Why is there an airline pilot shortage?

I wasn't very clear. See post above your post, sorry.

in re:

I agree ... generally. Once you have kids and really settle into that "comfort zone" of adulthood, change is difficult, especially when that pay and lifestyle are accommodating to your family's needs.

Of course change is difficult, but if moving out of, say, a high seniority position at American Eagle to pursue an opportunity at Delta is difficult, when American decides to shift flying to GoJets and Mesa, it's going to get hella difficult because as a subcontractor, you have zero control of flying you do not technically "own". That gun will be held to your head for the remainder of your time there.

That comfort that a lot of folks feel in high seniority positions at regionals, in this era, is synthetic.

The moral to the story is, if given the luxury of an option, do not put yourself in a position like that: Stay Hungry

 
I didn't mean to muddy the water. I know the considerations I make when I decide to apply for an airline position. My thought was that a senior regional Captain might have to make a similar decision. I didn't consider that ownership of the flying might make the regional precarious. I have some friends at Republic who were hired as J31 FOs by Chautauqua in the 90s. They have good pay, good QOL, and their employer is somewhat diversified. They have double digit seniority today so Republic would have to go Tango Uniform for them to lose their jobs.

That was the kind of person I was thinking of when I wrote that.
 
Side note: corporate positions don't come with guarantees either. Look at General Motors' flight department as just one example. Lots and lots of Fortune 500 pilots lost jobs in the last five years.
 
Side note: corporate positions don't come with guarantees either. Look at General Motors' flight department as just one example. Lots and lots of Fortune 500 pilots lost jobs in the last five years.

Absolutely. If they did, I'd never be looking. When we laid off a few years back, one of the people let go had been here 30+ years. Fortune 500 corporate is a good job, but without contractual protections you are an at-will employee. You go to work and do your best, but you have to walk on eggshells all of the time.

Steve is 100% correct
 
What if the perfect storm does happen? Economy takes an upswing, More folks are traveling, Retirements start, 1500 hrs/ATP in effect, where are the pilots going to come from?

It happened to the negative at the end of 2007, Guess it could happen to the positive in a few years.
 
What if the perfect storm does happen? Economy takes an upswing, More folks are traveling, Retirements start, 1500 hrs/ATP in effect, where are the pilots going to come from?

It happened to the negative at the end of 2007, Guess it could happen to the positive in a few years.

I don't think there is a shortage of pilots.. like others have said, it's a shortage of pilots willing to work for slave wages. It doesn't make sense to bank on a possible 20k a year salary after 110k+ of educational expenses.

The fact that they still pay instructors minimum wage, and regional airline pilots minimum wage is a testament to there being no shortage now or on the horizon.

  • 125,738 commercial pilots
  • 144,600 airline transport pilots
  • 94,863 CFI's
  • 72,280 student pilots
I think that's from 2009 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_certification_in_the_United_States)
I work in a cubicle and have been on the fence about this pilot career thing for almost 8 years now. I am a licensed private pilot... and believe me, I always wanted to do this, and I love flying and aviation. But facing the reality that I'm almost 30 and will never get to own a home, or a new car ever in my life makes me lean back to the side of the fence I am already on (the boring 9-5 life). Yea, it took me 4 years of college and 7 years in the career (IT) to get to a high 50's salary (which doesn't get you far in the North East with the average row home or condo costing over 150k, average rent costing over 1000), but I have worked since I was 14, and for minimum wage until age 20. College in total ended up costing me about 40 - 50 grand (even after the help of tuition 'reimbursement' from my job)... I really don't want to go back to that abuse and nonsense.. or the car from the 80's that's falling apart. Especially with the responsibility of ~75 lives in my hands every flight. And 55k more debt just to even qualify for the minimum wage instructing job for god knows how many years (1500 hour rule) then 4 more years of insulting pay at a regional? My cubicle doesn't seem as bad as it did when I was younger.


But on the flip side, this paper is kind of interesting...
http://www.aabri.com/manuscripts/09349.pdf

Wouldn't that p155 you off if you paid 55k for training, then 2 yrs later they started airline funded training programs?
 
I hear you man, just sold my 2010 pathfinder and got a 98 Honda. First two years suck, but I wouldn't say that I'm going to be making 20 grand forever. I hear guys everyday crying about how much money they don't make. Remember the average household income in the U.S is $46,326. Maybe I'm just ignorant but I still believe this career can be very rewarding, and a career with many options. (no im not drinking the kook aid) even thou I'm at a regional, and it sucks I wouldn't say my pay is insulting..
 
I hear you man, just sold my 2010 pathfinder and got a 98 Honda. First two years suck, but I wouldn't say that I'm going to be making 20 grand forever. I hear guys everyday crying about how much money they don't make. Remember the average household income in the U.S is $46,326. Maybe I'm just ignorant but I still believe this career can be very rewarding, and a career with many options. (no im not drinking the kook aid) even thou I'm at a regional, and it sucks I wouldn't say my pay is insulting..

Its true unfortunately. Everyone on these forums (myself included) say "omg don't be a pilot!" But with that said, all the other careers that meant you would be rich and supposedly great like lawyer, doctor, accountant etc... I don't know if I'd advise any of those careers either. Seems like the only thing still making money today like it was 20-30 years is anything involving oil, but who knows how long that will last.

Mind you I'm a 1980s-1990s kid also. So I can't speak of much prior. :biggrin:
 
I hear you man, just sold my 2010 pathfinder and got a 98 Honda. First two years suck, but I wouldn't say that I'm going to be making 20 grand forever. I hear guys everyday crying about how much money they don't make. Remember the average household income in the U.S is $46,326. Maybe I'm just ignorant but I still believe this career can be very rewarding, and a career with many options. (no im not drinking the kook aid) even thou I'm at a regional, and it sucks I wouldn't say my pay is insulting..

Being directly responsible for 1000's of lives every week, several multi-million dollar aircraft and spending 3/4 of the month away from home in a pee soaked hotel room for 25 a year grand (before tax) isn't insulting?

And for people not yet in a regional, they face the prospect of having to instruct for 5+ years for 15 grand a year with this silly 1500hr rule. Unless they get a good 135 job, which has about the same odds as hitting the powerball.
 
Its true unfortunately. Everyone on these forums (myself included) say "omg don't be a pilot!" But with that said, all the other careers that meant you would be rich and supposedly great like lawyer, doctor, accountant etc... I don't know if I'd advise any of those careers either. Seems like the only thing still making money today like it was 20-30 years is anything involving oil, but who knows how long that will last.

Mind you I'm a 1980s-1990s kid also. So I can't speak of much prior. :biggrin:

That's missing the point though. I don't think anyone here actually cares about being "rich". If they did, they wouldn't be working in the aviation industry. There are, however, other "regular" careers that provide enough to make a living and don't require a 100k+ loan which eats away 12 grand a year for 12+ years. You can make with relative ease 40 - 60k with a school loan of under 50k in most career fields. You certainly can't survive on 20 grand with 100k in debt. It's just not possible. Not even for a single person living at home with mom and dad. Every dime of take home pay would go to paying back that loan, and the rest to your annual medical certificate renewal.
 
And for people not yet in a regional, they face the prospect of having to instruct for 5+ years for 15 grand a year with this silly 1500hr rule. Unless they get a good 135 job, which has about the same odds as hitting the powerball.

Not that I entirely disagree, but just remember -- it was only about 15 years ago (mid 90s) when the minimums to be hired flying a turboprop were 1500TT and 500ME. Some carriers, such as Piedmont and Allegheny required 2500TT.

AND, even with 1500TT and 500ME, most carriers required that you make a small $10,000 "investment" in your training for the privilege.

So... maybe the 1500 hour rule is "silly"... or maybe 300 hour regional jet pilots was "silly" and this regulation simply corrects the anomaly. I know that I was a better pilot for having flight instructed and flying freight for a few thousand hours before going to my first regional job... flying a 19 passenger Jetstream 31 with no autopilot, no flight attendant, and a 223 knot redline.
 
Not that I entirely disagree, but just remember -- it was only about 15 years ago (mid 90s) when the minimums to be hired flying a turboprop were 1500TT and 500ME. Some carriers, such as Piedmont and Allegheny required 2500TT.

AND, even with 1500TT and 500ME, most carriers required that you make a small $10,000 "investment" in your training for the privilege.

So... maybe the 1500 hour rule is "silly"... or maybe 300 hour regional jet pilots was "silly" and this regulation simply corrects the anomaly. I know that I was a better pilot for having flight instructed and flying freight for a few thousand hours before going to my first regional job... flying a 19 passenger Jetstream 31 with no autopilot, no flight attendant, and a 223 knot redline.

Hey no argument there buddy... I agree with the good experience requirement (of instructing, freight, etc), but the 1500 hour rule misses the point... It's quality not quantity that should count, or a combination thereof. I mean in reality you could teach and fly the traffic pattern a gazillion times with students, and it won't make you that much better of a pilot out there in the system. But everyone should make more than 60k to fly any turboprop or jet plane period. If you can drive a truck for 60k+ to START (without 110k in education), then you should be able to fly a much more expensive airplane for the same (or more, but that's asking too much). And that 1500TT/500ME requirement for the turboprops back then: Didn't people usually move onto a major airline within about 2-3 years anyway and make high 5 figure / low 6 figures right off the bat when they did? Certainly not the case anymore. You probably need 10 years at minimum to move on now..

Oh, and anyone who doesn't jump on the wagon for advancement would be a fool for not doing so. So yea, those 300 hour RJ pilots might seem like a crazy thing, but admit it, you, or I, or anyone in their right mind would have jumped on that ship if the opportunity presented itself. At least you are on a path to move "up", and not side to side from crap job A to crap job B to crap job C. So yea, some paths are more noble than others, but in the end if you aren't going where the advancement is, well, you will pay for it in years of life and lack of money and a longer time spent with a crappy schedule.
 
And that 1500TT/500ME requirement for the turboprops back then: Didn't people usually move onto a major airline within about 2-3 years anyway and make high 5 figure / low 6 figures right off the bat when they did? Certainly not the case anymore. You probably need 10 years at minimum to move on now..

My first job after flying for several years in the Jetstream and Saab 340 was as a DC9 first officer for AirTran. It paid $25,000 per year in 1998. During my furlough from AirTran in October 1998 I was hired by US Airways in January of 1999. Starting pay there, for the first year, was $36,000 per year. Granted, after 3 years there I was making just under six figures.

So no, I don't think the logic holds. I agree that pilots should make $60,000 minimum. That's around what our newhires make. But, unfortunately, the airlines just don't see it that way.

By the way, if all you are doing as you build time is drilling around the traffic pattern... you're doing it wrong. You should be earning that CFII and teaching instrument students. Hopefully picking up an MEI and getting a few hours multi. Why not finish the AGI and IGI writtens while you're at it? If you're at a 141 school maybe you could become a check airman. As soon as you have 135 minimums you should be applying at those companies and, with a little luck, earning real world IFR experience (probably at night).

Those skills do transfer. And they make you a better pilot.
 
Simply, there is no upside to the new pilot joining the aviation industry, anymore. As Boris so eloquently states, this industry is in a race to the bottom. It comes down to how big your dream is, and what sacrifices are willing to be made long term to justify those sacrifices. People throughout this thread have stated that they're willing to sacrifice money and lifestyle, kids, and family, a long term retirement plan, or financial stability to fly airplanes. Seeing all of this, what's the incentive for a young person just finished with their ratings to become competent enough to join the aviation industry? Let alone a four year grad with a degree... Wait, they can't get jobs, anyways. Scratch that. If it stopped there, that would be difficult enough. But it doesn't. With the ATP rule, all of those sacrifices have compounded on themselves resulting in more time, money, lifestyle, etc. being sacrificed to accomplish a goal.

Bottom line is that you need to either have a REALLY big dream to endure these sacrifices, or you need to make enough money doing something else, outside of flying airplane, to create the capital required to fly your own airplane, or can make a transition without it affecting your financial situation.
 
Gawd Zap. Do you still have your number at US Airways? Could be worth cashing in depending on how a few things shake down in the next couple of years.
 
Back
Top