Anyone done EAS successfully?

It's free money, but when you underbid it just to get the work.... That's what seaport did when I lived in PDX. Cape air had the Coos Bay and Newport EAS routes won, then seaport came in crying that they didn't get to bid(because they didn't bid in time), and underbid the crap out of cape. They flew the Newport route until the money from the city went away and abandoned it. Then I'm sure the other routes were not profitable at what they told the govt they could do them for.
Cape Air on the other hand tries to use the subsidy to develop the market into something at least close to self sustaining. Rather than bleed it for the money and run.

To be honest I don't see Penair being successful long term in OTH either unless there is a lot more money coming from the feds. There isn't the traffic for a 34 seat turboprop. 9 seats is about right. I think PDT made money for Seaport, but I don't know why you wouldn't just drive up to Pasco and jump on Horizon.
Our service isn't going to be seven days per week. But I hear the Horizon flights used to be full in the baby dash.
 
@av8tr1 , let me get this straight because I am lost.

You have showed sympathy towards and agree with the ideology of the Oregon Terrorists who took over federal land because they hate 'big government' like you do, but you are wondering how entities make EAS, a government subsidized program, work?

Shouldn't you be taking the position that you want all EAS contracts to go under?

Or because EAS and the subsidy benefit(s)(ed) you, you were ok with that part of 'big government'?

Sing it!

 
No @Seggy I am not a fan of EAS routes. Never have been, even when I was flying for Seaport. I take the position that EAS routes are not good for the community. Either the business is there or it isn't. We waste tax payer monies on supporting weak markets where they are not needed. I think they should go away.
 
Cape Air on the other hand tries to use the subsidy to develop the market into something at least close to self sustaining. Rather than bleed it for the money and run.

That is what has to be done in an EAS market. Unfortunately, places like SeaPort wanted to simply milk the subsidy for every penny.
 
No @Seggy I am not a fan of EAS routes. Never have been, even when I was flying for Seaport. I take the position that EAS routes are not good for the community. Either the business is there or it isn't. We waste tax payer monies on supporting weak markets where they are not needed. I think they should go away.

You say now that EAS routes are not good for the community, yet in this thread, post 88 you say...

http://forums.jetcareers.com/thread...rvice-in-ca-and-ks.230719/page-5#post-2532169

The company tries to provide a valuable resource to remote communities.

So I am still confused.
 
Yes, I know @Seggy, as usual you're confused. Maybe your mom can explain it to you in simple enough terms even you can understand.

Ahhhhh, not sure what anyone in my family has to do with this.

I am confused by what you wrote in some posts. Should be simple enough for you to explain I figured.
 
Board in your moms basement again tonight @Seggy?

It's very simple. I said that Seaport provided a good service (when they are able to actually do it) by connecting remote communities to the rest of the world cheaply. That is what I referred to when I said "They provide a valuable resource to remote communities". Seaport isn't special in doing that though. Any company can do that and many do it much better than Seaport does.

However regardless of the valuable resource to remote communities I still don't think they should get government funds to do it. Why should my tax dollars go to pay for someone else to live in a remote area. I want to live in a remote area. I want to live in the mountains somewhere far off the beaten path but I don't expect anyone else, especially the government to pay for me to live there or commute from the area. Nore do I think anyone else should be offered other peoples money to do so.
 
Board in your moms basement again tonight @Seggy?

Nope.


It's very simple. I said that Seaport provided a good service (when they are able to actually do it) by connecting remote communities to the rest of the world cheaply. That is what I referred to when I said "They provide a valuable resource to remote communities". Seaport isn't special in doing that though. Any company can do that and many do it much better than Seaport does.

However regardless of the valuable resource to remote communities I still don't think they should get government funds to do it. Why should my tax dollars go to pay for someone else to live in a remote area. I want to live in a remote area. I want to live in the mountains somewhere far off the beaten path but I don't expect anyone else, especially the government to pay for me to live there or commute from the area. Nore do I think anyone else should be offered other peoples money to do so.

If the government isn't going to provide that valuable resource then who is?

I see it as you are contradicting yourself.
 
Ok, I'll bite. How is that contradicting myself? I am talking about two completely different things.

People in remote areas want access to metropolitan services they can't find where they live. They will fly, drive, ride a horse or even walk if they want out bad enough. (Note the government hasn't come into the conversation here). Now if some enterprising business comes in and says "spare the horses, or the soles of your feet, we'll fly you to the big city for the low price of X" X=the value of what the rural person will pay to save the time and fly instead of drive, ride or walk. That's the valuable service I refer to. That "valuable service" is a "valuable" to those who chose to live in those remote areas. (Again note the government hasn't come into the conversation yet). So if the enterprising business can charge a price that is agreeable to the rural person and do it where they make money in the process it makes sense and is valuable to both parties. If its too expensive for either side to come out with something they can appreciate and feel like they got a good deal then it isn't valuable and both should go their separate ways. That's called the free market. And its worked for 100s of years. No government money needed.

Now the people that live in these remote areas are not there by force of government. They are their because they choose to be. I choose to live in a remote area as well. But nothing requires the government to provide those people (or me) transport into and out of those remote areas. So why should our taxes go to EAS programs? If people want to get from point A to point B bad enough there are plenty of options without the government getting involved.

Seaport flies from PDX to OTH and PDT. Both are a little over 3 hours drive. The flight is roughly 1.2 to 1.5 hours each way. So why are our tax dollars going to saving these people 1.5 hours of their day? What necessity is there for the government to need to get involved? Why can't these people just drive instead of fly? Why are they so special that they need to get extra help from the government to get where they are going?
 
Ok, I'll bite. How is that contradicting myself? I am talking about two completely different things.

People in remote areas want access to metropolitan services they can't find where they live. They will fly, drive, ride a horse or even walk if they want out bad enough. (Note the government hasn't come into the conversation here). Now if some enterprising business comes in and says "spare the horses, or the soles of your feet, we'll fly you to the big city for the low price of X" X=the value of what the rural person will pay to save the time and fly instead of drive, ride or walk. That's the valuable service I refer to. That "valuable service" is a "valuable" to those who chose to live in those remote areas. (Again note the government hasn't come into the conversation yet). So if the enterprising business can charge a price that is agreeable to the rural person and do it where they make money in the process it makes sense and is valuable to both parties. If its too expensive for either side to come out with something they can appreciate and feel like they got a good deal then it isn't valuable and both should go their separate ways. That's called the free market. And its worked for 100s of years. No government money needed.

Now the people that live in these remote areas are not there by force of government. They are their because they choose to be. I choose to live in a remote area as well. But nothing requires the government to provide those people (or me) transport into and out of those remote areas. So why should our taxes go to EAS programs? If people want to get from point A to point B bad enough there are plenty of options without the government getting involved.

Seaport flies from PDX to OTH and PDT. Both are a little over 3 hours drive. The flight is roughly 1.2 to 1.5 hours each way. So why are our tax dollars going to saving these people 1.5 hours of their day? What necessity is there for the government to need to get involved? Why can't these people just drive instead of fly? Why are they so special that they need to get extra help from the government to get where they are going?


You were quite clear that SeaPort provided the service that was valuable. The ONLY reason they provided the service was because of the EAS contract. Hence the contradiction to your views about the government.
 
Ach ... you young bucks ...

I personally miss the days of smoky Northeast DC9s onto New Bedford's five thousand foot runway, open air observation decks at Boston's Logan Airport, commercial service into Pittsfield, Mass, and Yellowbirds between BOS and PWM eleven times a day. Although you ended up in Cleveland or Detroit or Chicago (when there was a reason to go to those once-great cities), you could fly, once upon a time, a DC9 or 727 between Portland or Boston to Manchester on the way to bigger places. It was undoubtably wasteful, but to see those gorgeous ladies rising to the clouds on long, black, smoky legs - or, better, to ride 'em - was a glorious age in which to live.

Oh God, Eastern Electras on the NY Shuttle ... Executive Twin Otters with multiple schedules into Lewiston-Auburn ... Winnepesaukee Aviation ... Mohawk Bac-111s and FH-227s you could fly without reservations all weekend long for $29.95, ending at bigger airports to sleep in the terminals that stayed open overnight ...

And paper timetables you could hold and study, while you dreamed. I miss paper timetables, and the world they used to open.

As a taxpayer for damned near fifty years, I'd much sooner, personally, cut the glut of non-essential Federal employees to a reasonable number - along with any number of pork projects - to fund EAS. That may be without reason or good logic, but I'd do it were I in charge:bounce:
 
.... Why are they so special that they need to get extra help from the government to get where they are going?

Because they used to have it (before airline deregulation) and the Government took it away.

In those days, the CAB required certain routes, and they made the airlines subsidize the less-traveled routes to keep the major traffic (read: profitable) routes. Good parallel: the old AT&T, where everyone could get a phone line, even way out in the boonies, subsidized by the townies since their phone service cost less to provide but they paid the same.

We expect the government to provide certain services, whether we use them or not. I'm a major user of the public library, and I'm glad they we taxpayers provide it. I never had kids, but I benefited from a public education, and my friends and neighbors who have kids deserve it, too.
 
Because they used to have it (before airline deregulation) and the Government took it away.

In those days, the CAB required certain routes, and they made the airlines subsidize the less-traveled routes to keep the major traffic (read: profitable) routes. Good parallel: the old AT&T, where everyone could get a phone line, even way out in the boonies, subsidized by the townies since their phone service cost less to provide but they paid the same.

We expect the government to provide certain services, whether we use them or not. I'm a major user of the public library, and I'm glad they we taxpayers provide it. I never had kids, but I benefited from a public education, and my friends and neighbors who have kids deserve it, too.
You actually benefit quite a lot from your neighbors kids getting an education. All of us do.
 
Replacing Sun Air for the HGR and LNS service? Was it AD reminiscing about his Colgan days? Haha

That won't happen.

While those cities have historically been IAD EAS services, they no longer strictly are. Sun Air is focused on PIT which is where they route all of their EAS services through. The IAD flights from LNS/HGR are now scheduled as tag ons from the PIT flights. So the one advantage Sun Air has in those markets is they offer two destinations from the EAS city. While cost is a factor in service being awarded, the city still has to select the product they want vS the cheapest option.

If sun Air loses all of these EAS routes, which I believe they will come next bid, it will be Mokulele who takes them over. They are already flying half of Sun Air's routes through an operational lease and have always been talking about mainland service. They were going to do Florida until Silver threatened them and they just bid on Seaport's old CA routes...
 
That won't happen.

While those cities have historically been IAD EAS services, they no longer strictly are. Sun Air is focused on PIT which is where they route all of their EAS services through. The IAD flights from LNS/HGR are now scheduled as tag ons from the PIT flights. So the one advantage Sun Air has in those markets is they offer two destinations from the EAS city. While cost is a factor in service being awarded, the city still has to select the product they want vS the cheapest option.

If sun Air loses all of these EAS routes, which I believe they will come next bid, it will be Mokulele who takes them over. They are already flying half of Sun Air's routes through an operational lease and have always been talking about mainland service. They were going to do Florida until Silver threatened them and they just bid on Seaport's old CA routes...
That's what everyone needs. Another piece of crap operation to come in.
 
You actually benefit quite a lot from your neighbors kids getting an education. All of us do.

Amen. When I'm shopping for a house (and I live in the 9th I've owned), I consider the neighborhood as very, very important. I'm not looking for a place where the age range is 26.7 through 28.9. I want a full range, from young married through retirement. It brings a much richer collection of interests and values. Kids benefit from knowing a wider range of people, both age & experience. Better schools also bring better neighbors, whose values are often closer to mine. I now live between an 80-something widow and a 40-something family with three girls, Jr HS through college. They're also my cat-sitters.
 
Back
Top