Anyone done EAS successfully?

The EAS in Alaska works because for the most part its not underbid, ticket pricing is base as if there was no subsidy, and other options of getting there don't exist. Also it's usually a small portion of the overall business.
 
Haven't they recently backed off some of the Midwest EAS routes? Additionally, their summer New England tourist season is crazy busy.

I'm of the opinion that the overhead of a gov't contract combined with population shifts back to metro areas and an overall reduction in EAS funding makes these routes be losers. If the only way to run these routes is to low ball on everything, then I question the value. That's a strategic position I don't like.

I sort of agree with Chris. The migration from rural/smaller cities to the Big Towns is nearly 100 years old by now, and basically not a cause of today's problems. Pilot shortage is a temporary phenomenon caused equally by Congress and regional pilot salaries, and while real, it cannot last. What today's realities certainly have done is shrink the gap between winning and losing.

The secret to EAS success shouldn't be a secret to small regionals, but it seems to escape many of those CEOs. The first rule is a no-brainer: Dependable, reliable service. The Legacies get it, the large regionals do, Cape Air does. SeaPort is only the most recent failure. You can only offset a problem here with low fares, and being the only game in town for a while before it comes back to bite you (Think about Allegiant, now in mid-cycle). Second rule, common to ALL businesses, is: Know your costs (both fixed and variable) and revenue (fares and subsidies). If the equation doesn't balance, analyze why and get out of Dodge if it isn't likely to work. Not as easy for EAS, since the contract is normally a 24 month commitment and the road out of Dodge has a DOT gate. That old song doesn't work here either: Lose money on each transaction and make it up on volume. Third rule: Match equipment to loads. Costs pretty much parallel equipment size. Those folks flying Saabs, and even Beech 1900s at the smallest markets, are flying on anticipated growth, and/or equipment they have (Great Lakes). A good argument for leasing, although you do have to pay the lessors (SeaPort).

The interesting exception to Rule Three is going on at Eagle and SkyWest. They have a few cities where they take older, thirstier mini-jets (Eagle's E-135s & 145s, SkyWest's CJR-200s) that they own, un-park them from the desert where they make zero dollars, and put them on potential-for-growth not-as-small EAS cities. The combination of some PAX revenue and the subsidy works for them in a cheap-fuel time. They are also very careful about expenses - eg: no outstation overnights, even though that improves PAX travel plans by getting you to the big city for earlier business or connections and back home later in the evening. There should be enough data soon to show whether Shiny Jet Syndrome will grow PAX revenue sufficiently. They're following Rule Two pretty well. They have until fuel prices go up to develop enough customers by paying attention to Rule One, or the Rule Three pit-bull starts chomping.

Rule Four is: Be nimble and realistic using today's realities. Times have changed! Project Rule Two out into the future, and set decision points for when to get out of a market if it isn't ever going to work, or if you'll run out of cash first. For most, it has been the latter.

Perhaps Rule Five is: Don't try it. :aghast:
 
It's a question of geography. Cape Air is a good operator, to be sure, but they were blessed with being on an island. There is no real alternative unless you dig boats. Alaska is the same. The distances and/or terrain involved discourage the alternatives. You have a captive audience. Like SWA out of DAL, that permits you the revenue pad to make the jump to other things and the luxury of time to figure out what works and what doesn't.

It becomes a "chicken or the egg" question. Are the good operators good operators because they can afford to be? Or can they afford it because they are a good operator? Like many corporations, they also got their start when times were different. Maybe it is easier if you are BigNameStuffMakerCo, and the founder in 1850 considered waste "treated" when it was dumped in the river. Over the years they built up the business on the backs of that infrastructure to the point now they can afford to be a good citizen.

Could the same type of operation be built today using today's conditions or regs? Seems like a much higher hill to climb.

Most other places I've seen have a bad case of SJS, and lots of EAS operators in the past were bound by code-share arrangements that essentially forced them to go with jet equipment or keep a small odd-ball fleet just for EAS markets. That doesn't work either.

Richman
 
I sort of agree with Chris. The migration from rural/smaller cities to the Big Towns is nearly 100 years old by now, and basically not a cause of today's problems. Pilot shortage is a temporary phenomenon caused equally by Congress and regional pilot salaries, and while real, it cannot last. What today's realities certainly have done is shrink the gap between winning and losing.

The secret to EAS success shouldn't be a secret to small regionals, but it seems to escape many of those CEOs. The first rule is a no-brainer: Dependable, reliable service. The Legacies get it, the large regionals do, Cape Air does. SeaPort is only the most recent failure. You can only offset a problem here with low fares, and being the only game in town for a while before it comes back to bite you (Think about Allegiant, now in mid-cycle). Second rule, common to ALL businesses, is: Know your costs (both fixed and variable) and revenue (fares and subsidies). If the equation doesn't balance, analyze why and get out of Dodge if it isn't likely to work. Not as easy for EAS, since the contract is normally a 24 month commitment and the road out of Dodge has a DOT gate. That old song doesn't work here either: Lose money on each transaction and make it up on volume. Third rule: Match equipment to loads. Costs pretty much parallel equipment size. Those folks flying Saabs, and even Beech 1900s at the smallest markets, are flying on anticipated growth, and/or equipment they have (Great Lakes). A good argument for leasing, although you do have to pay the lessors (SeaPort).

The interesting exception to Rule Three is going on at Eagle and SkyWest. They have a few cities where they take older, thirstier mini-jets (Eagle's E-135s & 145s, SkyWest's CJR-200s) that they own, un-park them from the desert where they make zero dollars, and put them on potential-for-growth not-as-small EAS cities. The combination of some PAX revenue and the subsidy works for them in a cheap-fuel time. They are also very careful about expenses - eg: no outstation overnights, even though that improves PAX travel plans by getting you to the big city for earlier business or connections and back home later in the evening. There should be enough data soon to show whether Shiny Jet Syndrome will grow PAX revenue sufficiently. They're following Rule Two pretty well. They have until fuel prices go up to develop enough customers by paying attention to Rule One, or the Rule Three pit-bull starts chomping.

Rule Four is: Be nimble and realistic using today's realities. Times have changed! Project Rule Two out into the future, and set decision points for when to get out of a market if it isn't ever going to work, or if you'll run out of cash first. For most, it has been the latter.

Perhaps Rule Five is: Don't try it. :aghast:

Is SkyWest selling the tickets?

I guess I'm a little confused, because AFAIK, they don't buy a drop of their fuel. None of the "regionals" do.
 
Yes and why is that so F'en hard to do.....

But seriously.....is that the issue? I know it was at Seapot. They didn't develop an environment that encouraged longevity and since everything was tribal knowledge they had to relearn things over and over again. But I would like to believe there are other contributing factors. Not everyone is a jerk to their employees.

We're talking about free money from the government to fly empty or nearly planes. How do you frack that up while competitors who don't have the free government cheese are thriving at moving people around?
It's free money, but when you underbid it just to get the work.... That's what seaport did when I lived in PDX. Cape air had the Coos Bay and Newport EAS routes won, then seaport came in crying that they didn't get to bid(because they didn't bid in time), and underbid the crap out of cape. They flew the Newport route until the money from the city went away and abandoned it. Then I'm sure the other routes were not profitable at what they told the govt they could do them for.
Cape Air on the other hand tries to use the subsidy to develop the market into something at least close to self sustaining. Rather than bleed it for the money and run.

To be honest I don't see Penair being successful long term in OTH either unless there is a lot more money coming from the feds. There isn't the traffic for a 34 seat turboprop. 9 seats is about right. I think PDT made money for Seaport, but I don't know why you wouldn't just drive up to Pasco and jump on Horizon.
 
No clue. I just know it isn't currently. In point of fact it was Seapots most profitable route. Yet because of an error in math with their big fancy "data warehouse" they came to the incorrect conclusion that it wasn't a profitable route. Yet most flights were full or nearly full every day.

All other routes never came close to the passenger loads OTH had. So Penair could probably make a good route out of it if they time the flights right. One flight a day doesn't seem right but its over my pay grade to have those answers.

The inmates are now running the asylum over at Seapot. They can't get out of their own way. All aircraft are grounded in PDX and have been for a few days due to maintenance issues. So now they are busing people in a company van from PDX to PDT/OTH for the time being. I know if I paid for a flight to either place and I showed up and had to take a van I would be pissed and asking for my money back. Be cheaper to rent a car and a lot less of a hassle.
 
No clue. I just know it isn't currently. In point of fact it was Seapots most profitable route. Yet because of an error in math with their big fancy "data warehouse" they came to the incorrect conclusion that it wasn't a profitable route. Yet most flights were full or nearly full every day.

All other routes never came close to the passenger loads OTH had. So Penair could probably make a good route out of it if they time the flights right. One flight a day doesn't seem right but its over my pay grade to have those answers.

The inmates are now running the asylum over at Seapot. They can't get out of their own way. All aircraft are grounded in PDX and have been for a few days due to maintenance issues. So now they are busing people in a company van from PDX to PDT/OTH for the time being. I know if I paid for a flight to either place and I showed up and had to take a van I would be pissed and asking for my money back. Be cheaper to rent a car and a lot less of a hassle.
It's been a few years, but I remember seeing the Van in OTH and it would usually go out with 2-3 people. 4 if you include the FO as a pax.
 
Yeah, if the company had weather or maintenance issues they would do that. They stopped for some reason and now they are picking it back up again because they can't keep airplanes in the air.
 
Is SkyWest selling the tickets?

I guess I'm a little confused, because AFAIK, they don't buy a drop of their fuel. None of the "regionals" do.

In the cases cited, I believe that they are regular regional code shares, with United or American selling the tickets, paint is the legacy design scheme and numbering likewise. Except, of course, for ATC, where they use SkyWest's / Eagle's call sign.

I assume that you are correct, but somebody is buying the fuel. The decision for a regional to enter a market does require 'advice and consent' from the legacy partner, and if the route is or becomes an economic dud, it will go bye-bye eventually. I mentioned it because it is a relatively new phenomenon and IMHO a win-win for everyone.
 
Back
Top