Why is there an airline pilot shortage?

I agree that this career takes a bit more sacrifice than some to get into, but let's stop with all of the, "OMG, it's so hard to become a pilot these days!!1". Being a pilot is still a cool job and there will always be people willing to do what it takes to make it work.

I drove truck after dropping out of college to pay off some of school debt. It's a job that pays great to start, about 40K-50K, and it can go up from there with owner operators easily clearing 100K. I did it for about a year and a half. The lifestyle was cool at first, traveling and seeing the country from the road, then the newness wore off and it sucked. The reason it pays what it does is because there is an actual shortage of drivers (when's the last time you read a news story about that, ay?) and people are not willing to put up with that lifestyle for less. Driving a truck is not hard, you can go from no experience to driving your own rig in about a month. The training cost is about $5K. It's very easy to get into the profession. However, when's the last time you heard anyone say, "I want to be a truck driver when I grow up."? It doesn't happen very often. It's not a cool or highly respected job. But there is a real shortage and the job pays well because of it.

Let's compare this to pilots. Specifically, regional airline pilots who often spend 60K+ on training and at least a year if not several years of training for a job that will start at 20K. While you may earn more than a trucker eventually, you could also have bad luck and end up starting over a few times. You will be away from home a lot, maybe not quite as much, but still much more than normal. But being a pilot is still a cool job and people seem to have a fantastical view of how great the career must be. Unless the skewed view of how things seem vs. how they really are is changed, there will never be a shortage of people willing to pony up the dough and become regional airline applicants.

It's time to take some of the shine off the profession. Quit showering on overnights. Trade in the hat for a trucker cap. Get a big gulp sized coffee mug and ogle every cute broad you pass in the terminal and wages will rise. :sarcasm:
 
It's quality not quantity that should count, or a combination thereof. I mean in reality you could teach and fly the traffic pattern a gazillion times with students, and it won't make you that much better of a pilot out there in the system.
Have you ever flight instructed for a living?
 
That's missing the point though. I don't think anyone here actually cares about being "rich". If they did, they wouldn't be working in the aviation industry. There are, however, other "regular" careers that provide enough to make a living and don't require a 100k+ loan which eats away 12 grand a year for 12+ years. You can make with relative ease 40 - 60k with a school loan of under 50k in most career fields. You certainly can't survive on 20 grand with 100k in debt. It's just not possible. Not even for a single person living at home with mom and dad. Every dime of take home pay would go to paying back that loan, and the rest to your annual medical certificate renewal.


I just don't agree with that statment. I worked 2 jobs while in school, and used my own cash for a lot of my flying. After getting an associate, BA, and all my ratings I ended up with 30k in student loans.. Just do your homework on where u do your flight training. I also don't understand why people throw around the 20 grand salary!!? If your in your thirtys your looking at a 30+ year career. Today at most regionals your looking at a 5 year upgrade. I understand you have a chance of getting furloughed, bankruptcies etc.... But your cubical job could easily be shipped to India, china or wherever someday. All I'm saying is within a few years of being in this industry your easily making more than the national average salary. I'm not saying we're not underpaid, overworked etc... But sometimes you just have to take a step back and look at the reality we are in. Since late 07 this country has been in terrible economic shape, high unemployment, and terrible growth. One more thing that pilots always say that bugs the hell out of me is " I'm responsible for 10000 of lives" well guess what ALL jobs are responsible for lives! If a cook at a restaurant takes a dump and doesnt wash his hands guess what, he's responsable for lives!
 
I agree that this career takes a bit more sacrifice than some to get into, but let's stop with all of the, "OMG, it's so hard to become a pilot these days!!1". Being a pilot is still a cool job and there will always be people willing to do what it takes to make it work.

I drove truck after dropping out of college to pay off some of school debt. It's a job that pays great to start, about 40K-50K, and it can go up from there with owner operators easily clearing 100K. I did it for about a year and a half. The lifestyle was cool at first, traveling and seeing the country from the road, then the newness wore off and it sucked. The reason it pays what it does is because there is an actual shortage of drivers (when's the last time you read a news story about that, ay?) and people are not willing to put up with that lifestyle for less. Driving a truck is not hard, you can go from no experience to driving your own rig in about a month. The training cost is about $5K. It's very easy to get into the profession. However, when's the last time you heard anyone say, "I want to be a truck driver when I grow up."? It doesn't happen very often. It's not a cool or highly respected job. But there is a real shortage and the job pays well because of it.

Let's compare this to pilots. Specifically, regional airline pilots who often spend 60K+ on training and at least a year if not several years of training for a job that will start at 20K. While you may earn more than a trucker eventually, you could also have bad luck and end up starting over a few times. You will be away from home a lot, maybe not quite as much, but still much more than normal. But being a pilot is still a cool job and people seem to have a fantastical view of how great the career must be. Unless the skewed view of how things seem vs. how they really are is changed, there will never be a shortage of people willing to pony up the dough and become regional airline applicants.

It's time to take some of the shine off the profession. Quit showering on overnights. Trade in the hat for a trucker cap. Get a big gulp sized coffee mug and ogle every cute broad you pass in the terminal and wages will rise. :sarcasm:

Not that I'm a trucker, or ever was one, but I guarantee some people out there actually DO want to be one. Some people actually get up and love getting on the highway and can't imagine living any other way. I remember talking to a guy who did that for like 30+ years and owned his own rig and wow he had some stories to tell.. Very smart guy, and one of the nicest people I ever talked to. But everyone is different and some people don't want the stationary lifestyle... It's the same thing as a 9 to 5 job. It seems great at first to have stability and the routine, then after 2 years you want to blow your head off. The traffic, the commute, the office politics, the backstabbing. 2 sides of the same coin. But the pay in the pilot profession is FAR from worth the sacrifice, even if you did enjoy doing it. I made a little breakdown in excel for your enjoyment:

Assumptions:
Column 1 is 9-5 job, 4 year degree, starting at 40 grand per year adjusted for 50k loan, 6.8% (12 year payoff), 4.1% raise per year.
Column 2 is Pilot career, adjusted for 100 grand loan, 6.8% (12 year payoff). Regional Wisconsin, Major USAirways 737/A320

$33,900.00 $11,784.00 Instructor
$35,289.90 $11,784.00
$36,736.79 $11,184.00 Regional New hire
$38,242.99 $21,984.00
$39,810.96 $23,784.00
$41,443.21 $49,884.00 Regional Captain
$43,142.38 $51,684.00
$44,911.22 $53,484.00
$46,752.57 $55,284.00
$48,669.43 $57,084.00
$50,664.88 $59,784.00
$52,742.14 $61,584.00
$61,004.56 $21,600.00 1st Year Loan Paid Off, Major New hire
$63,505.75 $49,248.00
$66,109.48 $53,568.00
$68,819.97 $63,072.00
$71,641.59 $64,800.00
$74,578.90 $101,088.00 Major Captain
$77,636.63 $101,952.00
$80,819.73 $102,816.00
$84,133.34 $103,680.00
$87,582.81 $105,408.00
$91,173.70 $106,272.00
$94,911.82 $108,000.00
$98,803.21 $108,000.00
$102,854.14 $108,000.00
$107,071.16 $108,000.00
$111,461.08 $108,000.00
$116,030.98 $108,000.00
$120,788.25 $108,000.00
$125,740.57 $108,000.00
$130,895.94 $108,000.00
$136,262.67 $108,000.00
$141,849.44 $108,000.00
$147,665.26 $108,000.00
$153,719.54 $108,000.00
$160,022.04 $108,000.00
$166,582.95 $108,000.00
$173,412.85 $108,000.00
$180,522.77 $108,000.00

Pay after 5 years $183,980.64 $80,520.00
Pay after 10 years $408,899.44 $347,940.00
Pay after 20 years $1,076,423.06 $1,027,452.00
pay after 30 years $2,091,233.57 $2,098,812.00
pay after 40 years $3,607,907.59 $3,178,812.00

Looks like the only time you are at an advantage is after 30 years, but this doesn't even consider missed investment opportunities from younger years. So aside from the time off later in the pilot career, financially it NEVER is a better deal than a typical 9-5 job. And this is ONLY if your career as a pilot works out damn near perfectly!

Oh and in reality it would be a year or 2 difference since pilot training is in addition to college... But you get the point.
 
Three pretty big assumptions in the pay ladder there.

1 - Getting hired within 2 years - especially with the new reg's next year.
2 - Upgrading within 3 years to a RJ Capt.... Unlikely.
3 - Getting hired at a legacy.



Oh and there's always getting furloughed. I've only had that happen 2x in the last 4 years.
 
turbomax97 said:
Three pretty big assumptions in the pay ladder there.

1 - Getting hired within 2 years - especially with the new reg's next year.
2 - Upgrading within 3 years to a RJ Capt.... Unlikely.
3 - Getting hired at a legacy.

Oh and there's always getting furloughed. I've only had that happen 2x in the last 4 years.

Which reinforces his theory since its based on best case (and maybe unrealistic) scenario. I would also like to see what kind of 9-5 jobs that typically pay 180k a year after 30 years.
 
Three pretty big assumptions in the pay ladder there.

1 - Getting hired within 2 years - especially with the new reg's next year.
2 - Upgrading within 3 years to a RJ Capt.... Unlikely.
3 - Getting hired at a legacy.



Oh and there's always getting furloughed. I've only had that happen 2x in the last 4 years.
But there's a pilot shortage coming up! :sarcasm:
 
The sooner people in this country realize we are not living in normal times, the less disappointed you will be. I can't think of any job that's not at risk of being lost. Whenever I miss being home, or take a look at my crappy paycheck, I think of some of my buddy's in Afganistan that haven't seen there kids or family in over a year, I hear about there paychecks. Look Kim Kardashian or whatever the hell her name is probably makes more money than an army battalion. Is that fair??
 
Assumptions:
Column 1 is 9-5 job, 4 year degree, starting at 40 grand per year adjusted for 50k loan, 6.8% (12 year payoff), 4.1% raise per year.
Column 2 is Pilot career, adjusted for 100 grand loan, 6.8% (12 year payoff). Regional Wisconsin, Major USAirways 737/A320

$33,900.00 $11,784.00 Instructor
$35,289.90 $11,784.00
$36,736.79 $11,184.00 Regional New hire
$38,242.99 $21,984.00
$39,810.96 $23,784.00
$41,443.21 $49,884.00 Regional Captain
$43,142.38 $51,684.00
$44,911.22 $53,484.00
$46,752.57 $55,284.00
$48,669.43 $57,084.00
$50,664.88 $59,784.00
$52,742.14 $61,584.00
$61,004.56 $21,600.00 1st Year Loan Paid Off, Major New hire
$63,505.75 $49,248.00
$66,109.48 $53,568.00
$68,819.97 $63,072.00
$71,641.59 $64,800.00
$74,578.90 $101,088.00 Major Captain
$77,636.63 $101,952.00
$80,819.73 $102,816.00
$84,133.34 $103,680.00
$87,582.81 $105,408.00
$91,173.70 $106,272.00
$94,911.82 $108,000.00
$98,803.21 $108,000.00
$102,854.14 $108,000.00
$107,071.16 $108,000.00
$111,461.08 $108,000.00
$116,030.98 $108,000.00
$120,788.25 $108,000.00
$125,740.57 $108,000.00
$130,895.94 $108,000.00
$136,262.67 $108,000.00
$141,849.44 $108,000.00
$147,665.26 $108,000.00
$153,719.54 $108,000.00
$160,022.04 $108,000.00
$166,582.95 $108,000.00
$173,412.85 $108,000.00
$180,522.77 $108,000.00

Pay after 5 years $183,980.64 $80,520.00
Pay after 10 years $408,899.44 $347,940.00
Pay after 20 years $1,076,423.06 $1,027,452.00
pay after 30 years $2,091,233.57 $2,098,812.00
pay after 40 years $3,607,907.59 $3,178,812.00

Looks like the only time you are at an advantage is after 30 years, but this doesn't even consider missed investment opportunities from younger years. So aside from the time off later in the pilot career, financially it NEVER is a better deal than a typical 9-5 job. And this is ONLY if your career as a pilot works out damn near perfectly!


You responded to my previous post and I think we respectfully disagree... I won't bring that back up bc its old news.

That said, all I'll say about this post is that your payscales are way off, for the pilots that is. I have no idea about truck drivers although my uncle has been truck driver for a long time and I'm pretty sure they don't make 180K/yr unless your on ice road truckers or doing some extreme truck driving on reality TV, or in some special circumstance.

As a CFI, I was making about 18.5k/yr and as a regional new hire I make about 25k/yr and was also given a bonus. I'm not making rapper money by any means, but I'm still a ways away from 11k or even 15k and thats not counting my bonus money or my military reservist pay (which I'm aware not everyone has).

All that said, go to airlinepilotcentral.com, it lists the payscales for most of the larger airlines/commuters/cargo and corporate ops in the USA. The reason most of want to go to a major is because it pays substantially more than what you've posted. Airways is the weakest paying of the original Legacy carriers and they still top out at 160k, DL is the holy grail for many topping out at 225k, Fedex at 255K. Don't get me wrong this industry has suffered since 9/11, and everything else, but there's still some gravy on the train. The pay scale you posted is the standard from most regional/commuter companies flying a 50 seat jet, a 737/A320 captain at Airways does make a bit more than what you posted.

On top of that, depending upon where you live and your personal situation... I challenge most people with a basic 4yr degree in accounting/business/finance/engineering whatever to beat your truckdriver payscale just working a 9-5 job.
 
Not you, Dan. He has our pilot example doing two years instructing, three years in the right seat at a regional (lulz), six years in the left seat at a regional, five in the right at a major (rofl!) And the entire rest of his career in the left seat at the same major climbing the same pay scale!???

Has that ever happened? I'm sure it has. Is it likely? Not even close. You lot think that making 180k outside of aviation is unlikely (I know several people IRL who easily pass that figure), but you accept as self evident that you'll never get furloughed, medically disqualified, or simply lose your job and have to start over. MOST professional pilots will have one of those things happen to them. Often more than once. Read that again and try to let it penetrate the SJS.
 
Is it really so easy for expatriates to be hired by Chinese airlines nowadays? I thought that they only wanted experienced airline captains.
That is correct. I live in Indonesia, which is just as desparate for pilots, yet it's not that easy getting a job for expats, definitely if you want an FO position. Typically, you need a type rating with 500 or more hours pic on that type before they want you if you're an expat.
 
That is correct. I live in Indonesia, which is just as desparate for pilots, yet it's not that easy getting a job for expats, definitely if you want an FO position. Typically, you need a type rating with 500 or more hours pic on that type before they want you if you're an expat.

Also, I've applied for Be400 jobs overseas with the requisite 500 PIC in the airframe, and not heard a word. With ~6000 TT, 1100 in the airplane, and ~700 PIC on type, I got one nibble from a totally disreputable operator in The Kingdom, offering me ~60k/year to sit in the right seat, live in a compound that is supposedly fortified (because everyone and his brother wants to kill you), and be on call 24/7/365 in a place where you have to make your own beer in secret and hope you don't get your head lopped off for it. And resesarch indicated that the checks sometimes arrived a few weeks late or with the wrong number of zeroes at the back. So even with the type and 500 PIC...maybe. Maybe not.

If you think that you'll just go ahead and get paid peanuts and "rack up" a bunch of Jet PIC, then go live like a billionaire playboy in the Third World, you're deluding yourself. But then, there seems to be a lot of that going around.

Look at the Russians. Their economy crumbled 20 years ago, and there were 10,000+ hour Antonov pilots running guns in to Jackholeastan for a cup of borscht and a bottle vodka. That's our future.
 
Also, I've applied for Be400 jobs overseas with the requisite 500 PIC in the airframe, and not heard a word. With ~6000 TT, 1100 in the airplane, and ~700 PIC on type, I got one nibble from a totally disreputable operator in The Kingdom, offering me ~60k/year to sit in the right seat, live in a compound that is supposedly fortified (because everyone and his brother wants to kill you), and be on call 24/7/365 in a place where you have to make your own beer in secret and hope you don't get your head lopped off for it. And resesarch indicated that the checks sometimes arrived a few weeks late or with the wrong number of zeroes at the back. So even with the type and 500 PIC...maybe. Maybe not.

If you think that you'll just go ahead and get paid peanuts and "rack up" a bunch of Jet PIC, then go live like a billionaire playboy in the Third World, you're deluding yourself. But then, there seems to be a lot of that going around.

Look at the Russians. Their economy crumbled 20 years ago, and there were 10,000+ hour Antonov pilots running guns in to Jackholeastan for a cup of borscht and a bottle vodka. That's our future.

I will gladly run guns and you can pay me in guns, lots of guns. Don't worry Boris our Kingdoms will be far from each other...
 
Hey guys,


While pilots are arguing about why nobody should be pilots, and about how being a pilot sucks, on a career piloting website, how many of you have actually tried to break out of this career in the midst of it, and actually been successful?

Because I did, and all it got me was a job working at a golf course and then $120,000 in debt for that brass ring that's supposed to pay big dollars. Oh and sure, I could make the $180,000 a year, if I wanted to sell my soul and end up against a wall with Boris standing in front of me with an AR-15 explaining why I had forgotten about the revolution. And before Boris freed me from my corporate shackles, I would have had to work 80 hours a week, never seeing my wife and kid.

I'm starting to see what mtsu_av8er was talking about with being sick of other folks complaining ALL THE TIME.
 
Back
Top