic equipment.. that's one thing. It's VFR.

If you're navigating under IFR... you're either
A) Accepting a vector...
or..
B) Navigating by reference to an electronic navigation device.

So in IFR, if you can't operate within the confines of a specific navigation requirement... you no go.
 
I used to get "Direct TTN" as soon as i checked on 23.8 from RDG or LNS all the time as /u. They always seemed dumbfounded when I said "unable"
 
I guess this is why we don't have navigators on airplanes anymore! (the Colonel at my first unit in the USAF was a navigator)

Anyway, it is certainly possible to navigate point-to-point accurately without RNAV. We all did it getting even PPL's pre-GPS. I could find my position on a sectional with just a single VOR receiver in about 15 seconds back then. I think these skills have just fallen into disuse for most of us.

I remember thinking how cool it was having LORAN when I learned how to fly ;)

You not VFR though. The Phil 8 in an IFR departure and you are on an IFR flight plan.
 

Attachments

or...
C) Dead Reckoning.
Would you trust your dead reckoning abilities in IMC in a non radar environment? I guess the better question is would you trust the reported winds aloft?

This seems like it has turned into a pendantic discussion. Can someone navigate direct to a fix without some form of RNAV? Sure! Is someone going to do it in the soup? No.
 
Would you trust your dead reckoning abilities in IMC in a non radar environment? I guess the better question is would you trust the reported winds aloft?

This seems like it has turned into a pendantic discussion. Can someone navigate direct to a fix without some form of RNAV? Sure! Is someone going to do it in the soup? No.
Dead Reckoning is REQUIRED when IFR, without Rnav, through a MEA Gap. There are gaps on airways up to 65 miles that you get no nav signal at all.
 
I guess this is why we don't have navigators on airplanes anymore! (the Colonel at my first unit in the USAF was a navigator)

Anyway, it is certainly possible to navigate point-to-point accurately without RNAV. We all did it getting even PPL's pre-GPS. I could find my position on a sectional with just a single VOR receiver in about 15 seconds back then. I think these skills have just fallen into disuse for most of us.
I think there's a slight difference between finding your place on a sectional periodically (I had to do that under the hood on my private ride and could do it today) and the workload associated with either flying long distances or in the high-workload environment of an approach (where 15 seconds can be a long, long time) using that as the exclusive method of staying on course.
 
Dead Reckoning is REQUIRED when IFR, without Rnav, through a MEA Gap. There are gaps on airways up to 65 miles that you get no nav signal at all.
I'm not doubting you, but could you please show me a an airway with a gap of up to 65 miles in a non radar environment that requires dead reckoning to a FIX? Again not doubting...I just would like to see how this is charted.
 
I'm not doubting you, but could you please show me a an airway with a gap of up to 65 miles in a non radar environment that requires dead reckoning to a FIX? Again not doubting...I just would like to see how this is charted.
What does RADAR have to do with it?

-mini
 
Back
Top