Plane crash in Compton, CA

While you all were bickering over whether this is relevant to the board, this was posted and nobody noticed it:

The house that was hit belongs to my God parents. Every body that was in the house is doing better than they could be given the circumstances.

GlideSlope, I'm very glad to hear that.
 
Originally Posted by darrenf
I think the only thing that will water down this site is people telling others that they should not post this or should not post that. If someone has to constantly worry whether something they post is going to cause them grief, then they are less likely to post, and that cannot be positive for our community. No matter what is said, it is bound to upset SOMEONE, so you cannot let that stop you, otherwise you may as well just be a lurker, and when everyone does that, then where is our beloved JC?? As far as crashes being an appropriate topic, of course they are. It's yet another part of flying, not a pleasant part, but a part non-the-less. When someone posts a message about a plane that crashed, then another user realizes they just flew that same plane last week, it causes us all to keep our awareness up a little, and maybe it will cause someone to catch a safety issue they might otherwise have missed. How can that be bad?


Excellent post, Darrenf. By the way, I read both IFR and IFR Refresher. IFR posts situations that have occurred with instrumented rated pilots with the intent to identify, evaluate, and learn from the experiences of others. Why is posting incidents of crashes, accidents, or errors on this site any different than reading one of those magazines?

To tell someone to go to NTSB reports is fine; guess if I wish to see pilot photos, videos, and flying experiences, is there a recommendation not to come to Jetcareers but to go to other websites such as Flight Level 350 or Airliners.net?

If I wish to receive information on airline interviews, is someone going to beg me off Jetcareers in favor of another website.

I do understand the perspective of asking the question about why. . .it seems a little shortsighted. It definitely got answered satisfactorily in MY opinion.

Well, perhaps a separate category for "incidents/accidents" would be beneficial to those interested in those posts. I agree that discussion of an incident/accident is indeed educational and valuable. Those posts that are of a first hand account offer the best information naturally. It's the posts that quote nothing more than a news account that contain very little valuable information.

:yeahthat: too!
 
I sort of agree with Toonces, although his wording really wasn't that great.

There are multiple plane crashes every day, and normally the way they are reported is doom and gloom (and lots of inaccuracy). I completly understand posting a crash that happened near where you live, to somebody you know, to an airplane you've flown, are has some other unique circumstance. But just your everyday, garden variety crash? Eh, I don't buy it.

But, as was already said, nobody is forcing me to read/reply to threads.


Someone is in 'airplane go boom denial' :banghead:

If one newb reads the post and learns what not to do when carrying human freight then it may be a loved one saved in the future. Kinda makes sense, huh?
 
Someone is in 'airplane go boom denial' :banghead:

If one newb reads the post and learns what not to do when carrying human freight then it may be a loved one saved in the future. Kinda makes sense, huh?

No, not really. The actual article posted didn't provide any sort of useful information. Additionally, normally these threads degrade into "wow... lots of airplanes crashing recently huh?" before any useful information gets passed along.

There was a section of the site where MikeD posted excellent accident analysis. I'm hoping at some point he comes back and posts some more. In the mean time, it might not be a bad thing to have, to intelligently discuss accidents/incidents. Unfortunately, the majority of these that are posted in the main forum don't contain anything useful for, as you called them, "newbs carrying human freight".

As it turns out this crash did effect a poster here, and I'm really glad to hear that things turned out as well as they did considering the situation.

And having lost three former students and a friend to airplanes going "boom" I'm thinking I'm not really in denial about it.
 
No, not really. The actual article posted didn't provide any sort of useful information. Additionally, normally these threads degrade into "wow... lots of airplanes crashing recently huh?" before any useful information gets passed along.

There was a section of the site where MikeD posted excellent accident analysis. I'm hoping at some point he comes back and posts some more. In the mean time, it might not be a bad thing to have, to intelligently discuss accidents/incidents. Unfortunately, the majority of these that are posted in the main forum don't contain anything useful for, as you called them, "newbs carrying human freight".

As it turns out this crash did effect a poster here, and I'm really glad to hear that things turned out as well as they did considering the situation.

And having lost three former students and a friend to airplanes going "boom" I'm thinking I'm not really in denial about it.

Understood

You do make a large assumption that the 'wow' factor far outweighs the benefit of a newb learning from 'airplane go boom' reality. 'Intelligent discussion' on some of these threads is entirely debatable no matter what the subject.

Do keep in mind that this particular news item is new! Not much conclusion can be derived from that. What I see important is that someone can have awareness of the news item for further research at their 'wow' leisure.
 
Back
Top