Accepting "Direct to.." when filed /A

No. VFR or IFR or not, while you can get to that exact point in space, you're not doing it with panel installed, certified navigation equipment on board the aircraft. Without proper tolerance certification, accepting something as precise as 'direct to a FIX' becomes an approximation at least to some degree.

Accepting a direct routing to a fix with uncertified equipment sounds like it would walk all over a few FARs.

Okay, lets define "direct" (from the Pilot Controller Glossary)
DIRECT− Straight line flight between two navigational
aids, fixes, points, or any combination thereof.
When used by pilots in describing off-airway routes,
points defining direct route segments become compulsory
reporting points unless the aircraft is under
radar contact.

Can I accept a DIRECT clearance VFR? I do almost every time I enter a Bravo. (which is a fairly often). Can I be cleared to something direct visually? Sure, any time I fly a visual IAP. The North Bay Visual RWY 17 @ KPIE is an example. Direct does not imply RNAV/GPS.

Back to the definition - Direct simply mean a straight line between any combination of navaids, fixes, or points. My PPL cross countries way back when (pre-GPS) were not on airways, yet had "direct" segments between visually identified landmarks. Those legs were straight line, and therefore, direct. I filed a flight plan, so presumably FSS was okay with it.
 
Direct from the AIM (5-1-8)

c. Direct Flights
1. All or any portions of the route which will not be flown on the radials or courses of established airways or routes, such as direct route flights, must be defined by indicating the radio fixes over which the flight will pass. Fixes selected to define the route shall be those over which the position of the aircraft can be accurately determined. Such fixes automatically become compulsory reporting points for the flight, unless advised otherwise by ATC. Only those navigational aids established for use in a particular structure; i.e., in the low or high structures, may be used to define the en route phase of a direct flight within that altitude structure.

So if you're /a with only a couple of VOR, sounds like you can only proceed directly to a VOR, but not a fix. And then the same section goes on to talk about service volumes for off airway navigation (260nm for high alt, 80 for low alt). I guess that explains why the DC-9s out and about always seem to get clearances like "fly heading 290, proceed XXX when able".
 
So if you're /a with only a couple of VOR, sounds like you can only proceed directly to a VOR, but not a fix. And then the same section goes on to talk about service volumes for off airway navigation (260nm for high alt, 80 for low alt).

If I am already over a VORTAC, what stops me from flying direct to a fix (even if it isn't on an airway)? I have the equipment to accurately determine both points...

All the AIM seems to be saying to me is that if you want to use a Fix, you need to have an accurate way of defining the fix. Specifically, you can't use a low altitude VOR when you are above its service volume. Seems like common sense to me.

I fly visually a lot. "Cleared to Aiport KXYZ" is very different than "Cleared Direct Airport KXYZ." Given the first clearance, it is very possible I would not want to fly in a straight line, for a variety of reasons.
 
If I am already over a VORTAC, what stops me from flying direct to a fix (even if it isn't on an airway)? I have the equipment to accurately determine both points...

All the AIM seems to be saying to me is that if you want to use a Fix, you need to have an accurate way of defining the fix. Specifically, you can't use a low altitude VOR when you are above its service volume. Seems like common sense to me.

Ah yeah...didn't think of that. So :yeahthat:
 
The question I always ran through my head with a handheld was "what would the FAA guy say if he was in the right seat". If you can look at a chart and show exactly where you are with what is INSTALLED in the aircraft you can use it. If you are using a 430/530/600/1000 you can show it all, a 496 WILL show where you are, but on the BOW W&B is it installed? Well...umm...you see....


It's your certificate, not mine. I went round and round with this back in the day (about 4 years ago) flying for an aircraft broker who bought planes with many times a sole radio, the FAA FSDO looked and told me "VFR only we have nothing that says you can't, IFR is a no-go using it for Nav". It has no bearing on me now, but things haven't changed beyond the fact that GA avionics are light years ahead of 121.
 
The controller seemed annoyed.

When PHL gives you direct DITCH, you are almost always on the 274 radial +/- about 3 degrees. A turn to the east would put you right on track for DITCH. That is a possible explanation for why the controller was annoyed.
 
The question I always ran through my head with a handheld was "what would the FAA guy say if he was in the right seat".

Who said anything about a handheld GPS?

I thought the question was whether you can accept a clearance "direct to" a fix with RNAV MEL'd? (Which I believe you can, in some circumstances, over a VOR, close to an intersecting airway being 2 examples). Military, you can do it "fix-to-fix" with DME and and RMI as well.
 
Who said anything about a handheld GPS?

I thought the question was whether you can accept a clearance "direct to" a fix with RNAV MEL'd? (Which I believe you can, in some circumstances, over a VOR, close to an intersecting airway being 2 examples). Military, you can do it "fix-to-fix" with DME and and RMI as well.

Someone asked the question in the thread, forgot to quote.
 
If I am already over a VORTAC, what stops me from flying direct to a fix (even if it isn't on an airway)? I have the equipment to accurately determine both points...

All the AIM seems to be saying to me is that if you want to use a Fix, you need to have an accurate way of defining the fix. Specifically, you can't use a low altitude VOR when you are above its service volume. Seems like common sense to me.

I fly visually a lot. "Cleared to Aiport KXYZ" is very different than "Cleared Direct Airport KXYZ." Given the first clearance, it is very possible I would not want to fly in a straight line, for a variety of reasons.


I'd agree to that right up the point where you said "If I'm already over a VORTAC".

What if you're not? The fix is VORTAC defined- but not from a position the onboard equipment can determine based on the depictions on your enroute/STAR/SID charts?

That's what I'm talking about.

If VFR, of course you can go "direct to the airport" or whatever.. but pilotage or dead reckoning... assuming those courses are predetermined and defined ahead of time based on the mode of navigation in use.

Example: In a recurrent sim, the instructor failed my GPS enroute to the missed approach holding fix. 'GPS 2 FAIL' was the fault. I asked the NFP (the Captain) to run the checklists - there were no real actions per the checklist. Then I asked for a VOR fix.

Then I improvised. I hit the NAV button on my nav control panel to cross feed from GPS 1 and went 'yellow needles'. This allowed me to slave the autopilot to the NAV mode again and ensure proper navigation reference.

My point in this? Without GPS direct, there wasn't any actual way to go direct to the fix. That was the whole point. Based on (of all things) previous experience flying -1900s with frequently MEL'd nav components, I reverted to that as my exit from the situation. Nearly all of my peers, I was told, were prone to frantically searching for radials and DME points that didn't exist based on the chart depiction.. or anything, really.

Were we truly reverted to /A, we would have had to declare 'unable' to fly the published missed approach on that particular procedure.
 
Okay, I'm certain most of us flying 121 have received an aircraft with an RNAV/UNS MELd.

The most important question that has been overlooked on this thread:

Was the unit not working (as in did it not turn on), or was the MEL a database out of date?

If it's a database, and you comply with the MEL (commonly verifying lat/longs against a current chart), and the MEL allows go direct.

If the box is shutoff, vectors only.
 
Well if I understand you, that's basically a DME arc right? And though you can do that with a pretty tight level of accuracy, it's not "direct". Now if the controller had said "Direct when able" then I suppose a whole host of methods could have been used to get us to DITCH.

Sorry, I answered before I looked at P8. The technique I mentioned will get you to a known distance from a NavAid on a known radial. In this situation you have a known radial but not a known distance. Therefore, the technique would not have worked for you.

Either way you could not accept a direct to but I think that's the general agreement anyway
 
When PHL gives you direct DITCH, you are almost always on the 274 radial +/- about 3 degrees. A turn to the east would put you right on track for DITCH. That is a possible explanation for why the controller was annoyed.

But she could not accept the clearance. Some controllers are better than others. I have been flying the DC-9 for just over a year, some controlers get it, and some are just annoyed.
 
But she could not accept the clearance. Some controllers are better than others. I have been flying the DC-9 for just over a year, some controlers get it, and some are just annoyed.

If you are already on the radial, there is no reason you can't accept the clearance. You know exactly where you are, and you know exactly where you need to go, and you know exactly how to get there. What more do you need?

I am not saying the OP was vectored onto the radial, but I have been flying out of PHL to DITCH for over a decade, both with and without RNAV. I would say about 90% of the time, they put you right on the 274 radial when they clear you to DITCH. I have no problem accepting that clearance without RNAV for the reasons I just mentioned.
 
If you are already on the radial, there is no reason you can't accept the clearance. You know exactly where you are, and you know exactly where you need to go, and you know exactly how to get there. What more do you need?

I am not saying the OP was vectored onto the radial, but I have been flying out of PHL to DITCH for over a decade, both with and without RNAV. I would say about 90% of the time, they put you right on the 274 radial when they clear you to DITCH. I have no problem accepting that clearance without RNAV for the reasons I just mentioned.

In the original question she wrote that she had just taken off and that she would need a vector to R-274. We understand from this that she wasn't on the radial.
We can IF this question to death and add other questions that aren't related, but the answer to her question is "NO". She was correct in her assessment of the situation.
 
My understanding is that you can request direct to wherever using a VFR GPS as a /U or whatever so long as you're within the operational service volume of a navaid.

Done that a few times actually.

It all depends on what your OPSPECS say. If you are authorized to use class I navigation at your company then you are able to go direct to anywhere you please with in the service volume, radar contact or not. If you are GA and are not operating under these OPSPECS it would not be legal but if you are close enough whos going to call you on it. The point of flying is to save time getting somewhere. Or to have lots of fun!:)
 
Man, it's been awhile since I did a "fix-to-fix". You'd tune, identity, monitor (TIM) the station, set up your HSI course for the outbound radial the fix is based on, turn in the shorter direction so that you're flying between the course arrow and bearing pointer (if you're going to a larger DME, favor the course, and if going to a smaller DME, favor the bearing pointer.). Once you're headed in the right direction, you check your heading at regular DME proportions using a small pencil or straw. Correct for known winds.

It's a fairly crude method, but you can get good at it with practice. In UPT, we had to use this method to arrive at a fix within 2nm, although I don't think they're making the folks do it anymore. With tightened up RNP requirements, etc, it just doesn't really cut it as a reliable means of IFR navigation anymore.
 
Man, it's been awhile since I did a "fix-to-fix". You'd tune, identity, monitor (TIM) the station, set up your HSI course for the outbound radial the fix is based on, turn in the shorter direction so that you're flying between the course arrow and bearing pointer (if you're going to a larger DME, favor the course, and if going to a smaller DME, favor the bearing pointer.). Once you're headed in the right direction, you check your heading at regular DME proportions using a small pencil or straw. Correct for known winds.

It's a fairly crude method, but you can get good at it with practice. In UPT, we had to use this method to arrive at a fix within 2nm, although I don't think they're making the folks do it anymore. With tightened up RNP requirements, etc, it just doesn't really cut it as a reliable means of IFR navigation anymore.

this is exactly what I was refering to! We, too, had to hit our distance w/in 2 miles. Those were fun days. And you're right, can't use it in RightSeatGirls' situation...
 
When PHL gives you direct DITCH, you are almost always on the 274 radial +/- about 3 degrees. A turn to the east would put you right on track for DITCH. That is a possible explanation for why the controller was annoyed.

Not true at all...we often get DITCH well North of the radial and that night we were. I centered the CDI and we were on the 292.
 
Back
Top