Is AOPA Legal a good thing to invest it?

Actually, it's a whole lot more than that. Putting in $99/yr for 40 years and compounding at 8% would yield a $25k return.
I was assuming 3.5% as a much more reasonable—if not generous—long term average. Granted, I'm building a lot of assumptions into that average that I'm not factoring into the $99/yr... but regardless, that very debatable rate is the absolute smallest point of my comment.

-Fox
 
I'm not measuring it wrong, at all. I can't afford a full aviation attorney defense that would go through all the various processes to the NTSB. I would guess a 100k citation captain couldn't afford it, either. It would be nice if @MidlifeFlyer could tell us a rough estimate of that cost. I personally know an aviation attorney who clears more than 100k who subscribes to the service, as does @MidlifeFlyer. That's really all I need to know. I'm guessing a full enforcement action could easily cost upwards of 50k.

Truth is, @ATN_Pilot makes a valid point when he says that there may in fact be a small amount of risk associated with the typical pilot. The question with insurance is always the same: what is the risk/benefit to me. That's a very personalized calculation. Some people self-insure their homes, their airplanes, their cars.

Typical enforcement action terminates, like most other litigation, with an agreed resolution at an early stage. In an FAA enforcement proceeding it's built into the system (for an overview of the flow, you can look at my powerpoint from an old talk at Slideshare. It's out of date - no discussion of the Pilots Bill of Rights - but the other information hasn't changed too much). That's typically going to amount to something less than 10 hours of attorney time unless there's some travel required. Get past that and time starts to mount. My typical trial day is about 10 hours billable and that's not including pre-trial prep time - interviewing witnesses, perhaps depositions, motions and arguments.

And then there's the appeals...

My risk/benefit calculation says the annual fee is worth it to me. That doesn't make someone who comes to a different conclusion for them wrong.
 
Back
Top