AirAsia A320 Possibly Missing

From what we've been told by our instructors, who were told from Bombardier, AOA is not reliable at high altitude.
If the wings are working why would the probes become unreliable (no ice)? They work on the same principle. The fact that it's even being taught should require further investigation.
 
If the wings are working why would the probes become unreliable (no ice)? They work on the same principle. The fact that it's even being taught should require further investigation.

I can't remember the exact terms that were being used, but it has to do with high altitude aerodynamics. I'll see if I can drum it up in my notes.
 
I can't remember the exact terms that were being used, but it has to do with high altitude aerodynamics. I'll see if I can drum it up in my notes.
I would appreciate that. Perhaps the probes are somehow blocked from the slipstream from a high mach number on the nose and the wing isn't affected as much due to its size.
 
More money, more time off.

Besides, the world doesn't really care where your engines or slung or if your toilet has a vacuum flush or not.

"My BMW has push-to-start!"

*silence*

"Camaaaaaan, it's got push-to-start! Just push the button and vvrrrrrRROOOM!"

*silence*


"So does my Nissan Altima, and I spent a third of what you did.........."


*awkward silence*
 
I can't remember the exact terms that were being used, but it has to do with high altitude aerodynamics. I'll see if I can drum it up in my notes.

That dont make sense. Indicated airspeed is indicated airpseed. Ground and true speeds are irrevalant unless close to reaching the speed of sound. But maybe Im missing something.
 
I would appreciate that. Perhaps the probes are somehow blocked from the slipstream from a high mach number on the nose and the wing isn't affected as much due to its size.

Seems I failed on this one. But our instructors are pretty cool. I'll send one of them an email, because now my mind needs an answer.
 
That dont make sense. Indicated airspeed is indicated airpseed. Ground and true speeds are irrevalant unless close to reaching the speed of sound. But maybe Im missing something.

I thought the same thing.

"How is it that this thing is unreliable just because of our altitude?"

But I have limited space available up there in muh noggen. So who knows, maybe I'm all screwed up. I'm trying to get an answer from the powers that be.
 
Regardless of glass cockpits and autopilots, it seems like a lot more emphasis needs to be spent on AOA awareness. The military uses AOA as a primary flight instrument, in recent years systems for small aircraft have dropped in price dramatically. When I went and got my PPL one of the main things my instructor taught about approach/landing was to look outside and memorize the correct sight picture, obviously the 152 I was flying didn't have an AOA indicator, but what I think he was trying to get me to recognize was the correct AOA. An Airbus pilot at 36K isn't going to necessarily be able to look out the window and get a reference but I don't think I've read that they lost AOA indication.

AOA is definitely getting affordable for GA. A couple friends of mine are aerospace engineers at this place, and they love their AOA over there. Icon is paving the way for making AOA data available to general aviation pilots, and while I feel it's partially being played up for marketing, I hope other manufacturers follow suit.



Also, we all fly that Cessna 175 in the video. [/hijack] :)
 
Seems I failed on this one. But our instructors are pretty cool. I'll send one of them an email, because now my mind needs an answer.

I'm digging WAY back now, but I seem to remember a bulletin that Bombardier put out for the CRJ about AOA vanes becoming unreliable during banking maneuvers during gusty wind conditions. One probe would lag or lead the other due to the wind gusts on a single side. I experienced this a few times and the result with normally a momentary stick shaker or stall warning. It got your attention but by the time you figured out what it was, it was gone. I can't think of ever reading anything about high altitude AOA vane limitations.

@EDUC8-or? Anything?
 
AOA is definitely getting affordable for GA. A couple friends of mine are aerospace engineers at this place, and they love their AOA over there. Icon is paving the way for making AOA data available to general aviation pilots, and while I feel it's partially being played up for marketing, I hope other manufacturers follow suit.



Also, we all fly that Cessna 175 in the video. [/hijack] :)

Having flown AoA, I think we should all but remove airspeed indicators from cockpits. Flying by reference to airspeed is akin to going to the moon on a donkey.
 
That's too much for an Altima, but I presume it was for the wife though. Am I right? :)

Hell yes! My car is an Acura TL. I don't drive no stinkin 4 cylinders!

And the Altima is just a standard 2010 model 2.5S sedan. I think those all came with push to start buttons.
 
Proper response: Yeah.

(pause)

But it's an Altima."

:)

(I'll admit, the joke only works if the delivery is right.)

It's a Beamer. Those suck these days. The last good Beamer was the 2001 7 series. The classic look. They have long since effed up a great car. Far too many disasters. Don't even get me started on the original iDrive.

For the same price range Id rather go for a Japanese luxury car.
 
Having flown AoA, I think we should all but remove airspeed indicators from cockpits. Flying by reference to airspeed is akin to going to the moon on a donkey.

And that's why you're just a pilot. :)
 
Back
Top