ppragman
FLIPY FLAPS!
Except the part where it's old timers balling up caravans and sleds and the low time Era FO who called for a go around before the captain ripped the gear off a 1900.
You're totally correct with this, still, I personally would like to see more mentoring, and a healthy mentoring environment. A lot of guys that are new to the environment don't know what they don't know, yes, some of the old timers sucked, but also many of them didn't - that's how they got to be old-timers. You don't fly VFR in Bethel for 20 years and live without knowing every inch of the terrain, the problem lies in taking guys who've flown VFR for the last decade and throwing them into the left seat of an IFR airplane (even if it is one that is as forgiving as the Caravan) and telling them to ignore their instincts and file IFR everywhere. Add in some management pressure to be on-time and make it in and the old bush adage of "if it's bad, go IFR, if it's really bad, go VFR" starts to be used. It would be good if the guys going from into the Van from the sled actually had some IFR background to draw from other than their instrument rating and what they've gleaned from flying the 207 around (and make no mistake that is instrument flying, but it's weak on procedures). I'd also say that the learning goes both ways in the cockpit, if you encourage a good environment with "real" CRM a lot of those issues wouldn't happen.