Tim Martins: CommutAir New Hire

None of us know what's happened between AE and Commutair. Perhaps there's been some epiphany, professional counseling, a "mea culpa moment" or perhaps something else.

Leave the guy alone. Everyone knows who he is, and I'm sure he's already on a very short "professional leash" as it is.

I know we're in a recession, lots of furloughs, cutbacks and industry angst, but it's not necessarily carte blanche to go all vigilante on another pilot.

Yes, it was repulsive. But I have to give Commutair the benefit of the doubt on this one and presume that Mr. Martins has been through a professional metamorphosis after his dismissal from Eagle.

At least, until uhh, the next "Tim Martins will be mission commander of the final shuttle mission" article.

Very much agree. I too think that the recession/pilot job shortages/furloughs/etc, all contribute to the "off with his head" mentality. Of course by NO means does he get a free pass.....he still has a price to pay.....but thats between him and Commutair. He paid the price of leaving Eagle already.
 
Compassion?
Considering this guys penchant for bending the truth--how do we know his logbook is even accurate? What if we forgive this guy, who we know lies frequently and often, and he lies about something important while carrying your loved ones causing a crash?

Would we still be willing to be compassionate?

He has no integrity and exhibits galactically poor judgment. Is this who you want flying people around?
 
Yes, and he's about to upgrade too.....provided he passes training, that is. :dunno:

That's right, you had to fly with him too. I don't know how a guy that thinks bringing a Rambo knife to training is a good idea is even allowed in the cockpit.
 
Considering this guys penchant for bending the truth--how do we know his logbook is even accurate? What if we forgive this guy, who we know lies frequently and often, and he lies about something important while carrying your loved ones causing a crash?

Would we still be willing to be compassionate?

He has no integrity and exhibits galactically poor judgment. Is this who you want flying people around?

Hate to say it, but perhaps that is what is needed.
 
Considering this guys penchant for bending the truth--how do we know his logbook is even accurate? What if we forgive this guy, who we know lies frequently and often, and he lies about something important while carrying your loved ones causing a crash?

Would we still be willing to be compassionate?

He has no integrity and exhibits galactically poor judgment. Is this who you want flying people around?

That's one heck of a leap of logic.

By all means guys, call CommutAir HR based on Internet posts about this guy and your raw emotions. Hell, call the FSDO while you're at it. When you're done though, go ahead and get Doug to deactivate your membership here at JC. I don't want to be a part of the same community as anyone who does the above.
 
I am not saying that people need to call HR on him, I agree that is uncool. I also ackowledge that A LOT of people know about him and I doubt he will get off the hook that easy. With that said, here are my issues and I am sure they are others as well.

It is nice to say "ohh what if he changed...leave him alone...he could be a different person..." blah blah blah. Are any of you willing to treat a scab like this? When we talk about scab's, people come out of nowhere willing to go to their house and actually cause physical harm to them. Some get downright crazy when it comes to scabs, and yet somehow that is ok but we should "leave this guy alone". I do not advocate violence and getting all crazy on scabs or anyone else, however I do think that for those that show no regard for professionalism and their fellow pilots then they should be outed and done away with.

All of you say that he hasn't hurt anyone. Are we sure? This guy has proven that he is willing to create not only a lie but a way blown out of proportion one at that and for what? Not only that, but he kept it up for a long time even when people outed him. So who else has he done this to. Like what was mentioned above, what if he has lied about flight time. Lying about flight time is small potatoes compared to what he came up with. So bottom line is, that this person who we don't know is telling the truth now or not may have taken someone elses job at commutair and maybe eagle when he wasn't deserving of it and there are plenty of other people out there who are and choose to be honest about themselves. How does that sit with everyone?

What about when this guy applies to Delta, UAL, Fedex, UPS etc. What if he lies and gets himself hired there. How has he not hurt anyone? He robbed someone else of a chance to be there who went by it honestly. And nobody say it can't happen. It can happen, and it DOES happen. How many of you know someone that has gone on to a major airline that you were like, "that is the last person that deserves a job like that"?

I have known people that got upgraded, typed, then downgraded and yet they continue to log PIC time. They will one day make it to a major because of their PIC time and beat someone else out for a job that actually earned it honestly. How does that sit with you? Are you sure this guy hasn't hurt anyone? I know I may be in a minority here because I am not being "forgiving" enough, but I have worked too hard to get where I am to continue to see dishonest people get ahead and good people get left behind. I stay out of trouble, never been arrested, went to college, log my time appropriately, and keep a good image on myself. I am not about to say it is ok for those people to be forgiven that easy that choose not to follow a few simple rules like I have. For those of you that have worked your butt off too to keep a clean image, you should feel the same way if you have any pride in what you had to do to keep it as such!
 
I remember what it was like when I knew everything. I don't miss those days.

My original point stands. If he has changed time will tell, if he hasn't time will tell sooner rather than later. He doesn't need our help and I don't need to treat him like crap to make myself feel better.
 
It should also be pointed out that due to the PRIA he is also responsible for disclosing all other companies thats he's worked for in the past (in the aviation field).

So unless he lied (which is possible) and "forgot" to mention AE, Commutair should know. Even if he did like, a simple google search should blow his cover anyways...
 
He's not a scab.

Every time we misuse that word, it's less scathing.

I'm sure somewhere, on some website, in some convoluted logic path someone thinks I'm a scab for doing my best to be cautious but encouraging about aviation.
 
A lie is a lie. It doesn't matter if the lie is about a maintenance item that you lie about so you can make a trip because of pressure from management, or if you lie about some other thing to keep yourself out of hot-water, or if you lie about your background like Tim Martins did (for whatever reason - to make himself look cool?). A lie is simply a lie. Someone who will lie when they don't have to is really compelling. Tim Martins didn't have to lie for the magazine article - he would gain no pay for being featured, he would gain no more days off - he simply lied for no tangible reason (other than the intangible "This will make people think I'm awesome"). This is particularly disturbing. I can make the leap and understand why someone would lie for personal gain - at least you can understand the reason. That is why Martins is unhinged - and why I would not ever want him in the front seat of an airplane that me or my family are on. That is why I wouldn't want a Captain to have to deal with him as an FO (think about it - "Did he REALLY do the walk-around?" and "Can I trust ANYTHING this guy tells me?"). The FAA has something about "good moral character" and I know that many will scoff at this - but it is there for a reason. Of course you will not catch everyone - but when someone lies this blatantly, for no apparent reason, it must mean he likes doing it - which means he's compulsive. I'm shocked that there is an outpouring of "he did his time" for this guy - particularly from MikeD. My sincere hope is that MikeD will eat a rare steak and perhaps watch a baby-seal clubbing video to get back in the right frame of mind.

As for Martins? Much like Joe Biden, he is a compulsive liar - and not good at it to boot. He doesn't belong anywhere near an airplane, or anywhere else for that matter. And, the HR chick that hired him - if this was known to her - needs to be fired as well.
 
That is why I wouldn't want a Captain to have to deal with him as an FO (think about it - "Did he REALLY do the walk-around?" and "Can I trust ANYTHING this guy tells me?").


Oooh! Ooh! I have a story about a similar situation but there's no way in hell I'm going to tell it on the Google indexable internet!

It's good. It'll have to wait for an in-person non-recorded moment over a cocktail.

It'll clear a LOT of stuff up! ;)
 
Back
Top