Should US pilots be armed?

I agree. But, the second ammendment rights should be exercised by the passengers themselves. Let's see what terrorists brings his AK47 on-board when Joe Redneck has his bazooka with him... (need I say sarcasm?)

In all seriousness, guns have no place on a plane. Even in well trained hands, the risks outweigh the benefits. Not to mention, there are little to no benefits, unless you want to play counter strike.

I should probably add that I'm not a big supporter of guns in the hands of civilians. That second ammendmend thing is a bit outdated by 200+ years.

Any other parts of the Constitution you feel that are outdated?
 
Any other parts of the Constitution you feel that are outdated?

In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.

If they get caught for something they must be guilty. No need for a trial.
 
No need to bang your had. What I meant by outdated:
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."
Weapons were the way to insure a young State. There is no longer a need for militias. Nowadays, guns for regular Joe's are not for the protection of civil liberties, but rather for making one feel more manly.
My reason not to like guns relates to the lack of regulation (and thus the number of idiots who are allowed to carry them). There is no requirement for a 'responsibility' test, psychiatric exam, a formlized training and so forth.
Two things to consider:
1% of accidental deaths in US are gun accidents (not talking about murders). About 70 children per day get shot in stupid accidents.
Per capita, there are roughly 10-20 times more crimes in US than in other western countries (Spain for instance, where civilians can't posses weapons). Most murders are commited w/ guns.

Yes, people kill people, but guns make things a lot easier and en-masse. Try the Arizona shooting w/ a knife or baseball bat. Or the Columbine masacre. There are too many idiots out there, and no way to control who gets the guns.

As I said, it's my personal opinion and I respect other's as well.
 
Yes, people kill people, but guns make things a lot easier and en-masse. Try the Arizona shooting w/ a knife or baseball bat. Or the Columbine masacre. There are too many idiots out there, and no way to control who gets the guns.

As I said, it's my personal opinion and I respect other's as well.

If someone wants a gun, they're going to get one.....law or no law. The AZ shooter, his mental status couldn't be used against him, because that would be discrimination against people with mental health issues, which he didn't even officially have (hadn't been in/out of an institution, etc). By all legal means, ie- criminal background, he had no background to prevent his purchase of a firearm.

Unless you want to go down the road of holding people accountable for thought crimes now......
 
I hear the program is ridiculously cheap considering it includes room and board and all your meals.

And people who get their guns illegally will continue to get their guns illegally, period. That has no effect on people who legally own guns, I don't see a problem there. If I had the money I'd go for as many Call of Duty weapons as I could legally own and fire them off at the range all the time. Shooting various guns at a shooting range in Hawaii was one of the coolest things I've ever done, especially since the target was a life-sized Osama Bin Laden.
 
No need to bang your had. What I meant by outdated:
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."
Weapons were the way to insure a young State. There is no longer a need for militias. Nowadays, guns for regular Joe's are not for the protection of civil liberties, but rather for making one feel more manly.
My reason not to like guns relates to the lack of regulation (and thus the number of idiots who are allowed to carry them). There is no requirement for a 'responsibility' test, psychiatric exam, a formlized training and so forth.
Two things to consider:
1% of accidental deaths in US are gun accidents (not talking about murders). About 70 children per day get shot in stupid accidents.
Per capita, there are roughly 10-20 times more crimes in US than in other western countries (Spain for instance, where civilians can't posses weapons). Most murders are commited w/ guns.

Yes, people kill people, but guns make things a lot easier and en-masse. Try the Arizona shooting w/ a knife or baseball bat. Or the Columbine masacre. There are too many idiots out there, and no way to control who gets the guns.

As I said, it's my personal opinion and I respect other's as well.

Have you been following what is happening in Egypt? Oh of course, that could never happen here, right? Do citizens not have the right to protect their household? What about hunt? Or should it be done only with knives and clubs?

On a regular occurrence, I encounter more idiots behind the wheel of a 2,000 pound bullet going 75 mph down the highway than I do that have guns. If you regularly encounter idiots with guns, then it is most likely illegal or you are hanging around in places you probably shouldn't be.

70 children per day get shot? O really?

Firearms are involved in 0.5% of accidental deaths nationally, compared to

motor vehicles (37%),
poisoning (22%),
falls (17%),
suffocation (5%),
drowning (2.9%),
fires (2.5%),
medical mistakes (1.7%),
environmental factors (1.3%),
and pedal cycles (0.7%).

Among children:
motor vehicles (41%),
suffocation (21%),
drowning (15%),
fires (8%),
pedal cycles (2%),
poisoning (2%),
falls (1.9%),
environmental factors (1.5%),
firearms (1.1%)
medical mistakes (1%).

source: http://www.nraila.org/issues/factsheets/read.aspx?id=120

More children die from falling, riding their bicycles, environmental factors (mother nature?) than do gun accidents.

Gun control supporters' "children" deception: Gun control supporters claim that firearm accidents take the lives of a dozen or more children daily, or 5,000 yearly, or one every 90 seconds. The Handgun Epidemic Lowering Plan (HELP) Network (dedicated to "changing society's attitude toward guns so that it becomes socially unacceptable for private citizens to have handguns") put the figure at nine per day. Some gun control supporters count anyone under age 24 as a "child," to get even higher numbers,8 by adding the relatively small number among children to the much larger number among juveniles and teenage adults, and calling the total "children." In fact, on average there is one such death among children per day, including one accidental death every seven days.

Lower murder rates in foreign countries prove that gun control works.

False. This is one of the favorite arguments of gun control proponents, and yet the facts show that there is simply no correlation between gun control laws and murder or suicide rates across a wide spectrum of nations and cultures. In Israel and Switzerland, for example, a license to possess guns is available on demand to every law-abiding adult, and guns are easily obtainable in both nations. Both countries also allow widespread carrying of concealed firearms, and yet, admits Dr. Arthur Kellerman, one of the foremost medical advocates of gun control, Switzerland and Israel "have rates of homicide that are low despite rates of home firearm ownership that are at least as high as those in the United States." A comparison of crime rates within Europe reveals no correlation between access to guns and crime.

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=4706
 
As odd as it sounds, I've never had one of my guns get up and fire itself either.


But then again, I don't have a Glock.
 
If someone wants a gun, they're going to get one.....law or no law. The AZ shooter, his mental status couldn't be used against him, because that would be discrimination against people with mental health issues, which he didn't even officially have (hadn't been in/out of an institution, etc). By all legal means, ie- criminal background, he had no background to prevent his purchase of a firearm.

Unless you want to go down the road of holding people accountable for thought crimes now......

Exactly my point. There is no good way to determine who is a lunatic (or could become one under a set of circumstances) and who is a more responsible individual. I hope you won't argue that a mass murder like the guy in Arizona is sane. But there is no way to know when someone could go postal. That is why I belive owning a gun doesn't bring any benefits, and gun ownership should be restricted to police/army.
Two side notes:
1. last year an older judge, in his 60s, mistakenly shot his wife in the Bay Area. Same year, a respected engineer, shot and killed his entire family because he lost his job (and obviously his mind). Both would probably not have happened if they didn't own a gun (killing your entire family w/ a knife... difficult).
2. 14% of deaths for the 25-34 group age are firearms related (http://www.the-eggman.com/writings/death_stats.html)

Yes, people outside the law can find ways to get a gun. But it's not easy, it costs money, and it's not something any petty criminal can do/afford (I know this as I lived in other parts of the world too). It makes it much less likely to get shot in a liqour store.

Apologies for the 'manly' comment. I was being sarcastic. Plus, I enjoyed the one time I went to a shooting range.
 
No offense, but NRA statistics? It's like asking the tabacco companies if smoking causes cancer.

OTOH, I agree w/ you, the 70/day figure I found on a site referred to accidents, not deaths. Even so, it could be inflated. Still, 2 accidental children deaths per day quoted by http://www.the-eggman.com/writings/death_stats.html could be closer to the truth. Even that is too much.
If you include non-accidental, for the age groups <24 years old, you get 20+ deaths.

As for Egypt: I was born in Romania, and witnessed a much more bloody revolution than what is happening right now in Egypt (so far). Still, the population didn't have weapons, but the regime toppled nonetheless.

Anyway, this is not related to the thread, so I'll stop posting on this theme.
 
Exactly my point. There is no good way to determine who is a lunatic (or could become one under a set of circumstances) and who is a more responsible individual. I hope you won't argue that a mass murder like the guy in Arizona is sane. But there is no way to know when someone could go postal. That is why I belive owning a gun doesn't bring any benefits, and gun ownership should be restricted to police/army.

No, the guy definitely wasn't sane. I was on-scene at the AZ shooting and saw the carnage first hand, so no defending anything there. Still, I don't believe in punishing everyone due to the actions of a lunatic.

Yes, people outside the law can find ways to get a gun. But it's not easy, it costs money, and it's not something any petty criminal can do/afford (I know this as I lived in other parts of the world too). It makes it much less likely to get shot in a liqour store.

You'd be surprised just how easy it is to obtain a gun by illegal means. As there are many illegal means to do so.
 
You'd be surprised just how easy it is to obtain a gun by illegal means. As there are many illegal means to do so.

Just to play devil's advocate here, if owning any gun as a civilian were illegal, would it be harder to obtain one illegally? It would seem like it would more difficult, a there would be no reason for a gun to even be around unless it belonged to police/military. Yes/no?
 
Just to play devil's advocate here, if owning any gun as a civilian were illegal, would it be harder to obtain one illegally? It would seem like it would more difficult, a there would be no reason for a gun to even be around unless it belonged to police/military. Yes/no?

Let me throw it back at you......

Drugs are illegal (talking the ones that are). Is it difficult or harder to obtain a gram of cocaine illegally?

Nope. There are many venues to get drugs since there's demand. A law doesn't reduce demand if someone wants something bad enough.
 
Probably not helpful, but here are some great ones.

1- "The very atmosphere of firearms everywhere restrains evil interference; they deserve a place of honor with all that's good."
~ George Washington.

2- "The best we can hope for concerning the people at large is that they be properly armed."
~ Alexander Hamilton .

3- "Arms discourage and keep the invader and plunderer in awe, and preserve order in the world as well as property."
~ Thomas Paine.

4- "Americans need not fear the federal government because they enjoy the advantage of being armed, which you possess over the people of almost every other nation."
~ James Madison.

5- "Games played with the ball and others of that nature, are too violent for the body and stamp no character on the mind. Let your gun therefore be the constant companion of your walks."
~ Thomas Jefferson.

6- "The great object is that every man be armed. Everyone who is able may have a gun."
~ Patrick Henry.

7- "Laws that forbid the carrying of arms... disarm only those who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes"
~ Thomas Jefferson quoting Cesare Beccaria.

8- "To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
~ George Mason.

9- "The said Constitution be never construed... to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms."
~ Samuel Adams.

10- "As nightfall does not come all at once, neither does oppression. In both instances, there is a twilight when everything remains seemingly unchanged. And it is in such a twilight that we all must be aware of change in the air -- however slight -- lest we become unwilling victims of the darkness.&rdquo;
~ Justice William O Douglas

11- "The Constitution is not neutral. It was designed to take the government off the backs of the people ...&rdquo;
~ Justice William O Douglas


12- "This country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing Government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it or their revolutionary right to dismember or overthrow it.&rdquo;
~ Abraham Lincoln - March 4 1861
 
Where do you think I would get my information? The Huffington Post?? LOL!

I'll stop now too. I apologize for the thread creep fellow JC'ers.
 
Try the Arizona shooting w/ a knife or baseball bat. Or the Columbine masacre. As I said, it's my personal opinion and I respect other's as well.

Actually had he had some sort of weapon that had not needed to be reloaded it might have been worse. I mean what if he had a baseball bat that had nails sticking out all over it. Or a chainsaw or some such. Or maybe he got out of the cab with a backpack full of pipe bombs. Yes, it's a bit of a stretch, but someone simply reaching over and swatting at his hands, like the one brave lady did while he re loaded, would have done nothing.

Let's not forget how many bombs were setup during the Columbine massacre either. Maybe because they didn't blow up, or maybe because the media just didn't care, but you never really hear about that. All you hear about is how scary the guns were they had.

Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but did you really think you wouldn't stir up a hornets nest on an internet site? Especially on a topic that has been discussed at length over and over on here?

For me, I like guns because they're fun. I don't know why, they just are. I guess for the same reasons I like using power tools and building things and driving tractors etc.

Are some people irressonsible, yes. But I can tell you right now that I was way more scared last night as I was driving to work and there was 10X the amount of traffic on the road as normal (I can say this as I drive a route where I normally see a handful of cars and last night was a steady stream as if it was day time). Why the more cars and why was I scared? Because I knew they all were leaving Super Bowl parties and a good amount were driving drunk.
 
I'm not a police officer but have carried and been responsible for firearms in the military and after the badassness (which is badass) wears off... its just one more thing to be responsible for and if your not getting paid for it or given any other benefits its not worth it from an employee point of view. As a pilot shooting and ILS down to Cat IIIc mins in JFK down to minimums the last thing I want to have to worry about is to make sure my weapon is on safe... just saying.
 
Back
Top