Virgin- Zero time to A330 copilot!

The Lufthansa scheme goes further than any other civilian programs I know of - they all do their Instrument Ratings in baby Citations. You see them doing patterns at Bremen the whole time. I do t know what sort of total time they have when they go on to the bus but they already have a good grounding of jet flying, descent profiles and so on.
 
The Lufthansa scheme goes further than any other civilian programs I know of - they all do their Instrument Ratings in baby Citations. You see them doing patterns at Bremen the whole time. I do t know what sort of total time they have when they go on to the bus but they already have a good grounding of jet flying, descent profiles and so on.

Unfortunately, the general gripe isn't about aircraft types flown; let's be real, any monkey can learn "descent profiles". Just about anyone with a PPL can be taught to "fly" a Citation.

The intangible we're talking about here is airmanship, which is learned/earned through experience. Better airmanship is usually the result from a wider variety of experience. Generally, the more a pilot has to use his judgment to affect the safe/efficient outcome of the flight, the more sharp and well defined that airmanship is going to be.

The general complaint is that ab-initio programs have such a narrow band of operating experience that it doesn't allow the pilot to develop much in the way of airmanship. That the types of operation, the locations, the weather, etc, don't require the pilot to actually use any real judgment, and thus that aspect isn't exercised or sharpened.

This is a problem even with the much-acclaimed military process, that new SUPT graduates have not had the opportunity to operate out of the limited and highly restrictive training environment, and thus need a good amount of seasoning in which they can develop their judgment and decisionmaking. This is with pilots who have been trained in a multiengine, aerobatic, supersonic jet, and trained to fly all manner of instrument, cross-country, formation, low-level high-speed navigation, and aerobatics...and we STILL don't consider them ready for prime-time until they've had a year's worth of seasoning to let their airmanship develop.

Given the natural limitations of a syllabus and a paid training program, there is just no way to grow the same type of airmanship that develops from "real world" flying. In Lufthansa's case, you end up with a pilot who has simply operated in that same limited, narrow training environment but in a Citation.
 
Unfortunately, the general gripe isn't about aircraft types flown; let's be real, any monkey can learn "descent profiles". Just about anyone with a PPL can be taught to "fly" a Citation.

The intangible we're talking about here is airmanship, which is learned/earned through experience. Better airmanship is usually the result from a wider variety of experience. Generally, the more a pilot has to use his judgment to affect the safe/efficient outcome of the flight, the more sharp and well defined that airmanship is going to be.

The general complaint is that ab-initio programs have such a narrow band of operating experience that it doesn't allow the pilot to develop much in the way of airmanship. That the types of operation, the locations, the weather, etc, don't require the pilot to actually use any real judgment, and thus that aspect isn't exercised or sharpened.

This is a problem even with the much-acclaimed military process, that new SUPT graduates have not had the opportunity to operate out of the limited and highly restrictive training environment, and thus need a good amount of seasoning in which they can develop their judgment and decisionmaking. This is with pilots who have been trained in a multiengine, aerobatic, supersonic jet, and trained to fly all manner of instrument, cross-country, formation, low-level high-speed navigation, and aerobatics...and we STILL don't consider them ready for prime-time until they've had a year's worth of seasoning to let their airmanship develop.

Given the natural limitations of a syllabus and a paid training program, there is just no way to grow the same type of airmanship that develops from "real world" flying. In Lufthansa's case, you end up with a pilot who has simply operated in that same limited, narrow training environment but in a Citation.


Which comes back to the original question I asked, at what point is one "good enough"?
 
Which comes back to the original question I asked, at what point is one "good enough"?

And clearly there's no concensus:

If we're really concerned about the quality of pilot produced by ANY ab-initio program, we have to first agree on what types of training and experience are necessary to have a pilot acceptable for operating in the environment he is designated to fly in.

Unfortunately, here's where the conversation goes off the rails, right from the start. We don't all agree on what makes a good pilot, or even what the minimum acceptable performance standard is. Unfortunately, it is an argument that really can't be "won" because we all come from such diverse sets of training and experience, and we all think our way is the best way.

That doesn't even get us to the next big "fight", the cost-vs-quality balance that will be performed in just designing a program to achieve that objective, much less implementing the program and executing it.
 
The truth is that none of us are ever good enough. That's the nature of being a professional, you always have more to learn, there's always a way you could have made a particular flight better, there's always something to improve. If you're not continuously trying to improve your flying and airmanship, you're doing it wrong.
 
Ab Intio is a money game and big investment to the airline. They have a vested interest to see that candidate makes it through past a certain point. I'm sure the military has no problems cutting candidates at anytime during the program if performance warrants it.

In the Ab Intio training i saw, the program appeared to have higher accident/incident rates in training than the traditional 141 US program did.

For those that haven't read it here is the AF 447. It a long article but worth the time.

http://www.vanityfair.com/business/2014/10/air-france-flight-447-crash
 
Europe has ab initio programs because there just isn't that much interest in professional aviation and the barriers to entry are huge.

I can't say that I agree with that. It may have been true over 10 years ago, but today is different. Here is why. Before JAA/EASA, the requirements for getting a commercial license were different for each country. In the UK, 700 hours was the minimum to get a commercial license unless you went through an ab initio program. With the introduction of pan-European harmonization, the requirements dropped to 200 hours for "modular" students and "170" for integrated syllabus students. Modular and integrated would roughly equate to 61 vs 141. There are several schools in Europe that specialize in the integrated route and they have very close ties with airlines for doing ab initio training.

With the rise of LCCs across Europe, lots of young folks went out and got money from their parents (some getting second mortgages) and some getting loans, and some working for it the old fashioned way, but the result was lots of guys getting their 170-200 hours and then getting hired straight into Airbus and Boeing operators across Europe. There is a large surplus of low houred pilots in Europe trying to get their first break. In fact, pilot training in Europe didn't see a slow down until 2013, despite the economic crisis hitting 5 years earlier.

Operators such as Virgin Atlantic have plenty of applications on file, many from LCC pilots and expats in the Middle East and elsewhere. Virgin Atlantic still plans on hiring pilots that meet their direct entry requirements of 3000TT, but this ab initio cadet program is pure marketing. The website for applying crashed the first day, as info about the program was plastered all over BBC and every other news outlet.

Lufthansa's and Air France's ab initio programs are a bit different, as that is where he source most of their pilots (not that they need to but that's what they want), but BA and Virgin Atlantic only source a small number of their pilots from ab initio programs.

I worked at a European school for a year and worked on the syllabi. We did both integrated and modular, and there wasn't anything really different about he syllabus except that the modular students flew extra hours on their own. Same airplanes, same instructors. Some of the newer ab initio programs are now done with the MPL syllabus, but even Lufthansa tried that and went back to the integrated syllabus.
 
Despite being a European I did my training the old fashioned way CFI-ing in the US, but most of my colleagues didn't have the opportunity to gain as much experience before joining the airlines. Because of the economic slowdown mentioned above, most of them had to do some GA flying while waiting for the airlines to begin hiring again, but they had accumulated at most 400-600 hours instructing or flying jumpers (mind the GA over here is very limited and 200 hours a year is pretty good). Before the recession people were commonly getting hired by the LCCs or even some national carriers with just 200 hours. Even during the slowdown Europe's biggest LCC was preferring fresh graduates (and still does). There is not much difference in experience gained between airline ab initio training and the traditional route in Europe. The major difference is cost, since some of those airline programs can cost well above $100,000. So, while I'd like to see more GA activity in Europe so that pilots joining the airlines had more experience, the ab initio programs are not the biggest problem. I'm more concerned about MPL programs and I think with the 1500h rule, you guys are going to see that one coming to the States soon as an alternative to the regular career path.
 
There is not much difference in experience gained between airline ab initio training and the traditional route in Europe. The major difference is cost, since some of those airline programs can cost well above $100,000. .

This ^^ at my school, we charged $15,000 more for a course just because it was "integrated" and not modular, yet modular students got 50 more flying hours in the whole course. Students were willing to pay more because the ab initio programs have that "integrated" syllabus label.
 
Back
Top