Guys, I understand not calling HR. Personally, I think that's a bad decision.
But let's get one thing clear; we're not saints, so let's not act as such. We will do nearly whatever it takes to ruin the careers and professional lives of scabs, and do so without apology. We have determined that this is a laudable cause, and we pat ourselves on the back for denying the jumpseat to "some worthless scab." We carry lists, and when we're forced to fly with them, we don't do anything but read checklists while in flight.
Is it a good idea to call HR on this guy? No. But let's not act as if we don't do it out of the goodness of our hearts. We will ruin careers if we feel the professional need to do so, and I'm not sure it's a good or a bad thing. What I DO think it is, is necessary in many respects, which is why nobody should be calling HR on this guy; it's unnecessary.