All Nippon 737 roll to 131.7 degrees

ComplexHiAv8r

Well-Known Member
WOW!!!

ANA plane flew almost belly-up after copilot error
(Japan Economic Newswire Via Acquire Media NewsEdge) TOKYO, Sept. 28 -- (Kyodo) _ An All Nippon Airways airplane briefly flew almost belly-up when it nosedived off Shizuoka Prefecture en route to Tokyo early this month, the Japan Transport Safety Board said Wednesday.

Flight 140 from Naha to Haneda, with 117 crew and passengers on board, managed to land at the Tokyo airport despite dropping about 1,900 meters from a height of about 12,500 meters in 30 seconds. Two flight attendants were slightly hurt, while four passengers later complained of ill-health.

The safety board's head, Norihiro Goto, told a news conference that data on the Boeing 737-700's digital flight recorder showed that in the incident which occurred at 10:50 p.m. Sept. 6, the twin-engine jet rolled to the left and descended after slightly rolling to the right when a copilot mistakenly operated the rudder trim knob in the cockpit.

The narrow-body aircraft continued to roll until it reached 131.7 degrees to the left, leaving it almost belly-up, according to the board. Its nose pointed down as much as 35 degrees at one point.

"The centrifugal force (exerted by the maneuver) may have helped lessen the impact on the passengers," Goto said.

Following the revelation that the airplane had flown almost belly-up, ANA Senior Executive Vice President Shin Nagase said at a separate news conference, "We deeply apologize for causing tremendous trouble and anxiety to our passengers." The unintended maneuver was caused when the copilot, in trying to unlock the cockpit door for the captain who was returning from a rest room in the cabin, mistook the rudder trim knob for the cockpit door lock switch nearby.

The incident occurred while the aircraft was flying over the Pacific about 40 kilometers south of Hamamatsu.

The transport safety board is investigating the incident.

(c) 2011 Kyodo News International, Inc.
[ Back To Contact Center Solutions Homepage's Homepage ]
 
That's nothing. China Air rolled a 747SP completely over and nearly did a split-S from FL410 to 9,500' on a flight to LAX.

Al Nippon has nothing on them.
 
FOs are good for nothin'!

But seriously, I operate the rudder trim knob all the time with the autopilot engaged. What gives?
 
Maybe he really disliked the captain and didn't want him coming back from his break at the urination station. :)
 
Must be a hell of a trim rate. In my toy jet I nudged the rudder trim once at night (on purpose) and it got stuck. We had enough time to go "what the world is going on...." *glance at engine gauges* "oh...the trim is stuck". Now I keep my hand on the switch until I verify it is done moving. Was hardly a big deal though. I'm thinking there is more to this story.
 
Can't speak for the 737, but the trim rate on the 757/767 is slow and very easily countered by rudder input (though, the autopilot doesn't control the rudder unless you're below 1500' on an autoland). Still, not a big issue.
 
Where is the lock to the cockpit door on a 737? How does it work out for it to be close enough to the rudder trim for this explanation to be plausible?
 
Were all the pax wearing parachutes? If not they need to make sure they violate the guy.

14 CFR 91.307 said:
(c) Unless each occupant of the aircraft is wearing an approved parachute, no pilot of a civil aircraft carrying any person (other than a crewmember) may execute any intentional maneuver that exceeds -
(1) A bank of 60° relative to the horizon; or
(2) A nose-up or nose-down attitude of 30° relative to the horizon.
 
Must be a hell of a trim rate. In my toy jet I nudged the rudder trim once at night (on purpose) and it got stuck. We had enough time to go "what the world is going on...." *glance at engine gauges* "oh...the trim is stuck". Now I keep my hand on the switch until I verify it is done moving. Was hardly a big deal though. I'm thinking there is more to this story.

Same here... I had the trim switch stick on the CRJ as well. If you don't catch it it can get pretty hairy. Eventually the A/P will disconnect due to the aileron forces required and with the trim at the stop it can go over pretty quick on you if you're not paying attention.... That second part we did in the sim "just to see what would happen"
 
That's nothing. China Air rolled a 747SP completely over and nearly did a split-S from FL410 to 9,500' on a flight to LAX.

Al Nippon has nothing on them.
Huge chunks came off that jet IIRC. they were lucky to get it down in almost one piece.
 
131 degrees is "almost belly up"?

Sheesh...people need to go get some aerobatics....
Pretty damn close to belly up when you are a paying passenger. Hell, I'm a pilot and I think it would scare the crap out of me if I was riding in the back. That's certainly not a normal attitude, and the something that caused it would be what would pucker me up.
 
I just think the name "All Nippon" is funny.

"Why yes, it is just a tad bit chilly in here. That's why we're All Nippon."
 
Back
Top