Don't call it a comeback! Sweet news about the 757.

If it shouldn't cross the little pond, it shouldn't fly to Hawaii.

Longhaul in narrowbodies that are 3+3 is stupid.

Agree 100%, just saying airlines use it for some of those low density longer range routes and a 737 can't replace it. That doesn't make it ok to use a narrowbody in the first place on those routes.
 
If it shouldn't cross the little pond, it shouldn't fly to Hawaii.

Longhaul in narrowbodies that are 3+3 is stupid.
Flew a UA 757 from Madrid to IAD. Going business class, it was perfectly fine. In the back, well, I wouldnt have wanted to be in the back.

When I was young (early 80s), I was able to fly on a 707 to Hawaii and an L1011 to Europe/Egypt. Both were fun.

I loved the Continental Air Micronesia Pub planes that use to fly in the Pacific. Having a bar in the middle was awesome. (my grandmother always ordered me a baileys and diet coke)
 
Touche. And the talk of 90 seaters at regionals makes my blood boil.

Mine too. And I'm at a regional.

Edit to add: If regionals ceased to exist tomorrow, I'd be happy. Short term would surely suck. I'd be out a job. Long term though, they'd have to make up for the lack of lift somehow. And that would likely be a job at a better place, for MMMTO.
 
Mine too. And I'm at a regional.

Edit to add: If regionals ceased to exist tomorrow, I'd be happy. Short term would surely suck. I'd be out a job. Long term though, they'd have to make up for the lack of lift somehow. And that would likely be a job at a better place, for MMMTO.
The suck could last for a bit. If all the regionals shut down tomorrow, would the same amount of flights pop up on 717s md-80s etc? Probably not.
 
The suck could last for a bit. If all the regionals shut down tomorrow, would the same amount of flights pop up on 717s md-80s etc? Probably not.

Clearly not, which would ALSO be a good thing. Fewer, larger airplanes = an infrastructure which can actually support the number of airplanes they're trying to push through it.
 
Agree 100%, just saying airlines use it for some of those low density longer range routes and a 737 can't replace it. That doesn't make it ok to use a narrowbody in the first place on those routes.

You're too easy. :stir:
 
Mine too. And I'm at a regional.

Edit to add: If regionals ceased to exist tomorrow, I'd be happy. Short term would surely suck. I'd be out a job. Long term though, they'd have to make up for the lack of lift somehow. And that would likely be a job at a better place, for MMMTO.
If a scope clause ever results in the destruction of my regional job, I'm going to dance a jig while wearing a party hat and chugging a beer while I smoke a celebratory cigar.
The suck could last for a bit. If all the regionals shut down tomorrow, would the same amount of flights pop up on 717s md-80s etc? Probably not.
Nothing is stopping anyone from operating 76-100 seat RJ's on a mainline certificate...
 
Boeing rejects business case for 757 re-engining
By: Stephen Trimble
Washington DC
Source:
21:54 11 Feb 2015
Boeing vice-president Randy Tinseth says the company has studied reviving and re-engining the 757 “a couple” of times, but concluded that the economics do not make sense.

“We’re not studying 757 re-engined replacements right now. It just doesn’t work,” says Tinseth, addressing the Pacific Northwest Aerospace Alliance (PNAA) conference in Seattle.

Tinseth was asked to respond to a report in the Wall Street Journal that cited a source within Boeing saying a re-engined 757 was one option being considered as the company’s response to the long-range Airbus A321neo.

“No, no,” Tinseth replied.

In Boeing’s view, the 757 replacement market is limited. There are 550 passenger-carrying 757s still in operation, Tinseth says, excluding about 200-250 freighters. Of that market, only about 50-80 are flying trans-atlantic routes that exceed the maximum range of the 737 Max 9 or baseline A320neo.

Instead of focusing on a 757 replacement, Boeing is looking more broadly at the market for an aircraft that can fill the space between the 737 Max 9 and the 787-8.

“We’ve been talking to our customers and they want an airplane that’s bigger than today’s 757 and flies further – probably 20% further,” says Tinseth. “We are trying to figure out what that means, what that airplane would look like.”

With the KC-46, 737 Max, 787-10 and 777X still in development, Boeing’s research and development resources are occupied through at least 2022, Tinseth adds.

“So we’ve got some time to do it and we’ll take a real hard look,” Tinseth says.

Another barrier to reviving 757 production is that programme’s outdated and expensive assembly process, Tinseth says.

The 757 was assembled in Renton, Washington, alongside the 737, but as a longer and taller aircraft it required different tooling.

“That airplane had a unique very unique production system. It was relatively expensive to build compared to the 737,” Tinseth says. “The business case is just not going to close.”

One potential advantage, however, in favour of reviving the 757 is the certification programme. A clean-sheet designs requires a completely new type certificate. Re-engining an existing model can be done using an amended type certificate. It was not clear, however, if the US Federal Aviation Administration allows a manufacturer to amend a type certificate for an out-of-production aircraft.

An FAA spokesman, however, confirms that the agency’s regulations allowing amended type certificates extend to cover models that are no longer in production.
 
The story of the destroyed jigs for the 757 has been around a long time, and it starts to make more sense if you add the complex, archaic and unique building system.

What makes less sense is the part about the engineering drawings also being shredded. Same rationale: Chinese knock-offs. Boeing laid off all the lawyers?

I guess Boeing doesn't have much faith in their own security.

They should consider taking the present developmental state of the 737 Max and add the features they'd put into the 757 NEO. If they re-named it the 757 Max, maybe they could slide it in on the existing certification. ;)
 
Boeing rejects business case for 757 re-engining
By: Stephen Trimble
Washington DC
Source:
21:54 11 Feb 2015
Boeing vice-president Randy Tinseth says the company has studied reviving and re-engining the 757 “a couple” of times, but concluded that the economics do not make sense.

“We’re not studying 757 re-engined replacements right now. It just doesn’t work,” says Tinseth, addressing the Pacific Northwest Aerospace Alliance (PNAA) conference in Seattle.

Tinseth was asked to respond to a report in the Wall Street Journal that cited a source within Boeing saying a re-engined 757 was one option being considered as the company’s response to the long-range Airbus A321neo.

“No, no,” Tinseth replied.

In Boeing’s view, the 757 replacement market is limited. There are 550 passenger-carrying 757s still in operation, Tinseth says, excluding about 200-250 freighters. Of that market, only about 50-80 are flying trans-atlantic routes that exceed the maximum range of the 737 Max 9 or baseline A320neo.

Instead of focusing on a 757 replacement, Boeing is looking more broadly at the market for an aircraft that can fill the space between the 737 Max 9 and the 787-8.

“We’ve been talking to our customers and they want an airplane that’s bigger than today’s 757 and flies further – probably 20% further,” says Tinseth. “We are trying to figure out what that means, what that airplane would look like.”

With the KC-46, 737 Max, 787-10 and 777X still in development, Boeing’s research and development resources are occupied through at least 2022, Tinseth adds.

“So we’ve got some time to do it and we’ll take a real hard look,” Tinseth says.

Another barrier to reviving 757 production is that programme’s outdated and expensive assembly process, Tinseth says.

The 757 was assembled in Renton, Washington, alongside the 737, but as a longer and taller aircraft it required different tooling.

“That airplane had a unique very unique production system. It was relatively expensive to build compared to the 737,” Tinseth says. “The business case is just not going to close.”

One potential advantage, however, in favour of reviving the 757 is the certification programme. A clean-sheet designs requires a completely new type certificate. Re-engining an existing model can be done using an amended type certificate. It was not clear, however, if the US Federal Aviation Administration allows a manufacturer to amend a type certificate for an out-of-production aircraft.

An FAA spokesman, however, confirms that the agency’s regulations allowing amended type certificates extend to cover models that are no longer in production.

Why you gotta steal my thunder. JERK!
 
Instead of focusing on a 757 replacement, Boeing is looking more broadly at the market for an aircraft that can fill the space between the 737 Max 9 and the 787-8.

Ummm... isn't that pretty much the same mission/airplane as the 757? 787-8 is basically a 767-200 modern day replacement.
 
I cant imagine that Boeing or Airbus will be getting back into the new jet design game for at least a decade or more...if that.
 
What makes less sense is the part about the engineering drawings also being shredded. Same rationale: Chinese knock-offs. Boeing laid off all the lawyers?

Boeing kept the lawyers. The lawyers are the ones who told the company to trash everything. If Boeing is sued in the future, the plaintiff cannot subpoena something Boeing no longer has. (ie, oops, so sorry, we don't have those engineering drawings anymore) It makes winning a case against Boeing much harder.
 
Sapper said, in part: ...
If Boeing is sued in the future, the plaintiff cannot subpoena something Boeing no longer has. (ie, oops, so sorry, we don't have those engineering drawings anymore) It makes winning a case against Boeing much harder.

But it also makes Boeing's task of winning that case far harder. (oops, sorry, how can we know they copied our drawings since we can no longer prove they were ours).

Seemed like a good idea at the time...
 
Sapper said, in part: ...

But it also makes Boeing's task of winning that case far harder. (oops, sorry, how can we know they copied our drawings since we can no longer prove they were ours).

Seemed like a good idea at the time...

I think we are thinking of different types of cases. I am thinking of product liability, like an airplane crashes... Boeing wants to make it hard for someone to prove they are liable for something. I am guessing you are thinking of information security / trade secret stuff. My guess is that at some point the trade secret thing becomes less important (ie, how the supercharger functions on a P&W R985 is no longer a trade secret), where the possibility of liability continues as long as the airplanes continue to fly (which can be a ridiculously long time, see DC3's still in cargo service).

Either way, means more work from the lawyers, so I guess it's a win / win for them either way.
 
Back
Top