Whats more common?

Never said I was. But, when shown a statement saying "Wouldn't tell a DPE that", with nothing else accompanying it, some people would infer that to mean teaching for a checkride. Teach what's practical, not what is going to work to please a single person, on a single day.
:)


Some people might, we shouldn't.

He is talking about something with a very loose application and your subject of complaint is very broad.

=

forum explosion.
 
I did

On my last 135 checkride (from the FSDO guy himself) I was asked, "when do you need an official weather briefing and where can you get one?"

I answered "not required for 91 flights or 135 VFR flights, Required on all IFR 135 flights (according to our op-specs) and you can get one from anyone that is QCIP qualified (which includes aviationweather.gov)"

he said, "your exactly right"

I would rather tell a DPE the difference between legal and smart, then to say that an official briefing is required for ALL flights, which is totally incorrect.

Uhh oh. Somebody is using common sense!
 


Show me where its required to prove it with your N number then.

Your quote you quoted says it is not intended to replace a briefing required by the FAA.

The FAA only requires an official briefing for 121 and 135 flights.

so your quote is not valid.

AWC...

Currently, GA and public access to AWC's aviation weather information over the Public Internet is not regulated. However, particular aviation users are restricted by FAA regulation from using ADDS.aviationweather.gov and AviationWeather.gov web sites. Volume 3 chapter 7 section 3 paragraph 1441 of the Air Transportation Operations Inspector's Handbook, Order 8900.1 states that if a part 121 or 135 operator obtains aviation weather or notices to airmen (NOTAM) data via the Public Internet, the operator must use an approved FAA Qualified Internet Communication Provider (QICP).

AWC's web sites now conform to the FAA's QICP standards described in FAA Advisory Circular AC 00-62 for reliability, accessibility, and security of internet communications of aviation weather and NOTAMs. This AC is not mandatory and does not constitute a regulation; however, part 121 and 135 operators are not authorized to obtain aviation weather information from AWC web sites without this designation. With QICP certification, AWC's aviation weather products will be authorized by the FAA for the commercial aviation community over the internet.
 

91.32 also says I need oxygen above 12,500 or 14000. I guess I need to buy a camera to mount on my airplane so I can prove to the FAA that I was actually using oxygen in case I crash.

Read 91.103, It says you must know all available information, but no where does it say that you need to prove you got it by using a website that records your Tail #.

I guess most of my flying is in the bush, I did a charter to Ashland MT the other day which is a grass strip in the middle of no where, no cell service Internet or anything. We finally got a waiver in our opspecs that allow us to take off VFR without an official brief, (we still comply with 91.103 because there is little information available). Now were allowed to use our own good judgement IF its VFR flight only.

Are you saying that if you land there, spend the night there, you can never fly out because there is nobody to record your tail # that you got a brief? Even if one is not available?

Thats the advantage of part 91 flying. Less rules and regulation. Lets keep it that way. And teach our students the difference between legal, safe and common sense.
 
FDX:
Weather,Known ATC delays,Runway length,Alternates,Fuel,Take'off and landing distance.

These are the things you must know before every x-c.
You need to prove that you had a weather brief via your N number on file.


Yeah, and I can find those things on TWC, FAA website, sectional chart, AF/D, POH....all without getting a briefing from a briefer or DUATs. You're telling me I need to have something track my N-number every time I take care of checking those things?

Prove to me that you need to have an N number on file.
 
Yeah, and I can find those things on TWC, FAA website, sectional chart, AF/D, POH....all without getting a briefing from a briefer or DUATs. You're telling me I need to have something track my N-number every time I take care of checking those things?

Prove to me that you need to have an N number on file.
-Mr FAA Man or Lady " did you get the weather before you flew into this freezing rain and had to make a emergancy?"
-Pilot Dude "Yes and it said there was no chance for freezing precip"
-Mr FAA Man or Lady "do you have a print out of the weather you got"
-Pilot Dude "No I don't"
-Mr FAA Man or Lady "then prove to us you got weather before your flight"
-Pilot Dude "uhhhh....."

You're playing a game you can't win.
 
91.32 also says I need oxygen above 12,500 or 14000. I guess I need to buy a camera to mount on my airplane so I can prove to the FAA that I was actually using oxygen in case I crash.
Now we don't need to get lippy. It doesn't serve the discussion.

Read 91.103, It says you must know all available information, but no where does it say that you need to prove you got it by using a website that records your Tail #.

I guess most of my flying is in the bush, I did a charter to Ashland MT the other day which is a grass strip in the middle of no where, no cell service Internet or anything. We finally got a waiver in our opspecs that allow us to take off VFR without an official brief, (we still comply with 91.103 because there is little information available). Now were allowed to use our own good judgement IF its VFR flight only.

Are you saying that if you land there, spend the night there, you can never fly out because there is nobody to record your tail # that you got a brief? Even if one is not available?


Thats the advantage of part 91 flying. Less rules and regulation. Lets keep it that way. And teach our students the difference between legal, safe and common sense.

I'm saying that if you get in an accident you will be violated via 91.103.
 
-Mr FAA Man or Lady " did you get the weather before you flew into this freezing rain and had to make a emergancy?"
-Pilot Dude "Yes and it said there was no chance for freezing precip"
-Mr FAA Man or Lady "do you have a print out of the weather you got"
-Pilot Dude "No I don't"
-Mr FAA Man or Lady "then prove to us you got weather before your flight"
-Pilot Dude "uhhhh....."

You're playing a game you can't win.

I'm just trying to make a point that LEGALLY you can get away with doing those things. Are those smart things to do? No! But legally, it is completely acceptable.

You still have failed to show me a reg that proves your point, which is that you need to have an N-number listed somewhere proving you got a weather briefing.
 
Where is the basis for argument if there is no rule or regulation to argue over?
They don't need one. The FAA writes the regs and enforces them. Regs are open to interpretation just like any law and quess who gets to interpret them..the FAA. Sure you can appeal to the NTSB but they don't have time for it. They can get you one 91.103 and even 91.13 is they are feeling nasty that day.

You crash and die, the weather happens to be bad. Unless you used a weather service that records your N number they are going to assume you didn't get any weather info before you flew. You may say who cares I'm dead, but it may mean something to the ones you leave behind.
 
I'm just trying to make a point that LEGALLY you can get away with doing those things. Are those smart things to do? No! But legally, it is completely acceptable.

You still have failed to show me a reg that proves your point, which is that you need to have an N-number listed somewhere proving you got a weather briefing.
I understand that but with all the money I spent on my ratings, the last thing I want to do is "get away with things" I rather play it safe, why do people think its such a negative thing?
 
They don't need one. The FAA writes the regs and enforces them. Regs are open to interpretation just like any law and quess who gets to interpret them..the FAA. Sure you can appeal to the NTSB but they don't have time for it. They can get you one 91.103 and even 91.13 is they are feeling nasty that day.

You crash and die, the weather happens to be bad. Unless you used a weather service that records your N number they are going to assume you didn't get any weather info before you flew. You may say who cares I'm dead, but it may mean something to the ones you leave behind.

What if I have weather charts/forecasts/other data that doesn't track my n-number (TWC,NOAA, other weather center data). You're telling me that I can't legally do that because there is no paper trail attached to my n-number? Interesting...

Agree to disagree.
 
They don't need one. The FAA writes the regs and enforces them. Regs are open to interpretation just like any law and quess who gets to interpret them..the FAA. Sure you can appeal to the NTSB but they don't have time for it. They can get you one 91.103 and even 91.13 is they are feeling nasty that day.

You crash and die, the weather happens to be bad. Unless you used a weather service that records your N number they are going to assume you didn't get any weather info before you flew. You may say who cares I'm dead, but it may mean something to the ones you leave behind.

If your dead then why would you care if you get violated or not?

I win.
 
I understand that but with all the money I spent on my ratings, the last thing I want to do is "get away with things" I rather play it safe, why do people think its such a negative thing?


Dude, I completely understand what you're saying. My point is that it's completely legal to use other sources of weather information, and it is not required by any rule or regulation to be able have your n-number trailed back to a weather briefing. Is it safe or smart? No. Is it legal, yes.
 
What if I have weather charts/forecasts/other data that doesn't track my n-number (TWC,NOAA, other weather center data). You're telling me that I can't legally do that because there is no paper trail attached to my n-number? Interesting...

Agree to disagree.
I never said it's illegal. It's a matter of proof. If you use DUATS or call then you get a majority of the info that you are looking for and a paper trail. After that go on to whatever site you want, but at least you have the paper trail and proof that you received weather and other pertinent info.

When I taught Ground School I always told my students that we can debate regs till the cows come home. But if I where you id just play it safe, have a paper trail, and the piece of mind that comes with it.
 
Back
Top