Cirruc chute pull, four survive

Yes. As do new build cessnas.

What do you think the problem is then? I know aluminum has some "give" to it (eg large plastic deformation curve) and will bend to some extent to absorb an impact. Carbon composite and fiberglass on the other hand has a very short elastic & plastic deformation curve. In other words they will take a lot of stress without bending, and then instead of bending and absorbing the force they just shatter spectacularly into little splinters of glass/carbon/resin.

Is that a fair assessment, and if so, do you think an AD as simple as a conventional fuel bladder in the wing that would be a more flexible barrier in case the composite ruptured?

I suspect the lesson here may be to not make wet wings out or brittle material. But I have no data to back that up. (Disclaimer: Not saying composite = dangerous. But it definitely raises new engineering problems and can't be treated conventionally.)
 
Can't blame bad judgement on an inanimate object.

I have seen a brake fire render a cirrus wing unusable, I never knew their gear legs were composite too.

Never flown one but I'd like to sometime


Sent from 1865 by telegraph....
 
What do you think the problem is then? I know aluminum has some "give" to it (eg large plastic deformation curve) and will bend to some extent to absorb an impact. Carbon composite and fiberglass on the other hand has a very short elastic & plastic deformation curve. In other words they will take a lot of stress without bending, and then instead of bending and absorbing the force they just shatter spectacularly into little splinters of glass/carbon/resin.

Is that a fair assessment, and if so, do you think an AD as simple as a conventional fuel bladder in the wing that would be a more flexible barrier in case the composite ruptured?

I suspect the lesson here may be to not make wet wings out or brittle material. But I have no data to back that up. (Disclaimer: Not saying composite = dangerous. But it definitely raises new engineering problems and can't be treated conventionally.)

Exactly what I was trying to say, but being not so great at spitting it out. Needless to say, I've got no particular interest in any of the SR-2x series. I'll take my composite airplane in the form of a Diamond, with an actual fuel tank, between the two spars of the aircraft.
 
The bottom line here is that the CAPS system, when employed effectively works to save lives. And it does. Look at this list, and tell me what the outcome of the majority of these incidents would have been without CAPS being available as an option.

So long as it's used properly and within it's envelope, it has the best chance of working. Even then, there are no guarantees of having no injuries, depending on what the chute lets you down on, but that's not really something that can be controlled. What can be controlled, generally speaking, is the altitude/attitude/speed that you deploy it, in a controlled situation. In an uncontrolled situation.....structural failure, etc......you use it where you use it, and accept the cards you're dealt.
 
What do you think the problem is then? I know aluminum has some "give" to it (eg large plastic deformation curve) and will bend to some extent to absorb an impact. Carbon composite and fiberglass on the other hand has a very short elastic & plastic deformation curve. In other words they will take a lot of stress without bending, and then instead of bending and absorbing the force they just shatter spectacularly into little splinters of glass/carbon/resin.

Is that a fair assessment, and if so, do you think an AD as simple as a conventional fuel bladder in the wing that would be a more flexible barrier in case the composite ruptured?

I suspect the lesson here may be to not make wet wings out or brittle material. But I have no data to back that up. (Disclaimer: Not saying composite = dangerous. But it definitely raises new engineering problems and can't be treated conventionally.)
I don't know. I just thought it really, really odd that a runway excursion in a piston single on landing turned into a multiple fatality accident. It may have had more to do with the relatively high landing speeds of the cirrus compared to, say, a 172. But like I said, people go off the side of runways all the time in airplanes and don't burn up. You may be onto something with the brittleness of the cirrus wet wing though, I can see where you might wrinkle the skin on a conventional airplane and have minimal fuel leakage vs. cracking the composite and having a big spill. I'll see if I can dig up the accident report.
 
I don't know. I just thought it really, really odd that a runway excursion in a piston single on landing turned into a multiple fatality accident. It may have had more to do with the relatively high landing speeds of the cirrus compared to, say, a 172. But like I said, people go off the side of runways all the time in airplanes and don't burn up. You may be onto something with the brittleness of the cirrus wet wing though, I can see where you might wrinkle the skin on a conventional airplane and have minimal fuel leakage vs. cracking the composite and having a big spill. I'll see if I can dig up the accident report.

How about looking at the NTSB report on the incident before posting speculation here? The Cirrus' approach speed is NOT that much higher than a 172's. I fly over the fence at 70 knots in the 172. Over the fence at 78-80 in the Cirrus. Stall horn at 65 in the Cirrus, 62 in the 172. There are so many variables involved in accidents. Read the report. Start there. Don't fault the airplane before having all of the facts.

In every accident I've ever witnessed, someone has died, and there was an ensuing fireball. Well, except the B-1, and that pilot said he was lucky the airplane didn't turn into a cartwheeling fireball. T-45's, P-51, F-18, all of them. It's part of the inherent risk of flying airplanes; you may burn to your death.
 
I flew a 2008 Cirrus, and a 2011 Cessna 206. I have over 1500 hours in each one. Id take the Cirrus any day over the Cessna. Owner payed over 100K more for the Cessna than the Cirrus cost. (700K for a new 206 with all the options)

Its just typical of these forums with the Cirrus haters from guys who never flown them. Cirrus had two AHRS, dual alternators, known ice, parachute. Cessna had no ice protection, fell like a rock when the fan quit, no yaw dampener, one AHRS, one alternator.

Cirrus was 20 knots faster on 5 gph less fuel with 300 miles more range. The only advantage of the 206 was: 300 LBS more useful load, 2 more seats, otherwise you might just as well buy a 1970 model 206 because the only thing that changed since then is the avionics.

Im tired of the spin argument. They recover from spins just fine without the parachute. If you dont like it because its not certified or tested, then dont ever buy a twin.

And the attitude that pilots go into conditions because of the equipment or parachute. That may be true. I dont like flying the 206 over the Rocky mountains at night. Its my job though. I get paid to do it although If I lose my engine, Im dead. If I get the option between the two planes, Im going to use the one with the parachute. If I had the option to use the King Air, then Im going to use that. Am I dangerous because Im going into worse conditions in the King Air because its better equipped? Cirrus is hands down better equipped than the best 206.

/end rant
 
I fly the Cirrus for a living for a part 135 on demand operator in the Washington DC area, and I have been very impressed with the plane. You can't blame Cirrus for the bone headed mistakes that pilots make. Yes some of the Cirrus pilots out there have more money than brains, but you could say the same thing about Bonanza owners, Cessna owners, and Piper owners. As far as the plane catching on fire after a crash, when you have any airplane make sudden impact with the ground wingtips first, the results will not be favorable. I feel very safe flying the Cirrus. Like any airplane, you have to know and respect its limitations. If you plan to fly into lots of unimproved airports and intentionally go "off runway," a Piper Cub would be a better choice. For getting from point A to point B in comfort and safety and landing on a paved runway, I am very pleased with the Cirrus.
 
I'm gonna say it again....

Fixed gear, single engine, plastic, no integral fuel tank, approach speeds excess of 75kts.... When used at the right time I think the 'chute is a great Idea! It's really not the best airplane to be making emergency landings in off-field.

I liked flying them, would NEVER own one though....

Get over the fuel tank. Lots of airplanes have wet wings, including newer 172s. I dont care what kind of tank you have or dont, if there is fuel in there and you crash, most likely it will burn.

Pilots do stupid things in all aircraft, from flying lawn chairs to 747, we are and always will be the weakest link in safety.
 
Get over the fuel tank.

No.

Lots of airplanes have wet wings, including newer 172s.

Yes, but they're also made of aluminum, which is able to absorb much more energy in an impact than plastic. That boat hull Cirrus calls an airframe will either not break or break. No bending allowed, except where they engineered it to (vertical impact). If part the airframe doesn't break off with an impact where does the energy transfer to? The pilot.

A 172 is also a high wing, the wing could see a lot less impact damage as you reonnect with nature during an off-field emergency landing. Approach speeds are also much slower. You're comparing apples to bananas.

Pilots do stupid things in all aircraft, from flying lawn chairs to 747, we are and always will be the weakest link in safety.

Once again, I'm not talking about Dr. Umptyshcmuk piling the airplane in from CFIT or Spacial-D (I like that, I'm gonna use it). Bonanzas have done that for them for decades before the Cirrus was ever on the drawing board. I'm talking about having to do a little off-roading if the big fan quits. An off field landing where Bob Hoover, himself might have to render an airplane unusable afterward, but still come out alive. All the characteristics and design of the Cirrus make doing that an undesirable choice. In this case the fuel tanks do play a part, even though the pilot might be doing everything else right.
 
One has to look at the dynamics of the individual accidents themselves and how/why fire was involved. Simple stats of Bonanzas, Centurions, and Cirri won't give an accurate picture.

Oh, I wasn't even giving statistics. I just glanced over the database, and a lot of airplanes seem to burn after they crash. This is the first time I've heard anyone say the danger in a Cirrus is an unusually high incidence of post crash fire. So baring any other data, it seems like the post crash fire danger of the Cirrus is being exaggerated.

Stupid people and airplanes have been a bad mix for over 100 years. Hell, even before the Wright brothers actually flew there were some spectacular failures of people trying.
 
The pilot of this was a former CFI of mine and I have spoke with him about it.

There was a powerplant malfunction, he set it up for best glide and picked his field. Either the winds changed or the propeller turned into a giant windmill, probably a combination of both, and the field was no longer going to be doable. So, he pulled the chute. Nothing else could be done, and everyone walked away a few hours later. Good job, I say.
 
Good job, I say.

Sounds like things went exactly as planned for a mid-air failure in a plane equipped with a chute. Not sure I see any reason to criticize this situation at all. In fact, with the chute, there's a good chance he survived an incident that he may have otherwise ended up dead in.

Question for you SR pilots... IIRC, there is no specific 'prop lever' in these things, and therefore, seemingly no way to feather. Can you use the single power lever to still manually control the pitch (I think I remember someone telling me that it was really just a complicated bit of connections that actually control the pitch, as opposed to the computer or something). Basically, any way to prevent the prop from becoming as much of a speed brake?
 
Question for you SR pilots... IIRC, there is no specific 'prop lever' in these things, and therefore, seemingly no way to feather. Can you use the single power lever to still manually control the pitch (I think I remember someone telling me that it was really just a complicated bit of connections that actually control the pitch, as opposed to the computer or something). Basically, any way to prevent the prop from becoming as much of a speed brake?

Can't answer the question, but this STC would give you that capability if you wanted it. A proper throttle quadrant and controls associated with it.

http://www.tamarackaero.com/?dispatch=products.view&product_id=29778
 
Question for you SR pilots... IIRC, there is no specific 'prop lever' in these things, and therefore, seemingly no way to feather. Can you use the single power lever to still manually control the pitch (I think I remember someone telling me that it was really just a complicated bit of connections that actually control the pitch, as opposed to the computer or something). Basically, any way to prevent the prop from becoming as much of a speed brake?

Few piston singles will actually feather. The prop control is just like that on a normal constant speed system. Only, instead of the pilot having to move the prop control independent of the throttle there is an indexed groove that the prop control rides in based on throttle position. In the even of an engine failure with a windmilling prop you just pull the power lever full aft. That's as good as it will get. There is a procedure during the run up for checking to prop governor.
 
Few piston singles will actually feather. The prop control is just like that on a normal constant speed system. Only, instead of the pilot having to move the prop control independent of the throttle there is an indexed groove that the prop control rides in based on throttle position. In the even of an engine failure with a windmilling prop you just pull the power lever full aft. That's as good as it will get. There is a procedure during the run up for checking to prop governor.
I meant to put feather in air quotes. Apologies. Whatever they can achieve would at least be somewhat better than the disc that a fixed pitch would present.
 
Also, most single engine pistons use oil pressure to increase blade angle and therefore if a loss of oil pressure occurred, either causing or as a result of the engine failure, you essentially have no control of blade angle and they will go to low pitch (which is, of course, the worst case scenario for glide performance).
 
Also just FYI the Cirrus is more a replacement for the 182 not 172 but with a lower operating cost and fuel burn (during flight, not post crash).
 
If you read through the accident database, you'll see that most people that kill themselves in Cirrus', much like any other airplane, would have made the poor decision with or without the chute. In fact, in one that I read, a pilot w 3 pax died in a descent from 3,000 AGL. Plenty of altitude needed to pull the chute. He was a Private who flew into IMC in Chicago. The majority of these accidents are stall spins, and occur outside of the safety envelope of the chute.

They were headed back northwest bound. They called DuPage tower, KDPA, and it was a MESS. I have the ATC recording of that day in my inbox... i'll post it here.


Heres the transcript:

VFR into IMC - non instrument rated pilot. You put this guy in this same situation in any aircraft, from Piper Cub, Cessna, to Mooney, and the result will be the same. Use this as an example of what not to do gentlemen.

9:57
3cd: "223cd"
female voice: "you are on unicom, did you want to talk also to the tower?"
3cd: "tower please"
female voice: "ok you need to switch to 120.9"

3cd: "dupage tower 223cd"
tower: "223cd, dupage tower"
3cd: "coming in let me see here.... visual flight rules uhh was wondering if we were going to available for landing"
tower: "223cd, the field is IFR, uhh say intentions"
3cd: "dupage tower, I just flew over your field I appologize, I didn't realize I was going that fast"
tower: "223cd, the field is IFR, say your intentions"
3cd: "if it's IFR we are going to move on down, I was just checking, I went down to about 2k and could see pretty well so I was just going to see if you are available"
<silence>
male voice: "are you (perhaps he meant is he) up flying around somewhere right now?"
male voice2: "yah and the tower is trying to key him in ya know, saying say your intentions is there anything I can do for you..."
male voice: "jump in the 'mustkateer' and lead him down to the ground"
male voice2: "tower is trying to do everything but put words in his mouth"
male voice: "that's exactly why they say you know you get stuck in the clouds and you don't have IFR training your life expectentency is like 3 minutes"
male voice2: "roger that.."
male voice: "but no big deal"


<seems like tower freq is silent, this is odd, maybe the tapes missed it>


<lots of microphone clicks, perhaps it is 3cd thinking of the right words to say..."




10:01am 3cd: "i am trying to stay uhh"
tower: "3cd do you still have the field in site"
3cd: negative we lost it, i am going out to north and make a straight in if that is OK
tower: 3cd roger, the field is a suggested heading of 200
3cd: roger, 200


10:04 tower: "3cd say intentions"
3cd: "I think I am about tempted.... is there a better field with better visibility as I don't want to get in there and get stuck all day"
tower: "3cd, do you want to talk to chicago approach because they can help with vectors or are you....
3cd: "no I think I am ok doing it either way but uhh I was just uhh do you have a uhh a later airport or a report today"
tower: "3cd, maintain vfr standby......"


10:05
tower: "3cd, chicago exec the wx there vis of 10, ceiling 1,500k overcast, vfr right now"
3cd: "roger that, what is there code"
tower: "PWK"
3cd: "PWK, rgr thank you again"

tower: "3cd, uhh are you familiar with the uhh class bravo..."
3cd: "you broke up there at the end"
tower: "3cd, are you familiar with the area at all"
3cd: "I did my uhh training there with american flyers"
tower: "3cd, rgr, would you like to talk to approach, they can give you suggested headigs and help you get in"
3cd: "I am still trying to descide if I should land at dupage or not, do you think that is a good idea or not?"
tower: "3cd, are you currently vfr right now?"

tower: "3cd, are you IN THE CLOUDS or are you CLEAR OF THE CLOUDS?"
3cd: "I am actually uhh puhh (he is nervous you can tell now to tell truth) i am in and out of the clouds right now"
tower: "3cd, roger"

( i bet tower is phoning chi approach right now about this situation)

tower: "3cd, are you IFR qualified?"
3cd: "I am in IFR training, and I let this get around me"

tower: "(heartbeat goes up!) rgr the altimeter is 29.86, I am going to call departure and tell them you are coming to them and they will give you vectors to dupage OK?"
3cd: "roger that"




10:08
tower: "3cd, dupage tower"
3cd: "dupage tower"
tower: "cirrus 3cd contact chi dept on 120.55"
tower: "cirrus 3cd, dupage..."
3cd: "3cd, 122.055 rgr"
tower: "negative 120.55"
3cd: "roger, 120.55"



10:10
tower: "cirrus 3cd, dupage tower..."

(no liveatc exists for 120.55 that I see...)


10:12
tower: "cirrus 3cd, dupage tower..."
 
Back
Top