Who thinks IFR in a single engine is crazy?

I think bdhill1979 (AKA Uncle Rico) was referring to the mountains specifically in his home state. But to add to our mountain flying discussion - I've flown over the mountains of Utah (10,000+') and had a little white knuckles doing such. I've also flown over some not so big mountains (3-5000') with much more confidence. Flying at 15-17,000', I have a few more options available to me over the smaller mountains that I do flying a few thousand feet above the MEA.
Utah, Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, Colorado, parts of Nevada, and Arizona are the mountains that I have flown over and am referring to. The MEAs around here start at 11000 feet, most are 13000+. The majority of this terrain is outside the capabilities of the average Single engine airplane to safely traverse.

If it is IMC around here it is either:
1. Wicked Icing conditions
2. Wicked Convective conditions


When did I become Uncle Rico? I'm honored

I personally teach my students to be prepared at any moment, for anything. This is that concept of staying ahead of the airplane. ;)
No kidding. I have two simple rules about this business.

1. Don't trust anybody
2. #### is going to happen any second now.


Equipment, ability, and legality don't always equate to the best decision. I've seen this happen a dozen or so times in 121 flying where a MEL allows the plane to legally but the PIC decided for one reason or another, the flight shouldn't be done. Notice shouldn't, not couldn't.

This is any PIC's prerogative regardless of 91, 121, or 135 flying. I always try to emphasize to my students the responsibility of being the PIC of any aircraft. There is a little phrase I use that seems appropriate for this discussion... "Legality is sometimes just a little different than reality" ;)
Just a simple "Word" is all that needs.
 
I look at SE IFR as kind of like a game of russian roulette depending on the variables. Are you flying with an engine that is close to or over TBO? Are the ceilings 400 or less? In my neck of the woods your chances of popping out of the deck and hitting a field would be a lot better than someone on the east coast or a more populated area, but the thought of only having 10-20 seconds to find something other than a tree, lake or house to hit is a little worrysome.
 
You guys are bored! :)

I remember when I'd stack couch cushions and make a fort. Now kids head straight for the internets and post polls!
 
Any idiot that launches into an IMC night in a single is a frigging moron.

End of story.


Depends on the single , depends on the moron..............no but seriously it depends on how comfortable the particular "moron" is with his plane.
 
I look at SE IFR as kind of like a game of russian roulette depending on the variables. Are you flying with an engine that is close to or over TBO? Are the ceilings 400 or less? In my neck of the woods your chances of popping out of the deck and hitting a field would be a lot better than someone on the east coast or a more populated area, but the thought of only having 10-20 seconds to find something other than a tree, lake or house to hit is a little worrysome.

:yeahthat:

My thoughts exactly.... Still pretty dissapointed in the poll results, I see quite a few more have said its no problem at all, without hesitation.... And only a couple have said its crazy talk...
 
I see quite a few more have said its no problem at all, without hesitation.... And only a couple have said its crazy talk...

Yes, I'd do it.

Yes, I know I'm screwed if my engine dies on me.

But the odds are greater that I'd kill myself instead of the engine doing it for me.

Should I just not fly at night, period? After all, if my engine quits on me, I'm screwed, right?

Should I just not fly, period? I fly around densely populated areas. There are all sorts of things to hit if my engine dies on me, day or night. Finding a place to put the plane down if the engine dies may be a problem.

There are risks inherent to flying. Sure, we should minimize them as much as we can but we cannot eliminate them.

The risk of an engine failure is so much smaller than the risk of me doing something to kill myself so it doesn't factor into my thinking.

I'm more worried about what I do than what the engine will do.

And isn't that really all I can control? What I do?
 
No, but there are certainly things you can do to help improve your safety. Flying single engine piston airplanes at night is kinda in the same boat, but we've all done it. I feel that if you limit if to a clear night, and do you best to keep within gliding distance of airports, you significantly improve your survival chances if something does happen. I understand we have to pick out battles, but better safe than sorry.
 
All of my flight experience comes from an extremely flat Florida.

So my obvious answer is 'No Problem'.

If you want to throw in mountainous terrain, I'd think about it a little harder. But still probably say 'No Problem' with sufficient planning and preparation.
 
that is just ridiculous!... how can you even question the capability of an (IFR Certified Aircraft) in IFR Conditions... That simply doesnt make sense.
If something is IFR Certified, its because it has been proven it can SAFETLY manage its way trough IFR conditions. (Given that the pilot is IFR rated).
IF you take your plane and exceed its Pre-define limits (or your limits), wether it being IFR or VFR, now... THATS CRAZY!..
My 2 Cents..
 
If you want to throw in mountainous terrain, I'd think about it a little harder. But still probably say 'No Problem' with sufficient planning and preparation.

I agree. Sometimes it is IFR coming out of TUS at night because the desert is so black, especially on moonless nights, regardless of what the stated flying conditions are. I fly into SAN, SBA, and LAX frequently. It is not uncommon for the marine layer to require IFR. Mountainous terrain would add another complicating and dangerous factor, especially due to convection and wind. Realizing one's limitations, based upon experience and available equipment, decreases risk.
 
Yes, I'd do it.

Yes, I know I'm screwed if my engine dies on me.

But the odds are greater that I'd kill myself instead of the engine doing it for me.

Should I just not fly at night, period? After all, if my engine quits on me, I'm screwed, right?

Should I just not fly, period? I fly around densely populated areas. There are all sorts of things to hit if my engine dies on me, day or night. Finding a place to put the plane down if the engine dies may be a problem.

There are risks inherent to flying. Sure, we should minimize them as much as we can but we cannot eliminate them.

The risk of an engine failure is so much smaller than the risk of me doing something to kill myself so it doesn't factor into my thinking.

I'm more worried about what I do than what the engine will do.

And isn't that really all I can control? What I do?

I am with Tony on this one.

As I mentioned, I fly a glass C182 now and find it very easy to fly in hard IFR conditions. Statistically speaking, it's not the engine issue that will get me. It's some stupid mistake I'll make as the pilot.

I posed this question sometime ago but, what about corporate and charter operators flying turbine singles like the PC-12, Meridian, C208, and TBM? I personally know outfits that fly these aircraft in the flight levels in hardcore IFR, over the Rockies, at night.

Is that anymore crazy that a high powered piston?
 
I never had an engine failure, but in 1600 or so hours of single flying I have had three complete electrical failures; one in a new aircraft. For that reason, unless I have an aircraft with some redundancy in the electrical system I would not fly low IFR in a piston single. I have no problem doing it with sufficient cloud heights and visibility that would allow me to get underneath and fly VFR with reasonable margins (I think my personal min was always 800OVC & 3SM over flatland).

Just imagine having low IFR conditions across an entire region (not uncommon in New England), and losing all navigational equipment. Even with a hand held VHF & GPS on board, that is not something I want to test myself with.
 
Back
Top