"Practice approach approved"

Dutch Rohls

Well-Known Member
What's the difference between "practice approach approved" and "cleared for the approach"?

Is "practice approach approved" an official phrase defined in controllers' regs/handbooks/etc?
 
What's the difference between "practice approach approved" and "cleared for the approach"?

Is "practice approach approved" an official phrase defined in controllers' regs/handbooks/etc?

practice approach approved is us approving you to do an instrument approach while VFR under your own navigation. It is normally followed or preceded with "separation services not provided". If we clear you for the approach, you will be afforded IFR separation (except for vertical separation, 500' still applies) even though you are VFR for the duration of the approach. Only time I do it is if it's requested by the pilot or i get too busy to deal with you.

3. Where separation services are not provided to VFR aircraft practicing instrument approaches, the controller shall;

(a) Instruct the pilot to maintain VFR.

(b) Advise the pilot that separation services are not provided.

PHRASEOLOGY-
“(Aircraft identification) MAINTAIN VFR, PRACTICE APPROACH APPROVED, NO SEPARATION SERVICES PROVIDED.”


(c) Provide traffic information or advise the pilot to contact the appropriate facility.
 
Last edited:
Only time I do it is if it's requested by the pilot or i get too busy to deal with you.
It seems to be a bit regional too. By the time I moved from the Denver area to North Carolina, Denver TRACON had pretty much moved to "practice approach approved" except at certain times at certain airports. After I moved I went to a pilot/controller meeting at RDU, and being fairly new to the area, asked which Raleigh TRACON preferred. They had no idea what I was talking about until I explained what "practice approach approved" meant.
 
It seems to be a bit regional too. By the time I moved from the Denver area to North Carolina, Denver TRACON had pretty much moved to "practice approach approved" except at certain times at certain airports. After I moved I went to a pilot/controller meeting at RDU, and being fairly new to the area, asked which Raleigh TRACON preferred. They had no idea what I was talking about until I explained what "practice approach approved" meant.

The only difference is apparently the RDU controllers need to hit the books. It's right there in the .65. Although they're probably slow enough where they don't need it.
 
I don't understand the benefit (if any) of a "practice approach".

If you're not yet IFR rated, flying with a safety pilot in VFR, and just looking to track courses and/or glide slopes, just shoot the approach. ATC, nor anyone else has to know you're approaching on instruments vs visually, nor does it make any difference to anyone. Seems to me that the "practice approach" overlay creates unnecessary hassle and potential confusion for everyone.

If you are IFR rated, or flying with an instructor, just grab a pop-up clearance. Actually practice real IFR radio calls, sequencing, etc, and get some real, valuable practice with the totality of instrument procedure.

But perhaps I'm missing something...
 
I don't understand the benefit (if any) of a "practice approach".

If you're not yet IFR rated, flying with a safety pilot in VFR, and just looking to track courses and/or glide slopes, just shoot the approach. ATC, nor anyone else has to know you're approaching on instruments vs visually, nor does it make any difference to anyone. Seems to me that the "practice approach" creates unnecessary hassle and potential confusion for everyone.

If you are IFR rated, or flying with an instructor, just grab a pop up plan and actually practice IFR radio calls, sequencing, etc, and get some real, valuable practice with the totality of instrument procedure.

But perhaps I'm missing something...

Usually what happens is person calls up VFR asking for vectors for an ILS or whatever approach. I may be able to give them flight following, but too busy to give them their vectors and turn to final etc. This is when I use "practice approach approved separation services not provided." Lot of times it's probably a student pilot working on their IFR is my assumption. Also if it's a slow guy when they first called up I might have had every intention of giving them vectors and a clearance, but in the 20 minutes it takes them to get their traffic picked up.
 
None to the pilot. The sole benefit is to ATC.

To me as a CFII the difference is between "unable" from Miami approach and "cleared for the practice approach" from the tower when there's 8+ in the pattern plus some coming in and leaving via the same corridor underneath MIA bravo and the tower does a great job working us into the flow.
Also "local thing" is to be at 1000 feet at the certain reporting point coming in to land VFR, I need to be higher to practice the approach.
Getting the approach back to base at the tail end of a practice sequence I normally get long vectors, which is fine too, but requesting it from the tower at the end of a timed turns/unusual attitudes practice while a mile or two away from IAF works faster.
Point being, there's certain benefit in some places, but frankly being under MIA is the first time I encountered such a place.
 
To me as a CFII the difference is between "unable" from Miami approach and "cleared for the practice approach" from the tower when there's 8+ in the pattern plus some coming in and leaving via the same corridor underneath MIA bravo and the tower does a great job working us into the flow.
Also "local thing" is to be at 1000 feet at the certain reporting point coming in to land VFR, I need to be higher to practice the approach.
Getting the approach back to base at the tail end of a practice sequence I normally get long vectors, which is fine too, but requesting it from the tower at the end of a timed turns/unusual attitudes practice while a mile or two away from IAF works faster.
Point being, there's certain benefit in some places, but frankly being under MIA is the first time I encountered such a place.
That's what I was getting at. At big Bravos, ATC is not going to like a 172 shooting an approach regardless of how it's "authorized". I mean, 80 knots on final is almost always going to be a pain when everyone else is bookin'. Also at big Bravos, you're usually going to need to be in the Bravo at some point to practice the approach a real sort of fashion.
So why not just get a pop-up (if they'll give it to you).
At little airports it's usually not really an issue any way you choose to do it, so why not do it for real?
 
That's what I was getting at. At big Bravos, ATC is not going to like a 172 shooting an approach regardless of how it's "authorized". I mean, 80 knots on final is almost always going to be a pain when everyone else is bookin'. Also at big Bravos, you're usually going to need to be in the Bravo at some point to practice the approach a real sort of fashion.
So why not just get a pop-up (if they'll give it to you).
At little airports it's usually not really an issue any way you choose to do it, so why not do it for real?

We don't usually do this at our main airports. I use it at towered and untowered satellites. For me I use it a lot at MMU and CDW. I would never do it at TEB or EWR.
 
That's what I was getting at. At big Bravos, ATC is not going to like a 172 shooting an approach regardless of how it's "authorized". I mean, 80 knots on final is almost always going to be a pain when everyone else is bookin'. Also at big Bravos, you're usually going to need to be in the Bravo at some point to practice the approach a real sort of fashion.
So why not just get a pop-up (if they'll give it to you).
At little airports it's usually not really an issue any way you choose to do it, so why not do it for real?

I teach at KHWO, which is under KMIA bravo
Full and proper lesson with approaches - get the squawk through the ground before departure, fly a bunch of approaches terminating with one back home.
Lesson with miscellaneous stuff - depart squawking 1200, do our thing, on the way back request approach from the tower - the tower clears you for the practice approach and can a) work you into the hectic traffic doing patterns on two parallel runways and b) if able work your circling requests into that flow since they know what you are trying to accomplish.
VFR arrivals that are not talking to Miami approach drop a thousand feet lower much further out, hence there is no kosher way to silently fly the approach.
To clarify - I am below Bravo in that scenario and "practice approaches" just make my and ATCs life easier. Oftentimes you have a bunch of VFR traffic in and outbound along a narrow corridor making your popup IFR not practical or impossible due to separation, thus making practice approaches useful
 
To me as a CFII the difference is between "unable" from Miami approach and "cleared for the practice approach" from the tower when there's 8+ in the pattern plus some coming in and leaving via the same corridor underneath MIA bravo and the tower does a great job working us into the flow.
Also "local thing" is to be at 1000 feet at the certain reporting point coming in to land VFR, I need to be higher to practice the approach.
Getting the approach back to base at the tail end of a practice sequence I normally get long vectors, which is fine too, but requesting it from the tower at the end of a timed turns/unusual attitudes practice while a mile or two away from IAF works faster.
Point being, there's certain benefit in some places, but frankly being under MIA is the first time I encountered such a place.
I agree with your example but am not sure if talks to the difference between "cleared for the approach" and "practice approach approved" firm a facility providing approach control services in ATC-speak. I should have been clearer that's all I was referring to.

What you are describing sounds more like the Towered airport equivalent of the very common practice of not using ATC approach services when practicing approaches to a nontowered airport. A variation in a theme to get things done.
 
I agree with your example but am not sure if talks to the difference between "cleared for the approach" and "practice approach approved" firm a facility providing approach control services in ATC-speak. I should have been clearer that's all I was referring to.

What you are describing sounds more like the Towered airport equivalent of the very common practice of not using ATC approach services when practicing approaches to a nontowered airport. A variation in a theme to get things done.
Essentially it is.
We can also request that from the approach, it just takes a little more time. Sometimes approach will advise that they are unable to facilitate a normal approach due to traffic and will ask if we can accept a VFR practice approach instead
 
I agree with your example but am not sure if talks to the difference between "cleared for the approach" and "practice approach approved" firm a facility providing approach control services in ATC-speak. I should have been clearer that's all I was referring to.

What you are describing sounds more like the Towered airport equivalent of the very common practice of not using ATC approach services when practicing approaches to a nontowered airport. A variation in a theme to get things done.

You are correct. A tower can't clear someone for an approach anyway. The only differences between "cleared approach" and "practice approach approved" when given by the approach controller is what separation services you will be provided and whether you are given vectors to final or not.
 
In the en route world I use it where we are 1 in 1 out (basically any airport we're providing approaches to). That way if somebody calls for a clearance off the field I'm not having to block for a guy on an approach. Certainly used if I have an actual ifr inbound behind.
 
That's what I was getting at. At big Bravos, ATC is not going to like a 172 shooting an approach regardless of how it's "authorized". I mean, 80 knots on final is almost always going to be a pain when everyone else is bookin'. Also at big Bravos, you're usually going to need to be in the Bravo at some point to practice the approach a real sort of fashion.
So why not just get a pop-up (if they'll give it to you).
At little airports it's usually not really an issue any way you choose to do it, so why not do it for real?

Both IAD and BWI are cool with this if you don't try and do it during a major push or arrival period. They seem to be willing to work with you, especially if you call and try to make sure you're trying to meet their needs. I got to shoot the ILS into 1R at IAD during my training and it was a great experience.

I haven't tried it at BWI but I've been told by a lot of people that BWI is pretty GA-friendly for a "big Bravo."
 
Interesting discussion. On the USN side (not sure if DoD wide or not), you can commence a "practice approach" when a field is below mins, whereas you cannot do the same if there is an intent to land (i.e. a "real approach" I suppose). That much is written hard in our governing regs, the equivalent of civilian FARs. But with that backstory, I have always understood a practice approach to be one where there is no intent to land, unlike the consensus here that such an approach is one conducted VMC.
 
I don't understand the benefit (if any) of a "practice approach".

If you're not yet IFR rated, flying with a safety pilot in VFR, and just looking to track courses and/or glide slopes, just shoot the approach. ATC, nor anyone else has to know you're approaching on instruments vs visually, nor does it make any difference to anyone. Seems to me that the "practice approach" overlay creates unnecessary hassle and potential confusion for everyone.

If you are IFR rated, or flying with an instructor, just grab a pop-up clearance. Actually practice real IFR radio calls, sequencing, etc, and get some real, valuable practice with the totality of instrument procedure.

But perhaps I'm missing something...

In the case of a lot of military aircraft they can be instrument equipped but not legally instrument rated due to equipment

The Apache and Kiowa community specifically, and whole chunks of particular models of aircraft are incapable of legally doing certain types (RNAV mostly) approaches but we maintain equipment to provide an emergency recovery capability. In that case we cannot fly an IFR clearance because legally our aircraft cannot be IFR but as instrument rated aviators we fly practice IFR conditions all the time.
 
Interesting discussion. On the USN side (not sure if DoD wide or not), you can commence a "practice approach" when a field is below mins, whereas you cannot do the same if there is an intent to land (i.e. a "real approach" I suppose). That much is written hard in our governing regs, the equivalent of civilian FARs. But with that backstory, I have always understood a practice approach to be one where there is no intent to land, unlike the consensus here that such an approach is one conducted VMC.
I don't see a VMC consensus. I'm just looking at the AIM and ATC Handbook.

There are two separate issues. The AIM, at 4–3–21 and the ATC Handbook at 4-8-11 both recognize that "practice" can be under VFR or IFR. It's just plain English. Under IFR it might just mean the intent is to do a few for, um, practice, before landing or, it might be you want to decline a visual already and do one for practice. Under VFR it just means you're not doing it under IFR. Done both. Nothing more complicated than that. In either case, it might be one or many. Landing or not doesn't make any difference. Most flights, even those practicing procedures, end with a landing ;)

OTOH the ATC phraseology, "practice approach approved" is more specific. For practice approaches under IFR, ATC is required to provide separation services and approach clearances are given. VFR practice is also given approach clearances if separation services are being provided. But, according to the ATC Handbook,

Where separation services are not provided to VFR aircraft practicing instrument approaches, the controller must;
(a) Instruct the pilot to maintain VFR.
(b) Advise the pilot that separation services are not provided.
​

PHRASEOLOGY−
“(Aircraft identification) MAINTAIN VFR, PRACTICE APPROACH APPROVED, NO SEPARATION SERVICES PROVIDED.”
​






 
Back
Top