AirAsia A320 Possibly Missing

We do stalls at every recurrent at DL with the emphasis on protecting the alpha, not the altitude.

High altitude unreliable instrumentation is thoroughly covered in initial checkout as well.
Flight safety does high altitude upset recovery to. It's not part of the checkride, but every time I've been there... for 3 different types, we've done it in the sim. And yes, you have 3X,000 ft. You have to lose some, er well, a lot of it.
 
Captain was an ex-fighter pilot.

Maybe we all need to start practicing stall recoveries while embedded in thunderstorms? We'll get an abnormal like both FACs failing, stuck trim perhaps...Engine flameouts?
 
Regardless of glass cockpits and autopilots, it seems like a lot more emphasis needs to be spent on AOA awareness. The military uses AOA as a primary flight instrument, in recent years systems for small aircraft have dropped in price dramatically. When I went and got my PPL one of the main things my instructor taught about approach/landing was to look outside and memorize the correct sight picture, obviously the 152 I was flying didn't have an AOA indicator, but what I think he was trying to get me to recognize was the correct AOA. An Airbus pilot at 36K isn't going to necessarily be able to look out the window and get a reference but I don't think I've read that they lost AOA indication.


From what we've been told by our instructors, who were told from Bombardier, AOA is not reliable at high altitude.
 
Not proclaiming to be super pilot. no argument here that high altitude stalls can be difficult or confusing, especially when we're not exposed to them often in training. That being said, and I realize we don't have all the facts in this incident, it's the decisions leading up to these stalls that are alarming. AF447, not flying around the storm, or the 757 off of South America were the crew had a faulty airspeed indicator and continued the takeoff, then got confused as to which one is working. And once it gets to the point of the stall, it shouldn't progress to the point where we can't recover in 37000ft. Maybe it's not just the pilots fault, maybe its a training issue as well. If you think theres a good excuse for any of these planes stalling out of the sky Id love to hear it.
Um, yes, I would say it's a training issue. Again, we don't do a lot of high altitude handling beyond "let's pretend the autothrottles are deferred and oh hello, low speed event." And almost everyone gets some form of high altitude stall exposure now, but it's not enough to just stall and recover. Actually flying the airplane at high altitude beyond managing exceptional situations isn't really done.

@Cherokee_Cruiser nailed it. And we do our high speed stall recoveries with a similar emphasis on stuffing the nose down too as @PeanuckleCRJ alludes to above as well, but that's about it.
 
Um, yes, I would say it's a training issue. Again, we don't do a lot of high altitude handling beyond "let's pretend the autothrottles are deferred and oh hello, low speed event." And almost everyone gets some form of high altitude stall exposure now, but it's not enough to just stall and recover. Actually flying the airplane at high altitude beyond managing exceptional situations isn't really done.

@Cherokee_Cruiser nailed it. And we do our high speed stall recoveries with a similar emphasis on stuffing the nose down too as @PeanuckleCRJ alludes to above as well, but that's about it.
I got to try my hand at hand flying a lear for about 30 seconds above RVSM.(George protested) It's actually pretty hard, and not something I'd want to do... really ever. Just keeping it level at cruise speeds is incredibly difficult(or at least a saturating task) and you're sitting there not too far from both the high and low speed buffets. Pilot induced oscillation comes to mind.
 
Stall warning was blaring from 37k to impact. It will be interesting to see what the control inputs were when the data is released.
 
As I understand it.

On an AirBus the sticks don't move together. Assuming the FO is flying the Captains stick is completely motionless. True?

If that's the case if both the Captain and FO are giving inputs which one is the plane responding to?
 
As I understand it.

On an AirBus the sticks don't move together. Assuming the FO is flying the Captains stick is completely motionless. True?

If that's the case if both the Captain and FO are giving inputs which one is the plane responding to?

Correct the side sticks don't move on their own.

The Aural Warning starts yelling "Dual Input" when both pilots are simultaneously giving inputs. The inputs are summed in this case.

There's a button on the stick to "takeover" which basically locks out the other side. I'm sure all this data is recorded.
 
Correct the side sticks don't move on their own.

The Aural Warning starts yelling "Dual Input" when both pilots are simultaneously giving inputs. The inputs are summed in this case.

There's a button on the stick to "takeover" which basically locks out the other side. I'm sure all this data is recorded.

This was an issue on AF447, wasn't it? As I recall, there were dual inputs, the warning went off, and then I think both pilots were hitting the takeover buttons, weren't they?

I gotta go back and re-read the story...
 
I'm just winding my clock while thinking about the intensity of the storm along with proximity to the equator.

We're pretty lucky up in the higher latitudes. We get massive storms, they generally happen over America's "bargain basement" states so there are plenty of options for avoidance.

Down toward the equator, the storms are unlike anything you'll experience in the US because they can be smaller, but HYPER intense. Mix that with some language barriers, FIR boundaries, systems failures and a lack of strong knowledge of equatorial meteorology, I wouldn't be so fast to judge.

Hell, I've seen the toughest "been there, done that at two different airlines" square-jawed wanna-be Maverick from Top Gun fumble around like a nervous toddler when they hit something as simple as WATRS airspace and there's a smidgen of weather.

We really don't know. Yet. And that's ok.
 
It's an airplane, a bid and a job. Not necessarily an imaginary extension of my penis! :) I would fly a Seneca at mainline as long as the money, the contract and the bases were attractive enough.

When guys get all excited about the possibility of E175's coming on property, I tell them "if they paid me enough money to fly a Cessna 150 around full of rubber dog scat to enjoy my time off, I'd do it. Who cares what we fly, MMMTO!"
 
When guys get all excited about the possibility of E175's coming on property, I tell them "if they paid me enough money to fly a Cessna 150 around full of rubber dog scat to enjoy my time off, I'd do it. Who cares what we fly, MMMTO!"

More money, more time off.

Besides, the world doesn't really care where your engines are slung or if your toilet has a vacuum flush or not.

"My BMW has push-to-start!"

*silence*

"Camaaaaaan, it's got push-to-start! Just push the button and vvrrrrrRROOOM!"

*silence*
 
Last edited:
Maybe he meant this FiFi.....
image.jpg
 
I'm just winding my clock while thinking about the intensity of the storm along with proximity to the equator.

We're pretty lucky up in the higher latitudes. We get massive storms, they generally happen over America's "bargain basement" states so there are plenty of options for avoidance.

Down toward the equator, the storms are unlike anything you'll experience in the US because they can be smaller, but HYPER intense. Mix that with some language barriers, FIR boundaries, systems failures and a lack of strong knowledge of equatorial meteorology, I wouldn't be so fast to judge.

Hell, I've seen the toughest "been there, done that at two different airlines" square-jawed wanna-be Maverick from Top Gun fumble around like a nervous toddler when they hit something as simple as WATRS airspace and there's a smidgen of weather.

We really don't know. Yet. And that's ok.
It's also one of the most volcanic regions in the world. Just some more baseless speculation.
 
Back
Top