AirAsia A320 Possibly Missing

We don't know enough of what happened to say they flew a perfectly good plane into the ocean. I'm not going to throw guys under the bus yet saying they can't fly with the autopilot off.

Enter a thunderstorm, plane gets thrown 6000fpm plus for thousands of feet above Rec Max, massive G's, possible structural failures, stall....

This isn't just getting slow and stalling and recovering wings level over a beautiful landscape.

I see you have enjoyed severe turbulence too.
 
We don't know enough of what happened to say they flew a perfectly good plane into the ocean. I'm not going to throw guys under the bus yet saying they can't fly with the autopilot off.

Enter a thunderstorm, plane gets thrown 6000fpm plus for thousands of feet above Rec Max, massive G's, possible structural failures, stall....

This isn't just getting slow and stalling and recovering wings level over a beautiful landscape.

I agree with you there. But so far, like I said, the evidence looks pretty damning.
 
I don't think I've been in anything comparing to what these fellows found themselves, nothing that left anything bent or anybody hurt. Nothing that sent me thousands of feet off of altitude while busting my FACs or other similar onboard computer system. Nor have I been in a high altitude stall recovery from said severe conditions.....Which is why I'm not condemning them. I simply don't know much other than they were in severe wx, and while in it had a dual FAC failure.

Practice stalls all you want. Lets practice stalls while at 41000'/unusual attitude and with no airspeed to make it realistic.
 
We realize transport category aircraft are pretty stable ships right? It's usually not until "we" go screwing with that stability that something bad happens.

AF447 woulda popped right on out the other side of that storm if the FO hadn't jerked the plane all over the place.

As far as this incident, no comment yet beyond the similarities are interesting.
 
Getting pretty sick of hearing about airline pilots stalling aircraft from 37000ft all the way down to the ocean. This is starting to look very similar to 447.
 
We realize transport category aircraft are pretty stable ships right? It's usually not until "we" go screwing with that stability that something bad happens.

AF447 woulda popped right on out the other side of that storm if the FO hadn't jerked the plane all over the place.

As far as this incident, no comment yet beyond the similarities are interesting.
Indeed. The correct reaction when the autopilot knocks itself offline is not to stir the pot, but to, um, fly the airplane.

Whether or not the accident pilots, in the case of Air France 447, had the skill to fly the airplane in that environment is another matter, that deserves the attention of the regulators and training departments everywhere.

Getting pretty sick of hearing about airline pilots stalling aircraft from 37000ft all the way down to the ocean. This is starting to look very similar to 447.
The phenomenon of high altitude handling errors is not limited to airline pilots. And while things look superficially similar between these accidents, I would like to take you and put you into that cockpit and see what you do when suddenly blessed with a handful of airplane whose flight instruments appear at odd purposes, Mr. Superpilot.

That said, high-altitude hand-flying isn't really a thing that we get to practice...well, ever, now that I think of it. You might get exposed to it in initial simulator when we do the "let's break all the flight instruments" day, but you probably don't see it in recurrent, and you're not even permitted to kick off Otto in RVSM airspace. I will admit (with some gnashing of my teeth at the fact that apparently this is a problem) that anyone with an instrument rating should be able to corral it somewhat within PTS and get out of the high altitude environment without stalling, but a dynamic situation at high altitude is not to be trifled with.

I would love some more high altitude handling training, personally, although you can sum it up with "go neither slow, nor too fast."

Can computers even accurately simulate these kinds of situations?
Uh, why wouldn't they be able to?

Now whether or not the simulator manufacturers bothered to include legitimate high altitude upsets in the simulator's flight envelope is another matter, but sure, that can be modeled.
 
I have. Looking out at the wing of an airplane you know has had a hard life and praying it stays attached is never fun. Neither is having your head set knocked off from said turbulence.
I find it preferable to not look and assume (hope? pray?) that the wings are still attached, personally, but indeed. When the headset departs your noggin and heads for the overhead panel, you tend to think in the metaphysical.
 
The phenomenon of high altitude handling errors is not limited to airline pilots. And while things look superficially similar between these accidents, I would like to take you and put you into that cockpit and see what you do when suddenly blessed with a handful of airplane whose flight instruments appear at odd purposes, Mr. Superpilot.

.

Not proclaiming to be super pilot. no argument here that high altitude stalls can be difficult or confusing, especially when we're not exposed to them often in training. That being said, and I realize we don't have all the facts in this incident, it's the decisions leading up to these stalls that are alarming. AF447, not flying around the storm, or the 757 off of South America were the crew had a faulty airspeed indicator and continued the takeoff, then got confused as to which one is working. And once it gets to the point of the stall, it shouldn't progress to the point where we can't recover in 37000ft. Maybe it's not just the pilots fault, maybe its a training issue as well. If you think theres a good excuse for any of these planes stalling out of the sky Id love to hear it.
 
Why can't CNN rent a sim for an hour? The media once again hires a mickey mouse sim made out of plywood for the story.... http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/29/asia/airasia-disaster/index.html

Not denying that they should use a sim that is an actual representation of the airplane in question, but a full motion redbird sim is hardly a "plywood box."

This is the sim they were using in the video. For an AATD, it's actually kind of bad ass.
http://www.redbirdflightsimulations...sc=71320972.1.1422557742615&__hsfp=2626667494
 
Indeed. The correct reaction when the autopilot knocks itself offline is not to stir the pot, but to, um, fly the airplane.

Whether or not the accident pilots, in the case of Air France 447, had the skill to fly the airplane in that environment is another matter, that deserves the attention of the regulators and training departments everywhere.


The phenomenon of high altitude handling errors is not limited to airline pilots. And while things look superficially similar between these accidents, I would like to take you and put you into that cockpit and see what you do when suddenly blessed with a handful of airplane whose flight instruments appear at odd purposes, Mr. Superpilot.

That said, high-altitude hand-flying isn't really a thing that we get to practice...well, ever, now that I think of it. You might get exposed to it in initial simulator when we do the "let's break all the flight instruments" day, but you probably don't see it in recurrent, and you're not even permitted to kick off Otto in RVSM airspace. I will admit (with some gnashing of my teeth at the fact that apparently this is a problem) that anyone with an instrument rating should be able to corral it somewhat within PTS and get out of the high altitude environment without stalling, but a dynamic situation at high altitude is not to be trifled with.

I would love some more high altitude handling training, personally, although you can sum it up with "go neither slow, nor too fast."


Uh, why wouldn't they be able to?

Now whether or not the simulator manufacturers bothered to include legitimate high altitude upsets in the simulator's flight envelope is another matter, but sure, that can be modeled.



Hand flying an aircraft from takeoff to 10,000 ft is different than hand flying one in the FL3xx's. In crusie, we all fly with the AP on. I've never had a guy just randomly at FL350 click it off and say "I'm just gonna hand fly to stay proficient." It doesn't happen. The key fact remains that we as pilots do not hand fly in the less dense air that is in the FL3xx's. Even George gets conservative up there and limits to half-bank in nearly all passenger jetliners. As far as accidents are concerned in terms of AF447 and QZ8501, it seems the pilots took manual control and then proceeded to control the aircraft as if it was at 1,000 - 3,000 ft -----> 10-15 degrees nose up and bank to 30 degrees.

Pilots need sim sessions in the FL3xxx's in which the AP is failed and they forced to handfly. Then put it in a stall scenario and make the pilot recover. These should be mandatory PC/PT events in every sim session. At our Co we are already doing the RNAV approach as AP off and A/Thrust off after the Asiana crash. It's time for industry-wide sweeping changes in pilot training in the less dense air where we spend 90% of our times. Yes, it's all common sense and one would think so, but recent fatality numbers say otherwise. And it's not just Air France or Air Asia, it's industry wide. Their training syllabus and programs aren't much different from other Airbus programs found at other airlines.
 
Hand flying an aircraft from takeoff to 10,000 ft is different than hand flying one in the FL3xx's. In crusie, we all fly with the AP on. I've never had a guy just randomly at FL350 click it off and say "I'm just gonna hand fly to stay proficient." It doesn't happen. The key fact remains that we as pilots do not hand fly in the less dense air that is in the FL3xx's. Even George gets conservative up there and limits to half-bank in nearly all passenger jetliners. As far as accidents are concerned in terms of AF447 and QZ8501, it seems the pilots took manual control and then proceeded to control the aircraft as if it was at 1,000 - 3,000 ft -----> 10-15 degrees nose up and bank to 30 degrees.

Pilots need sim sessions in the FL3xxx's in which the AP is failed and they forced to handfly. Then put it in a stall scenario and make the pilot recover. These should be mandatory PC/PT events in every sim session. At our Co we are already doing the RNAV approach as AP off and A/Thrust off after the Asiana crash. It's time for industry-wide sweeping changes in pilot training in the less dense air where we spend 90% of our times. Yes, it's all common sense and one would think so, but recent fatality numbers say otherwise. And it's not just Air France or Air Asia, it's industry wide. Their training syllabus and programs aren't much different from other Airbus programs found at other airlines.

IIRC, we did high altitude stalls in last years event. It takes a helluva lot of power/altitude/airspeed to get it back to normal flying again at altitude. So much so that most people don't recognize that it isn't time yet to raise the nose back up and try and get back to some semblance of normal flying again. Most people induced a secondary stall while trying to recover. I know I did on my first go of it. Mind = blown!
 
We do stalls at every recurrent at DL with the emphasis on protecting the alpha, not the altitude.

High altitude unreliable instrumentation is thoroughly covered in initial checkout as well.
 
Regardless of glass cockpits and autopilots, it seems like a lot more emphasis needs to be spent on AOA awareness. The military uses AOA as a primary flight instrument, in recent years systems for small aircraft have dropped in price dramatically. When I went and got my PPL one of the main things my instructor taught about approach/landing was to look outside and memorize the correct sight picture, obviously the 152 I was flying didn't have an AOA indicator, but what I think he was trying to get me to recognize was the correct AOA. An Airbus pilot at 36K isn't going to necessarily be able to look out the window and get a reference but I don't think I've read that they lost AOA indication.
 
Back
Top