Hey I'm the first to admit that OpenAirplane isn't for everyone. It sounds like you've had good experiences with renting airplanes, I with that was typical. Just a couple of thoughts...
- Most FBOs require you to invest hundreds of dollars and half a day before you can rent their airplanes. This is a hassle and expense that pilots tell us keeps them from flying when away from their home base 51% of the time. (A survey of US pilots we conducted in 2011.)
- We publish a detailed Local Procedures Briefing for all our Operators. This is an opportunity for them to document their tribal knowledge and show up ready to fly with the confidence of a local. Here's and example: https://www.openairplane.com/operators/chicago-executive-flight-school/#op-localprod
Not trying to change your mind about this, just pointing out what we built to make renting airplane easier, safer, and more fun.
While I would love to see something like this work, there seem to be several challenges around this.
One, airspace and terrain variations, has already been pointed out. But this is a huge deal. I would argue that a once a year checkout on theoretical aspects of complex airspace with perhaps even some actual practice in complex airspace is not enough to ensure proficiency navigating around LAX or SFO. I flew VFR several times a week in SFO, and IFR the other days of the week in and out of all kinds of complex airspace all over the country. But when I moved to LAX, I was still rather trepidatious and sought advice about local controller customs, landmarks, and navigating the VFR routes. As regards mountain flying, there are certainly some general commonalities regarding the dos and don'ts. But to be really safe, one must know the specific peculiarities of the specific area in which one wants to fly. Local terrain, local Wx patterns, anomalies, and wind flows are what kills people in the mountains. There is no safer way to ascertain this knowledge than consulting/flying with an experienced local pilot/instructor.
Two, there is a tremendous amount of risk and liability in renting airplanes, which I imagine elicits a high degree of caution on the part of those renting airplanes. This is similar to when an employer is hiring a new pilot. The pilot may look awesome on paper, and the pilot may actually be awesome in reality, but hiring organizations are still going to want a skills check of their own doing.
And, (2.5), checkouts don't have to be long. When I did renter checkouts, I could tell in about 5 minutes of subtly-asked questions and pre-flight whether the person was going to be safe or not. If the person seemed solid, we'd start with a turn in the pattern to a crosswindy runway (if possible). If the first turn was good, on the second turn I'd pull the engine abeam the departure numbers. If the pilot performed the correct checks, maintained correct SA, AOA, & A/S, and landed decently, I could be fairly certain he was safe. I'd have him taxi, shut down, do a hot start, then a last shut down and post-flight. Total time: ~1hr tot, 0.3-0.4 in the plane.
Three (and this is a generalization so it may not be worth a D), in my experience as an instructor I've noticed that the folks who don't seek advice are usually the ones who end up in trouble. Often times, a person's resistance to a checkout is the best indication that s/he needs one.
But I do like this concept and would like to see it work.