Tim Martins: CommutAir New Hire

What about the mans deeds done like 90 days ago?

I'm not defending the guy, I think he's a scumbag. I wouldn't give him the time of day. That said he has an incredible mountain to climb and if he does everything right he will probably still fail, he doesn't need our help.
 
Martins was outed for the actions he did, and paid the consequences for them. Do I think the rest of his life should be made hell for it? No. Only he knows inside what he feels about getting caught, and the price he's paid for it. I hope he learns a good few lessons for it, and in some way makes up for it.

Even our own TomCatter here on JC, who I personally busted 7 years ago this month for being a poser USN F-14 Tomcat pilot here on JC; to me, that situation is done and done. Hopefully, he learned his lesson and had gone on with his life. But I don't think chasing him down and ruining the rest of his life is the right thing to do either.

http://forums.jetcareers.com/48230-post31.html

http://forums.jetcareers.com/48230-post31.html

http://forums.jetcareers.com/general-topics/5337-my-apologies-all.html
 
I just think it sucks for the people who are trying to find a job in this economy, even one as anemic as a C5 FO.

I agree. But at what point does someone pay off the pricetag of doing what they did? To me, it depends on what damage was done, apart from their own tarnished image. If the damage is all to them, and they've paid for it, then whats the point of still going after them forever? He lost his job at Eagle. He deserved to. He made his bed in that situation and paid the price for it. Hopefully he learned his lesson. If he does it again, he'll pay again; and he better damn well know that, for his own sake. His only thing he can do is try and rebuild his integrity from the gutter where its at, and work his way up again.

Part of me wonders if much of the deep desire of some to quash this guy for the rest of his life goes beyond just what he did with his false life story; but because he hoodwinked and pulled a fast on on ALPA, and made them look stupid in their own magazine by accepting the honor they bestowed him of being "a role model for the ALPA Code of Etchics".

I was pretty pissed at TomCatter for what he did 7 years ago. But after thinking about it, and his apologizing for it....even though it was only because of, and after he was caught..........I just felt pity for him and hoped he could find some true meaning in his life and what he was doing and going to do with it. Hope he learned that he didn't need to be anything other than who he was. I never learned his fate.
 
Couple of notes:

1) Is Tim from Algeria?

2) For those saying that calling HR would be uncool - didn't there used to be a part about being of "good moral character" to be a pilot or mechanic? Has that changed? Is that no longer a requirment?
 
2) For those saying that calling HR would be uncool - didn't there used to be a part about being of "good moral character" to be a pilot or mechanic? Has that changed? Is that no longer a requirment?

Sure is, but what gives any of us the right to be the judge of that, to the point of taking it upon ourselves to have him removed from a job?

Everyone has the right to live his own life, and yes, that includes those who lie in ALPA magazines. You guys might not agree with that, but it's not your right, duty, or responsibility to enforce your own moral code on others. That would be extraordinarily egotistical on your part.
 
Are you saying that it is OK for him to cover this up? Somehow I don't believe he was completely forthright with CommutAir regarding the reason for his separation at American Eagle, but perhaps I am wrong.
 
Martins was outed for the actions he did, and paid the consequences for them. Do I think the rest of his life should be made hell for it? No. Only he knows inside what he feels about getting caught, and the price he's paid for it. I hope he learns a good few lessons for it, and in some way makes up for it.

Even our own TomCatter here on JC, who I personally busted 7 years ago this month for being a poser USN F-14 Tomcat pilot here on JC; to me, that situation is done and done. Hopefully, he learned his lesson and had gone on with his life. But I don't think chasing him down and ruining the rest of his life is the right thing to do either.

http://forums.jetcareers.com/48230-post31.html

http://forums.jetcareers.com/48230-post31.html

http://forums.jetcareers.com/general-topics/5337-my-apologies-all.html
Wow those posts sure bring back a lot of memories!:D Most of those people don't even post anymore!:crazy:
 
Guys, I understand not calling HR. Personally, I think that's a bad decision.

But let's get one thing clear; we're not saints, so let's not act as such. We will do nearly whatever it takes to ruin the careers and professional lives of scabs, and do so without apology. We have determined that this is a laudable cause, and we pat ourselves on the back for denying the jumpseat to "some worthless scab." We carry lists, and when we're forced to fly with them, we don't do anything but read checklists while in flight.

Is it a good idea to call HR on this guy? No. But let's not act as if we don't do it out of the goodness of our hearts. We will ruin careers if we feel the professional need to do so, and I'm not sure it's a good or a bad thing. What I DO think it is, is necessary in many respects, which is why nobody should be calling HR on this guy; it's unnecessary.
 
Are you saying that it is OK for him to cover this up? Somehow I don't believe he was completely forthright with CommutAir regarding the reason for his separation at American Eagle, but perhaps I am wrong.

Absolutely not, but in the end it's his problem. What do you guys care if he lied to CommutAir to get his job? Your greatest responsibility is to yourself, and yourself alone. Unless he's killing people in his spare time, what right do we have to contact his company and have him fired?
 
I think he's still less scary than the Colgan FO that tried to cut Smittey's throat with a Rambo knife in ground school. Then he told another Capt I flew with that he had a dream the night before where he had to kill him to take over the airplane....Is that d nozzle still working there?
 
I think he's still less scary than the Colgan FO that tried to cut Smittey's throat with a Rambo knife in ground school. Then he told another Capt I flew with that he had a dream the night before where he had to kill him to take over the airplane....Is that d nozzle still working there?
LOL.
 
Sure is, but what gives any of us the right to be the judge of that, to the point of taking it upon ourselves to have him removed from a job?

Thank you for being consistent with the same opinion you held in the FSDO thread a while back. :beer:

There is potentially a lot more want of action when the guy under the microscope is disliked and all the calls to 'MYOFB' can be pushed aside.
 
Guys, I understand not calling HR. Personally, I think that's a bad decision.

But let's get one thing clear; we're not saints, so let's not act as such. We will do nearly whatever it takes to ruin the careers and professional lives of scabs, and do so without apology. We have determined that this is a laudable cause, and we pat ourselves on the back for denying the jumpseat to "some worthless scab." We carry lists, and when we're forced to fly with them, we don't do anything but read checklists while in flight.

Is it a good idea to call HR on this guy? No. But let's not act as if we don't do it out of the goodness of our hearts. We will ruin careers if we feel the professional need to do so, and I'm not sure it's a good or a bad thing. What I DO think it is, is necessary in many respects, which is why nobody should be calling HR on this guy; it's unnecessary.

As I said, I believe Martins paid for his lie by losing his job at Eagle.

You do the crime, you pay the time. He shouldn't have to pay for the same crime for the rest of his life.

So the guy made ALPA look stupid with the collateral damage of his actions. It's not like he went scot free.

He has a long ladder to climb again. And its likely going to be a lonely climb in some respects.
 
I think he's still less scary than the Colgan FO that tried to cut Smittey's throat with a Rambo knife in ground school. Then he told another Capt I flew with that he had a dream the night before where he had to kill him to take over the airplane....Is that d nozzle still working there?

Yes, and he's about to upgrade too.....provided he passes training, that is. :dunno:
 
The CommutAir MEC is well aware of Tim Martins being in new-hire training. Let them deal with this issue as they see fit. Outside intervention is not needed. ;)
 
I don't think the guy is human scum, and I agree that calling HR isn't necessarily the classiest move especially if the pilot group knows about it.

I will say an important trait for someone in the 121 world is can some stand to sit by you and work with you effectively and safely. Unless this was just some aberration, I would guess he has some real personality problems. I am all for redemption, but a few months might be a short time to tackle some fundamental self worth issues, if not deeper problems. If I were in charge I would screen his application and kick him to to curb if he lied. If he managed to tell the straight truth, that would be an amazing good start.

I hope he is told that he is on a short leash, and better watch his Ps and Qs.

For those calling for his head, I can certainly see your point.:beer:
 
None of us know what's happened between AE and Commutair. Perhaps there's been some epiphany, professional counseling, a "mea culpa moment" or perhaps something else.

Leave the guy alone. Everyone knows who he is, and I'm sure he's already on a very short "professional leash" as it is.

I know we're in a recession, lots of furloughs, cutbacks and industry angst, but it's not necessarily carte blanche to go all vigilante on another pilot.

Yes, it was repulsive. But I have to give Commutair the benefit of the doubt on this one and presume that Mr. Martins has been through a professional metamorphosis after his dismissal from Eagle.

At least, until uhh, the next "Tim Martins will be mission commander of the final shuttle mission" article.
 
Back
Top