Cause of Kamaka Air Cargo Caravan crash released

The flap motor thing is the biggest bunch of BS. Every caravan operator changes the motor only when warranted. I’d argue that’s far safer than pulling the transmission as you don’t interrupt the rigging. Couple bolts, electrical plug, check/replace the coupling, easy peasy. Seems to me that there used to be an SB or something that said you could do it, but maybe we were just doing pirate maintenance. Also, primary and secondary motors were the same. And good luck stocking a spare full transmission assembly. Even 10 years ago if you wanted to pay for one outright (arm, leg, and firstborn child) you straight up couldn’t get one. Used to be able to dig up a spare motor and get it overhauled.

Actually thinking about it, you may not have needed to interrupt rigging to replace the transmission either. Even in that case it was silly to replace the whole thing when it was just a motor failing.

I didn’t dig deep enough to see if the NTSB thought the flaps were mis rigged, but knowing the history of the aircraft type, I’d put money on frequently either exceeding or just barely meeting the max flap speeds for bending parts and causing them to fail. We used to observe the next lowest “step” for flap speeds on our machines (flaps 30 at flaps 20 speed, etc) and the worst we had was the occasional motor dying.
 
Last edited:
It’s been a bit since I’ve touched a 208 (like…10+ years…) but in addition to a backup flap motor that I don’t remember much about other than the line stopped safety wiring the switch guard for it without telling flight ops it’s also a big 172 with roll spoilers. I can’t see an uncontrollable roll resulting in the time it would take someone with at or above my poor level of stick and rudder skills to recognize the asymmetry and retract the flaps to match.
 
Probably depends heavily on your specific airframe.
At this point in my life it'd be a 172 most likely. I do no flaps almost as much as I do normal landings so that it's a non-event if they get stuck. In X-plane I tried asymmetrical 172 flaps but the plane isn't controllable.
 
Last edited:
At this point in my life it'd be a 172 most likely. I do no flaps almost as much as I do normal landing so that it's a non-event if they get stuck, in X-plane I tried asymmetrical but the plane isn't controllable.
I’d have to think through it but in a 172 first thing I’d probably try after getting the thing under control is to retract the flaps to get them both up or at least more symmetrical. Many other aircraft I wouldn’t as you could make things worse, but the Cessna cross cable setup the worst that would happen is the motor stalls out and trips the breaker and you’re still stuck with the asymmetry.
 
Also, control system rigging (even of a secondary flight control like flaps) is one of just a handful of tasks that would have me thinking through and double and triple guessing myself and other folks work. Especially in older GA airplanes rigging instructions and diagrams are not always the best and a for whatever reason a lot of people struggle to really understand how control cable rigging works in it’s fundamental principles and just start tweaking stuff “if you have to hold right aileron to keep the wings level I’ll just adjust the cables a little so the right aileron comes up”
No, that’s not how that works at all.

Also also, the scariest is trim tab work because it’s real frigging easy to think yourself into rigging something backwards, especially ailerons, and if you screw it up there’s probably an even chance that it doesn’t end well.
 
I’d have to think through it but in a 172 first thing I’d probably try after getting the thing under control is to retract the flaps to get them both up or at least more symmetrical. Many other aircraft I wouldn’t as you could make things worse, but the Cessna cross cable setup the worst that would happen is the motor stalls out and trips the breaker and you’re still stuck with the asymmetry.
Yes, but i'm just wondering in the event that you can't retract the flaps and have to land in an asymmetrical position. If that's even possible as it seems near impossible in X-plane if they're stuck at 30 degrees on one side and up on the other in a 172.

This is all why a club's maintenance is so important to me. After twice finding tools inside aircraft rolling around when I lifted the elevator and shook the wings respectively during preflight, I left a club years ago wondering what else their mechanics must be doing carelessly.
 
Yes, but i'm just wondering in the event that you can't retract the flaps and have to land in an asymmetrical position. If that's even possible as it seems near impossible in X-plane if they're stuck at 30 degrees on one side and up on the other in a 172.

This is all why a club's maintenance is so important to me. After twice finding tools inside aircraft rolling around when I lifted the elevator and shook the wings respectively during preflight, I left a club years ago wondering what else their mechanics must be doing carelessly.
Well, I think you’d put in full aileron, and if that doesn’t stop the roll, add a bootful of rudder too and accept whatever slip/skid that gives you. I would also be careful with speed changes if you have it under control-though on a 172 I think faster would be better? Because you have 2 ailerons and a rudder working against the single flap that’s trying to roll you and the faster you go the more effective they would be?
 
By the way @ChasenSFO … I went on a deep dive into remembering stuff I used to do on single engine Cessnas and reviewing diagrams… on an electric flap 172 I would guess your most likely asymmetrical flap situation is going to be right flap extends normally and left flap retracts. The reason for this is that the right flap is driven directly by the actuator, but the left flap is driven by cables interconnecting it to the right flap. So if the cable that pulls the left flap down snaps due to wear and tear, you could have the left flap retract and the right stay where it is. Thats also why when you push on the flaps when they’re extended you’ll feel more spring/give in the left side-that’s the cables stretching/flexing.
 
Back
Top