Virgin- Zero time to A330 copilot!

Lufthansa has had an ab initio program here at GYR for as long as I can remember, with the yellow Bonanzas/Barons, and at one time T-34Bs also.
 
I see writings but no substance.

Most of the progressive airlines with good ab-initio programs make the first good decision to train their pilots in foreign countries, namely, the United States and Australia. Air France uses France's EPAG for their cadets. Lufthansa, Sabena (back when it existed), and many Asian airlines train their pilots here and then take them back home for numerous sim sessions. Lufthansa was the main developer of the ab-initio program. They have perfected it to a good art form. AF should have modified their ab initio program. A good start would be letting their cadets train here in the USA, Canada, or Australia.
 
I've always thought of civilian vs. military training as occupying two extremes - the LEAST competitively selected pool (many of my students immediately come to mind) vs. the MOST competitively selected pool. Both flying airplanes.

Not putting down civilians (being one myself) as we can still be excellent pilots, and the difficulty of CFI & ATP ratings can be decent selectors.

But picturing a USAF pilot training class vs. the motley crew of yo-yos that would show up at the part 141 flight school on the first day of the year is frankly humorous.

Advance apologies if I offended anyone. I'm sure you're a great pilot!

My guess is that most wouldn't have the "blank check" approach to training like the military, either. The military puts out a great pilot in a relatively short period of time, but spends a GOB of money in the process.

My guess is this is something that an operator that puts "training" in the expense column isn't apt to do. This is where the comparison of programs that produce 300 hour wonders to the military falls apart.

Richman
 
If we're really concerned about the quality of pilot produced by ANY ab-initio program, we have to first agree on what types of training and experience are necessary to have a pilot acceptable for operating in the environment he is designated to fly in.

Unfortunately, here's where the conversation goes off the rails, right from the start. We don't all agree on what makes a good pilot, or even what the minimum acceptable performance standard is. Unfortunately, it is an argument that really can't be "won" because we all come from such diverse sets of training and experience, and we all think our way is the best way.

That doesn't even get us to the next big "fight", the cost-vs-quality balance that will be performed in just designing a program to achieve that objective, much less implementing the program and executing it.
 
Lufthansa has had an ab initio program here at GYR for as long as I can remember, with the yellow Bonanzas/Barons, and at one time T-34Bs also.

Regularly we'd have to look for "Lost Bananas" out in the Cessna North practice area.
 
Most of the progressive airlines with good ab-initio programs make the first good decision to train their pilots in foreign countries, namely, the United States and Australia. Air France uses France's EPAG for their cadets. Lufthansa, Sabena (back when it existed), and many Asian airlines train their pilots here and then take them back home for numerous sim sessions. Lufthansa was the main developer of the ab-initio program. They have perfected it to a good art form. AF should have modified their ab initio program. A good start would be letting their cadets train here in the USA, Canada, or Australia.

Oh so flight training, specifically ab initio training, is an 'art form' now.

Ok. Thanks. Makes tons of sense...
 
Oh so flight training, specifically ab initio training, is an 'art form' now.

Ok. Thanks. Makes tons of sense...

IMO, it has been an art form. It takes a certain aptitude and skill set from the pilot's side, and a rigorous, stringent, and thorough training program from the airline side to make an ab-initio program safe and effective. So in that sense yes it is an art form. In the United States, I'd say the military has this art form down pat.
 
FWIW, and if anyone cares, ALPA, at their Board of Director's meeting last week made "oppose any efforts to roll back the First Officer Minimum Qualification rule and oppose alternate certification methods" as one of their strategic priorities.

My guess is any ab initio type programs here will be firmly opposed, at least the 300 hour, still got Funions residue on their fingers, Euro style version ("it's not a purse...it's a shoulder bag...and it was a gift") and will probably make it more trouble than it's worth.

The good news about the institutional inertia this industry has, at least in the US, is we get to see all the bad ideas others try play out first. A smart man learns from his own mistakes. A wise man learns from the mistakes of others.

Richman
 
IMO, it has been an art form. It takes a certain aptitude and skill set from the pilot's side, and a rigorous, stringent, and thorough training program from the airline side to make an ab-initio program safe and effective. So in that sense yes it is an art form. In the United States, I'd say the military has this art form down pat.

An art form doesn't have a rigid set of standards. It allows for an expressionist way to get an end result.

I would say the military has a rigid set of standards. You don't conform to those standards, you are out. You are correlating ab-inition training with military training. Fine. In an ideal world I can see that. But then you are saying they are 'art forms'. FAAAAAAR from it. You are just trying to say things in an attempt to make it 'stick'. Not going to work.
 
An art form doesn't have a rigid set of standards. It allows for an expressionist way to get an end result.

I would say the military has a rigid set of standards. You don't conform to those standards, you are out. You are correlating ab-inition training with military training. Fine. In an ideal world I can see that. But then you are saying they are 'art forms'. FAAAAAAR from it. You are just trying to say things in an attempt to make it 'stick'. Not going to work.

I meant art as in 'fine, precise' form. Not all art is expressionist do whatever you want kinda thing.
 
Ok.

It has just been in my experience that there are many ways to 'skin the cat' in aviation. You don't need to be 'precise' every time. You need to get the job done safely. Sometimes that takes thinking outside of the box.
 
Ok.

It has just been in my experience that there are many ways to 'skin the cat' in aviation. You don't need to be 'precise' every time. You need to get the job done safely. Sometimes that takes thinking outside of the box.

I dunno. Lufthansa seems to have a pretty good safety record. And they do ab initio. If you look at their record, most of the accidents they have had are from terrorist attacks. None of them are from the ab initio era. I'm not really a fan of it, but if it's fine right, it works just fine.
 
Eh. My spidery sense tells me anyone pitching a program for low timers who isn't a low timer themselves, is looking to make a buck somewhere.

Grumpy Dragon's been right 10 times out of 10 on this one.

Richman
 
Back
Top