Accepting "Direct to.." when filed /A

RightSeatGirl

KA'PLAH BITCHES!
Okay, I'm certain most of us flying 121 have received an aircraft with an RNAV/UNS MELd. So this basically means we have to radio navigate. A few weeks back we had our RNAV inop, took off from PHL on the P8 SID and were given Direct DITCH from the controller, I was PM, and responded "unable direct, we need a vector to join the CYN 274 radial to the fix." The controller seemed annoyed and the Cap I was flying with, a training dept guy, said we can absolutely accept "direct". Once we landed I asked him to explain how we can fly "direct" to a fix without an RNAV, he started talking about all this guestimation stuff and he lost me...

My question is about the legality, can you accept "Direct" to a non-facility fix without an RNAV/UNS? Is there some old skool technique to do this that I am unaware of? Because short of joining a radial and tracking inbound until the appropriate DME, unless you triangulate your exact position, bust out a plotter, well...I don't get it...
 
No you can't, you were correct. You could do fix to fix if you knew how to do the procedure, but I've never heard of it being taught outside of the military.
 
Okay, I'm certain most of us flying 121 have received an aircraft with an RNAV/UNS MELd. So this basically means we have to radio navigate. A few weeks back we had our RNAV inop, took off from PHL on the P8 SID and were given Direct DITCH from the controller, I was PM, and responded "unable direct, we need a vector to join the CYN 274 radial to the fix." The controller seemed annoyed and the Cap I was flying with, a training dept guy, said we can absolutely accept "direct". Once we landed I asked him to explain how we can fly "direct" to a fix without an RNAV, he started talking about all this guestimation stuff and he lost me...

My question is about the legality, can you accept "Direct" to a non-facility fix without an RNAV/UNS? Is there some old skool technique to do this that I am unaware of? Because short of joining a radial and tracking inbound until the appropriate DME, unless you triangulate your exact position, bust out a plotter, well...I don't get it...


As far as I know you're absolutely correct.
 
Heres another question that goes along with this topic. Youre /A and report the field in sight, ATC says cleared direct to the airport, but doesnt clear you for the visual approach. Can you accept direct to the airport without RNAV?
 
That must be why you're called the "right"seatgirl. You're absolutely correct.

There is a means to intercept the distance on a radial using an old technique but it is not authorized for use (considering this situation) under the perfomance standards of today.
 
The controller seemed annoyed and the Cap I was flying with, a training dept guy, said we can absolutely accept "direct". Once we landed I asked him to explain how we can fly "direct" to a fix without an RNAV, he started talking about all this guestimation stuff and he lost me...

Aroo??
 
That must be why you're called the "right"seatgirl. You're absolutely correct.

There is a means to intercept the distance on a radial using an old technique but it is not authorized for use (considering this situation) under the perfomance standards of today.

Well if I understand you, that's basically a DME arc right? And though you can do that with a pretty tight level of accuracy, it's not "direct". Now if the controller had said "Direct when able" then I suppose a whole host of methods could have been used to get us to DITCH.

As far as field in sight, yes. When you call field in sight you are announcing that you now have the visual capability of flying straight to the field. Cleared for the visual then means you may deviate from direct to the field navigation in order to line up on your assigned runway.
 
You are correct, you can always mention you are "Vector equipped" and you can be vectored to join the filed route like the 9's and 72's in the world. I applaud the avatar returning but I think you have trademarked it on here- jtrain needs to let it go....

Quite surprising a check airman didn't agree. Only way I think he could have been right is if you were cleared to a VOR, not a RNAV point.
 
/A cannot accept direct.

My aircraft is /A. I go about going direct either by RV to a fix and then A/F'ed, RV to my destination or ask for my on course heading direct (would like to get heading 320 direct XYZ - when possible). Most of the controllers are accommodating, but I have had a few who have gotten their panties in a bunch.
 
Get this aaaaaaaaall day in Potomac airspace while flying /A.

"XXX, proceed direct KRENE."
"Unable direct, XXX."
"XXX, fly heading 230."

No need to get fancy with it.
 
Question for the masses:

Can you accept "Direct To" with /A and a hand held GPS.

Careful with your answer!


No. VFR or IFR or not, while you can get to that exact point in space, you're not doing it with panel installed, certified navigation equipment on board the aircraft. Without proper tolerance certification, accepting something as precise as 'direct to a FIX' becomes an approximation at least to some degree.

Accepting a direct routing to a fix with uncertified equipment sounds like it would walk all over a few FARs.
 
My guess is the controllers who get all bent out of shape over it are either incredibly lazy or haven't worked ATC very long. It comes down to more of a wording thing than legality thing. "Heading 320 to intercept", or "direct when able" works just fine. Simply "direct" is technically not legal for /A even if you have your own means of going direct.
 
Not that I disagree with the logic that you can not accept "direct to" without /G, there are several non-FAR/AIM publications that suggest it's perfectly acceptable as it's being used as "situational awareness".

Even a GNS530 doesn't have to be current for enroute operations.
 
My understanding is that you can request direct to wherever using a VFR GPS as a /U or whatever so long as you're within the operational service volume of a navaid.

Done that a few times actually.
 

In my experience, training dept guys aren't all that great at thinking outside the box. Great at doing a perfectly standard single engine non precision approach to mins with a single engine go around, etc. But when catering doesn't show up at the plane or we're trying to figure out what econ speed to fly, they're not the quickest. I don't know that its their fault, I think they just spend too much time flying the box and not staying current in real world experience. That is presuming this training dept person she was with was a sim instructor. I've found our standards people to be pretty good.
 
In the FWIW column:

IFR Magizine's editiorial posiiton is that you may accept a direct clearance when simply /A using using the "close enough" VOR triangulation method or whatever else you can come up with.

There is also an ATC type who hangs out on the AOPA and Pilots of America formums who insists that direct nav via VFR GPS is absolutely okay in a radar enviormnemt (which, at least in theory, is the only palce you shoud get a dirtect route outside of the service volume of a VOR) .

Me, if I am in radar contact, I'm in the "I only have a handheld GPS. Can you give me a heading" wink-wink school of thought.
 
My understanding is that you can request direct to wherever using a VFR GPS as a /U or whatever so long as you're within the operational service volume of a navaid.

Done that a few times actually.
If correct, I think the theory is radar contact, not merely in the service volume of a VOR.
 
Back
Top