Cirruc chute pull, four survive

But one question. How much time do you have in a Cirrus?

Zero, because I don't feel it is a safe airplane, particularly because of the lack of integral fuel tanks. Perhaps you should read into this study. http://www.avweb.com/avwebflash/news/Cirrus_Safety_Record_Average_205914-1.html

When the Cirrus is compared to similarly constructed aircraft of the same era, the record is terrible.

Do tell me how many planes with integral fuel tanks would have ended up like this one? I'll take flying the Diamond 40 over a Cirrus any day of the week. Wet wing versus integral fuel tanks contained between two fully load bearing spars, thank you very much.

Embedded media from this media site is no longer available


Don't get me wrong, it's probably a decent aircraft. My biggest beef with Cirrus is their marketing and ability to attract pilots with money > brains. That ends up putting a black eye on all of GA. And the fuel tank issue.
 
If used correctly, yes. The main thing I was told by my CFI when I got my PPL in the Cirrus that as soon as you pull the chute, you've totaled the plane.

I'm not sure I buy this. When I was in college a couple cirrus reps. from Duluth flew a 20 and 22 in to our airport and were giving demo rides to the cfi's. I clearly remember him saying the total cost (parts & labor) for a new chute was in the neighborhood of $20,000 to $25,000.
Now of course the aircraft could be damaged in addition to needing a new chute so that may be where your instructor is getting his info?

Anyway these numbers were from back in 06-07 so they may be a bit off now.
 
I'm not sure I buy this. When I was in college a couple cirrus reps. from Duluth flew a 20 and 22 in to our airport and were giving demo rides to the cfi's. I clearly remember him saying the total cost (parts & labor) for a new chute was in the neighborhood of $20,000 to $25,000.
Now of course the aircraft could be damaged in addition to needing a new chute so that may be where your instructor is getting his info?

Anyway these numbers were from back in 06-07 so they may be a bit off now.

IIRC, that's the 10 year repack cost, which is required for continued airworthiness.
 
Cost for a 10 Year Chute Repack is around 10K. That's not bad for having the safety of a chute in case of emergency.

Low alt stalls and spins are deadly - regardless of which airplane you fly.
 
Zero, because I don't feel it is a safe airplane, particularly because of the lack of integral fuel tanks. Perhaps you should read into this study. http://www.avweb.com/avwebflash/news/Cirrus_Safety_Record_Average_205914-1.html

When the Cirrus is compared to similarly constructed aircraft of the same era, the record is terrible.

Do tell me how many planes with integral fuel tanks would have ended up like this one? I'll take flying the Diamond 40 over a Cirrus any day of the week. Wet wing versus integral fuel tanks contained between two fully load bearing spars, thank you very much.

Embedded media from this media site is no longer available


Don't get me wrong, it's probably a decent aircraft. My biggest beef with Cirrus is their marketing and ability to attract pilots with money > brains. That ends up putting a black eye on all of GA. And the fuel tank issue.

That plane could have been powered by baby seal tears and lubricated with unicorn sperm... they still would have had to scrape the occupants of that plane off the parking lot with a shovel. How many survivable accidents have there been where the Cirrus burned up versus other aircraft in a similar situation?
 
A Cirrus is just an airplane, just like the Boeing/Airbus argument down another thread. There's nothing spooky or gee-whiz about it. Its an airplane. If you're going to fly it, know it's strengths and limitations. Insofar as the emergency chute, you have to deploy it within it's limits......you have to help it, help you. If you deploy it out of it's bank/ rate of descent/ altitude limits, you're not helping it succeed and it likely won't work. It's the same thing with an ejection seat in a fighter.....there's an envelope that it's guaranteed to work in; if you deploy it at other times, there are no guarantees.

Even the F-117 had an automated "leveler" system, but that was because the thing was a Spatial D nightmare.
 
A quick search of the NTSB database looks like 210s and A36s also often catch fire when they crash.

One has to look at the dynamics of the individual accidents themselves and how/why fire was involved. Simple stats of Bonanzas, Centurions, and Cirri won't give an accurate picture.
 
My biggest beef with Cirrus is their marketing and ability to attract pilots with money > brains.

Isn't that the point of all marketing departments? If that's your beef with Cirrus, than my beef with Cessna is that they do the same thing. $300k for a 50 year old design? Sounds like more money than brains to me.
 
I'm gonna say it again....

Fixed gear, single engine, plastic, no integral fuel tank, approach speeds excess of 75kts.... When used at the right time I think the 'chute is a great Idea! It's really not the best airplane to be making emergency landings in off-field.

I liked flying them, would NEVER own one though....
 
Can you elaborate on this? That sounds neat.

In the F-117A, we had what was known as PAARS, or Pilot Activated Automatic Recovery System. When the PAARS button was depressed on the stick, the autopilot and autothrottles engaged (if off), the aircraft recovered itself to the horizon via the closest means available, rolled wings level upright, and established a 5 degree nose-up at 250 knots. Only problem was that in finding the quickest way to the horizon, it didn't know the difference between positive and negative Gs.

The systems was born of a couple of accidents we had in the jet that were attributed to spatial-D. The 117 was VERY easy to get spatial-D in, since:

- because the cockpit was so sealed well, there was no "wind rush" or other aural cues of airspeed.......60 knots sounded like 600 knots. This caused a problem when.....

-.......the pilot was flying, as I spent most of my time heads-down in the IRDS display searching for my target and heavily depended on the autopilot to be doing the flying. Visual lookout was kind of a joke, as there wasn't time to and the plane had crappy viz anyway except for out the sides; but then in combat, that didn't matter (though I certainly wasn't maintaining any reasonable see and avoid while VMC in stateside airspace...kind of unsafe in that way). The IRDS did have a small mini-HUD like display in the corner of it that showed aircraft attitude only, but we usually decluttered that since there was already a ton of targeting information we needed to be looking at. The jet really did need a WSO onboard.

So I can see where a system like this LVL device could come in handy.
 
Thanks MikeD. That sounds like a challenging cockpit to work in. I can easily imagine getting spatially disoriented, looking down a lot, in that environment.
 
Thanks MikeD. That sounds like a challenging cockpit to work in. I can easily imagine getting spatially disoriented, looking down a lot, in that environment.

You're constantly heads-down, and like I said, in training stateside, outside and below Class A airspace at times; am hurtling along at 0.95M on autopilot, and not seeing and avoiding while VMC like I should, as my head is down and buried in the sensors doing target search/track. Had I had a near miss or midair........but luckily I never did.
 
Yes, but they have structure on top of just the skin of the wing, to support the wing

So do these:




I'm thinking sour grapes on this one. The video you posted was the incident at DVT, that I have been referencing. You can read the accident report here: http://www.ntsb.gov/aviationquery/brief.aspx?ev_id=20100804X02630&key=1 so that you may become fully educated on the incident vs. posting a 30 second video to try to make a point that has no merit.

SteveCostello hit on the biggest point about that incident; he was dead before a drop of fuel left the wing.

Did it occur to you that the F-117, B-2, F-22, and JSF are all built out of composite, and have no external structures to support the aircraft structure?

The bottom line here is that the CAPS system, when employed effectively works to save lives. And it does. Look at this list, and tell me what the outcome of the majority of these incidents would have been without CAPS being available as an option. http://www.cirruspilots.org/Content/CAPSHistory.aspx

Next time you're in Phoenix, give me a shout. We'll go for a flight. I promise not to hit the "Explode" button, pull the CAPS, handle, or use the Wings Level switch. I don't have a Wings Level switch, anyways. :D
 
Back
Top