Cirruc chute pull, four survive

If used correctly, yes. The main thing I was told by my CFI when I got my PPL in the Cirrus that as soon as you pull the chute, you've totaled the plane.
 
If used correctly, yes. The main thing I was told by my CFI when I got my PPL in the Cirrus that as soon as you pull the chute, you've totaled the plane.

Which is why I think people are so reluctant to pull expensive red handle. "Man, if I just hang with this for another few seconds, I can pull this out and save my bacon... and a lot of money."

The Cirrii have had a 'Level Wings' button for a while now... wonder if people are actually using that at all when they get knee deep in stuff they can't get out of.
 
Which is why I think people are so reluctant to pull expensive red handle. "Man, if I just hang with this for another few seconds, I can pull this out and save my bacon... and a lot of money."

The Cirrii have had a 'Level Wings' button for a while now... wonder if people are actually using that at all when they get knee deep in stuff they can't get out of.

I feel the chute and all the fancy features lead the weekend warrior pilots to believe they can fly in worse conditions than they otherwise should/can because they've got an out.
 
If used correctly, yes. The main thing I was told by my CFI when I got my PPL in the Cirrus that as soon as you pull the chute, you've totaled the plane.
An old instructor of mine told me to never break a fingernail to save an airplane...

But seriously, I need a chute anytime I land.
 
Insurance companies rather have you pull the chute rather then deal with loss of life. Some insurance companies even encourage using the chute over trying to land during emergencies. It's cheaper for Insurance compaines to rather replace an aircraft then deal with loss of life and law suits. etc..
 
I feel the chute and all the fancy features lead the weekend warrior pilots to believe they can fly in worse conditions than they otherwise should/can because they've got an out.

While I hear this argument quite frequently, it is a little short sighted. It also sounds like the, "People will drive faster and more recklessly with airbags in their cars."What you're suggesting also falls directly into the "Hazardous Attitudes" of pilots we learned about in our Commercial. Are you really suggesting that the majority of pilots who fly the Cirrus do so with such a reckless disregard for our lives, and others? Look at the entire situation.

1. Pulling the chute means an off airport landing. Nobody like landing off airport, and nobody likes dirty loafers.
2. Off-roading an airplane attracts cops. FAST. Nobody likes cops.
3. Off-roading an airplane attracts Feds. Nobody likes feds, either.
4. Off-roading an airplane is often fatal. Nobody likes fatal anything.

If you read through the accident database, you'll see that most people that kill themselves in Cirrus', much like any other airplane, would have made the poor decision with or without the chute. In fact, in one that I read, a pilot w 3 pax died in a descent from 3,000 AGL. Plenty of altitude needed to pull the chute. He was a Private who flew into IMC in Chicago. The majority of these accidents are stall spins, and occur outside of the safety envelope of the chute.

An example of the chute working to design specs is the ATP pilot out of New Orleans that had his engine decide to stop after departing. He descended below the clouds, slowed to 80 kias, put in 15 degrees of flaps, flew it to the horn, and pulled the handle. He got wet shoes, but the plane floated and he used it as his rest area until a boat arrived to pick him up.
 
If you read through the accident database, you'll see that most people that kill themselves in Cirrus', much like any other airplane, would have made the poor decision with or without the chute. In fact, in one that I read, a pilot w 3 pax died in a descent from 3,000 AGL. Plenty of altitude needed to pull the chute. He was a Private who flew into IMC in Chicago. The majority of these accidents are stall spins, and occur outside of the safety envelope of the chute.

Stall spins are the exact reason the parachute is there. In fact, it's the reason that the aircraft didn't have to demonstrate the ability to recover from a spin as required by Part 23. The Cirrus is the new doctor killer. Pilot has too much money and not enough brains, decides, I have a parachute, wing leveler and a basic, non-FIKI TKS system, so I'm good to fly in anything.
 
If used correctly, yes. The main thing I was told by my CFI when I got my PPL in the Cirrus that as soon as you pull the chute, you've totaled the plane.

Not entirely true. There are several that have had a chute pull that were put back together and are flying.

Stall spins are the exact reason the parachute is there. In fact, it's the reason that the aircraft didn't have to demonstrate the ability to recover from a spin as required by Part 23. The Cirrus is the new doctor killer. Pilot has too much money and not enough brains, decides, I have a parachute, wing leveler and a basic, non-FIKI TKS system, so I'm good to fly in anything.

Actually, the chute was an original design element that happened to also meet alternate criteria for spin certification. And they did do spin certification in Europe.
 
Actually, the chute was an original design element that happened to also meet alternate criteria for spin certification. And they did do spin certification in Europe.

Understood. The fact of the matter is, the aircraft certificated under part 23 without having demonstrated the ability to recover from a spin. I'm sorry, but it's a piss poor airplane design that happened to get a couple of marketing people (similar to Steve Jobs and Apple) behind it.

Additionally, look at the post impact fire stats on the Cirrus versus anything else. The wet wing, upon contact with anything basically turns the whole thing into a fireball.
 
Understood. The fact of the matter is, the aircraft certificated under part 23 without having demonstrated the ability to recover from a spin. I'm sorry, but it's a piss poor airplane design that happened to get a couple of marketing people (similar to Steve Jobs and Apple) behind it.

I'd like to know what you think is "piss poor" about it.
 


Now this is cool. Having listened to voice recordings of VFR pilot's who've continued flight into IMC and hear their screams and pleas for help to ATC while they enter an uncontrolled descent and kill themselves and others.... the thought of people having a last line of defense against these situations is really appealing.
 
Stall spins are the exact reason the parachute is there. In fact, it's the reason that the aircraft didn't have to demonstrate the ability to recover from a spin as required by Part 23. The Cirrus is the new doctor killer. Pilot has too much money and not enough brains, decides, I have a parachute, wing leveler and a basic, non-FIKI TKS system, so I'm good to fly in anything.

You're starting to show your ignorance, and are leaning into "biased". A low altitude stall/spin is beyond the performance envelope of the CAPS. The POH states that deployment below 400' AGL is not recommended. Off the top of my head, both the DVT and SDL incidents happened below 400'.

I fly a Cirrus, and I do not have a wings leveler. I don't have an anti-ice system, either. Does that make me more intelligent? By your rationale, it would. So thanks, for the compliment. :smoke:

Understood. The fact of the matter is, the aircraft certificated under part 23 without having demonstrated the ability to recover from a spin. I'm sorry, but it's a piss poor airplane design that happened to get a couple of marketing people (similar to Steve Jobs and Apple) behind it.

Additionally, look at the post impact fire stats on the Cirrus versus anything else. The wet wing, upon contact with anything basically turns the whole thing into a fireball.

What makes it a "piss poor design"? The wing is incredibly efficient. The lightweight composite makes it fly faster, and longer than anything aluminum in its class. For what it is (a light single, piston powered aircraft built to fit an affordable budget) it is a remarkable airplane. It is comfortable. I can get 4 hours of seat time in it comfortably. I'm 6'5, btw. I've flown from SDL to Houston, non-stop. MSP to OKC, non-stop. I'm not just saying this because I fly it. If I didn't like the airplane, there's nothing lost in saying, "You're right, it's a P.O.S!" But I do. My friends like it. Everyone who has flown it likes it. Passengers find the back roomy, and comfortable. It's got a 950lb useful load. I like it.

And I've built almost 500 hours of time in it. At less than it would cost me to rent a 172. And it does 160. So, yeah, I like it.

Your statement about it becoming a "fireball" on impact is off-base. A lot of airplanes will erupt into a fireball when they hit things, like Earth, whether it be a 172, or a 747. But sometimes they don't. Like the SDL incident. It didn't explode. It looks like you're just looking for a reason to not like that particular airplane.

But one question. How much time do you have in a Cirrus?
 
The fireball issue is a little concerning. IIRC there was a basic runway excursion on landing a few years back that turned into 4 fatalities because the aircraft burned. I would be interested to know the details behind how and why because Cubs have been going off the side of runways for almost a century now and not burning up.

As far as other features, eh, I find that a lot of people that knock Cirrii haven't flown them. As with most aircraft, the number one safety issue with the cirrus seems to be the loose nut in the front left seat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GX
Back
Top