FloridaLarry
Well-Known Member
In this day and age (short of a willfully-suicidal flight crew) the liability pattern usually includes some causal factors from the aircraft builder. Plaintiff's lawyers, looking for deep pockets, assume that the Boeings of this world have pockets that are pretty deep, including their liability insurance. Boeing's lawyers want to limit that to the extent possible, ably abetted by their insurance company's lawyers. Plaintiff's legal team will find someone who remembers, has doodles stashed in a drawer, or will find an existing airframe that had the same problem ten years ago.
Trade secrets don't stay secret, either The patent application reveals a lot. If you want to badly enough, you can reverse-engineer something, given enough time and money. Since these very complex machines contain thousands and thousands of parts, you usually end up with the resultant brain-storming at Company B: "Oh, that's how they did it. Now we can tweak their design here and here, to make it bigger / better / faster / cheaper. That'll also make our patent lawyers happier."
Did Boeing really think that Chinese Mythical Aviation LLC was going to go to a junkyard in the State of Washington and buy up the old jigs, un-bend them, and therefore make a 75 knock-off cheaper?
In both types of cases, it's guys & gals in thousand-dollar suits jockeying for position. The games are won by singles and walks; grand slams mostly occur in fiction.
Trade secrets don't stay secret, either The patent application reveals a lot. If you want to badly enough, you can reverse-engineer something, given enough time and money. Since these very complex machines contain thousands and thousands of parts, you usually end up with the resultant brain-storming at Company B: "Oh, that's how they did it. Now we can tweak their design here and here, to make it bigger / better / faster / cheaper. That'll also make our patent lawyers happier."
Did Boeing really think that Chinese Mythical Aviation LLC was going to go to a junkyard in the State of Washington and buy up the old jigs, un-bend them, and therefore make a 75 knock-off cheaper?
In both types of cases, it's guys & gals in thousand-dollar suits jockeying for position. The games are won by singles and walks; grand slams mostly occur in fiction.