What would you do?

Ian_J

Hubschrauber Flieger
Staff member
You are the PIC for a Part 135 freight company flying a multi-engine twin. You take off under day VFR conditions. Very shortly after takeoff, you realize you lost a vacuum pump. The other one is working just fine. You have work on board. What would you do?
 
You are the PIC for a Part 135 freight company flying a multi-engine twin. You take off under day VFR conditions. Very shortly after takeoff, you realize you lost a vacuum pump. The other one is working just fine. You have work on board. What would you do?

Well I don't know 135 regs, but my question would be:

Is it VFR along the entire route and destination?

I am guessing that there is some hard 135 regs as to what is required.
 
Yes



Nope. Not when the discovery was made in flight.

Well, if it is VFR along the entire route, and at the destination, and you have another vacuum pump working, I would think it would be o.k.

Is there an electric backup for the instruments?

Are there company regs? I would think the company would ask why did one not continue on if it were VFR?
 
Well, if it is VFR along the entire route, and at the destination, and you have another vacuum pump working, I would think it would be o.k.

Is there an electric backup for the instruments?

Are there company regs? I would think the company would ask why did one not continue on if it were VFR?
To hell with it, just get there. It's not gonna get fixed in flight and I'm not diverting for a vacuum pump when I have another. If BA can fly from LA to London with an engine not working, I can make a couple hundred miles with one vacuum pump
 
To hell with it, just get there. It's not gonna get fixed in flight and I'm not diverting for a vacuum pump when I have another. If BA can fly from LA to London with an engine not working, I can make a couple hundred miles with one vacuum pump

Now if it were IFR, would that change your answer? Iask because I really don't know about 135 and the rules.
 
A vaccuum pump went out? Not until I get done for the night. It probably happened on my last leg and mx can have it fixed while I am sleeping.
 
You are the PIC for a Part 135 freight company flying a multi-engine twin. You take off under day VFR conditions. Very shortly after takeoff, you realize you lost a vacuum pump. The other one is working just fine. You have work on board. What would you do?

Not sure about anybody else, but my MEL says I can dispatch with one inoperative vacuum pump so long as it is day VFR conditions. Guess in my mind, I was going anyway, and the MEL backs me up fully for continuing the flight so long as it remains day VFR.
 
You are the PIC for a Part 135 freight company flying a multi-engine twin. You take off under day VFR conditions. Very shortly after takeoff, you realize you lost a vacuum pump. The other one is working just fine. You have work on board. What would you do?



You are in training at Hairnet? If you did turn around and land for losing a vacuum pump, you would quickly gain the reputation of being a pu$$y. Even in IMC, I would continue with just one pump. Just don't use your deice boots unless you HAD too. Been there, done that.
 
Now that you've already been dispatched, it's become a safety thing. Is it safe to continue?
 
I think it would be ok to continue in VFR conditions. However, I would write up the vacuum pump once I got to a maintenence base.
 
I think it would be ok to continue in VFR conditions. However, I would write up the vacuum pump once I got to a maintenence base.


What if your destination wasn't a maintenance base? Are you saying that you would depart with a know mechanical discrepancy? I know that you commuter guys always say that you never write anything up at an outstation because you have no maintenance there. Why is that? Is it because you are all such company guys that you will violate FARs to help the company? Are you too lazy to write it up at an outstation? Worried that you might lose pay somehow if you cancel at an outstation and a reserve has to take your next trip at the hub? If it's broke, write it up wherever you are. Call me when you get it fixed, I'll be in the crew lounge. Oh, you don't have those at most outstations do you?
 
What if your destination wasn't a maintenance base? Are you saying that you would depart with a know mechanical discrepancy? I know that you commuter guys always say that you never write anything up at an outstation because you have no maintenance there. Why is that? Is it because you are all such company guys that you will violate FARs to help the company? Are you too lazy to write it up at an outstation? Worried that you might lose pay somehow if you cancel at an outstation and a reserve has to take your next trip at the hub? If it's broke, write it up wherever you are. Call me when you get it fixed, I'll be in the crew lounge. Oh, you don't have those at most outstations do you?

Take it easy there partner! First of all, I am not a "commuter guy." Not yet anyway. I work for Ram Air Freight, a part 135 cargo company based out of RDU. I would never hesitate to write up anything that I viewed to be a safety critical item, regardless of where I am. More than once I have had to write up something at an outstation where there wasn't any maintenence. Dispatch had to figure out a way to get me home, find someone to cover the rest of the run, and find a way to get a mechanic and the necessary parts to the outstation.

Would I ever violate an FAR to help the company? That sure as h*ll won't happen as long as I am the PIC.

Losing one vacuum pump on a twin engine plane in day VFR conditions is not a critical problem in my opinion. At my company, that is something that can be MEL'd. Let dispatch know about the problem. Finish the run, provided that it is done in compliance with the FARs, and with the MEL. Dispatch will make arrangements to have the plane brought to a MX base.

If you have a problem that is a safety issue, and/or is something that can't be MEL'd, write it up wherever you are and let dispatch figure out what to do.

As far as crew lounges go, the only one that we have is in RDU. Everywhere else you go, you just have to take whatever the FBO has to offer you.
 
Are you saying that you would depart with a know mechanical discrepancy?

Yes...if it can legally be MEL'd and you can stay within the FARs...

Look at the original question...he asked if he lost a vacuum pump in day VFR...Since pilot4500 and I are the only ones that have mentioned a Minimum Equipment List obviously we know what we are doing and like I posted earlier, my airplane can be DISPATCHED with one vacuum pump inoperative and the flight occurs with the LIMITATION that it is day VFC only...guess that means it is perfectly legal for me to depart with a dead vacuum pump

Same goes for stuff like a gyroscopic rate of turn/slip skid inicator, a VOR reciever, clock, landing light, VHF reciever, and ammeter/voltmeter...I can legally dispatch into day VMC with any of these out of service. Now that being said, is it necessarily smart...depends on the situation.

Biggest thing is to check your MEL stay within the regs and keep safety in mind above anything else, no matter what your reputation at your company may become.
 
Yes...if it can legally be MEL'd and you can stay within the FARs...

Look at the original question...he asked if he lost a vacuum pump in day VFR...Since pilot4500 and I are the only ones that have mentioned a Minimum Equipment List obviously we know what we are doing and like I posted earlier, my airplane can be DISPATCHED with one vacuum pump inoperative and the flight occurs with the LIMITATION that it is day VFC only...guess that means it is perfectly legal for me to depart with a dead vacuum pump

Same goes for stuff like a gyroscopic rate of turn/slip skid inicator, a VOR reciever, clock, landing light, VHF reciever, and ammeter/voltmeter...I can legally dispatch into day VMC with any of these out of service. Now that being said, is it necessarily smart...depends on the situation.

Biggest thing is to check your MEL stay within the regs and keep safety in mind above anything else, no matter what your reputation at your company may become.


If you will read his original question closer, he had already departed, then the pump failed. He wanted to know what to do. He would be perfectly legal and safe to continue. MEL has nothing to do with his scenario, as MELs only pertain to dispatch and are not used inflight. If he did an air-turnback in day MVC because of a vacuum pump failure, he would be instantly labeled a pu$$y by everyone at Airnet, his fellow pilots, dispatch, mx and the flight department.
 
Pretty much what I thought.

Now how would you answer this question if asked on a part 135 oral?
 
Pretty much what I thought.

Now how would you answer this question if asked on a part 135 oral?

Answer:

Yes the flight can be done in a safe manner without violating in Ops Specs, 135, or 91 regs.

bada bing.
 
Even if I was IFR I would probably just continue. The only time that I wouldn't is if I was going into a place like ATL or ORD. I try not to mess the big airports up because I know that sometime later I will be going in there and I do not want to screw the airport over, airlines on the other hand are a different story. But even when I was flying a C210 I still had two pumps to get me there. That's the reason that there are two pumps.
 
If you will read his original question closer, he had already departed, then the pump failed. He wanted to know what to do. He would be perfectly legal and safe to continue. MEL has nothing to do with his scenario, as MELs only pertain to dispatch and are not used inflight.

Guess I should explain myself...

Losing a vacuum pump in flight during day VMC, I'll worry with it when I get to my destination.

My previous post about the MEL was pertaining to your question of if departing with a known mechanical descrepancy on the airplane. The answer there is still yes...see previous post...I was just referencing the day VMC portion of the original question.

If he did an air-turnback in day MVC because of a vacuum pump failure, he would be instantly labeled a pu$$y by everyone at Airnet, his fellow pilots, dispatch, mx and the flight department.

And I agree, turning back day VMC after losing a vacuum pump is a not smart move...
 
Back
Top