Whats more common?

Champcar

Well-Known Member
At the flight school where I got a majority of my ratings, we did a Weight and Balance and got a weather briefing before every flight, no matter how routine or if it was clear and a million and just going around the pattern. Since that was how I was taught, that is what I do.

My experiance with other Flight Schools though is that this is not the case. I have walked in for a check out and had the CFI say lets go fly, no weight and balance for this particular flight or checking the weather. Now I end up saying hold up In a polite way in these situations and crunch the numbers my self and check Duats quick.There is a FSDO right on the field and all it takes is one line check to make for a bad day.

I was curious to see which situation is more common out there?
 
Well, you really don't have to do a weight and balance every flight. We did do it a couple of times though, since it teaches the student how to do it. I always taught my students to be familiar with weight and balance. So after they proved that we were legal to fly, then I wouldn't have him do it again (for us). But I would tell them that if they decided to change the configuration, maybe throwing some friends in the back, then it is worth checking again. I would also have them play around with the weight shift formula just to test different scenarios. Again, this also really depends on what kind of plane you have. We flew C172's for singles, and you can load them up pretty much any way you want and they are normally within CG.

As for weather, I pretty much did what you did. Again, especially for local flights, you don't "have" to check the weather, but I would anyways. The real reason I made them do it was to check TFR's. It is also good practice for the cross-country stage. We used DUATS as well, that way they could mess around with it at home.

I too have seen the "lets go fly" thing. And I don't have a problem with it, especially if the instructor quickly checked the NOTAMS before they left. Also, for things like pattern work I could see someone not checking. The really important thing is making sure the student knows how to do these things, especially when they need them.
 
At the flight school where I got a majority of my ratings, we did a Weight and Balance and got a weather briefing before every flight, no matter how routine or if it was clear and a million and just going around the pattern. Since that was how I was taught, that is what I do.

My experiance with other Flight Schools though is that this is not the case. I have walked in for a check out and had the CFI say lets go fly, no weight and balance for this particular flight or checking the weather. Now I end up saying hold up In a polite way in these situations and crunch the numbers my self and check Duats quick.There is a FSDO right on the field and all it takes is one line check to make for a bad day.

I was curious to see which situation is more common out there?

The N-number specific weight and balance data which is a part of the operating limitations is required to be on board the aircraft.

Look at 91.103.

There is nothing in the regs stating that you have to physically have a weight and balance computed for each flight inside the aircraft.

If you are going to fly consistently in the same make model and type (by "type" I mean 172"R", 172"N" etc.) of aircraft with your instructor, and have done a weight and balance with them in the aircraft for a previous flight, and know that with full tanks and whatever you bring on board you are within the envelope, then that suffices legally.

If I were you, I would just write up a weight and balance that includes you and your instructor, full tanks, x amount of baggage (average of whatever you usually take), slip it inside a plastic paper sleeve and tuck it inside your flight bag so that you can have it handy should you ever need to prove your assessment with documentation.

As far as weather goes, you don't have to get a phone briefing from an AFSS, or an electronic briefing from DUATs. A quick look at NOAA (aviationweather.gov) will suffice.

However, under your PIC authority, you can do whatever you like. So if someone is going to rush you into flying without letting you do whatever you need to do to feel "in the loop," you can tell them to pound sand.
 
As FDX said, being ramp checked wouldn't be a big deal in this case.


Out of four schools, one has required w&b and a flight plan prior to every flight.

It wasn't half bad, it wasn't half good either.

My current school requires a copy of the W&B and flt plan prior to a x-c.
I agree with that.
 
I guess the W&B thing is more habit than anything. I just feel better having all the info with me for each flight. I always want to be prepared for whatever happens.
 
The N-number specific weight and balance data which is a part of the operating limitations is required to be on board the aircraft.

Look at 91.103.

There is nothing in the regs stating that you have to physically have a weight and balance computed for each flight inside the aircraft.

If you are going to fly consistently in the same make model and type (by "type" I mean 172"R", 172"N" etc.) of aircraft with your instructor, and have done a weight and balance with them in the aircraft for a previous flight, and know that with full tanks and whatever you bring on board you are within the envelope, then that suffices legally.

If I were you, I would just write up a weight and balance that includes you and your instructor, full tanks, x amount of baggage (average of whatever you usually take), slip it inside a plastic paper sleeve and tuck it inside your flight bag so that you can have it handy should you ever need to prove your assessment with documentation.

As far as weather goes, you don't have to get a phone briefing from an AFSS, or an electronic briefing from DUATs. A quick look at NOAA (aviationweather.gov) will suffice.

However, under your PIC authority, you can do whatever you like. So if someone is going to rush you into flying without letting you do whatever you need to do to feel "in the loop," you can tell them to pound sand.
I disagree withonly using aviationweather.gov. It doesn't record a n number so how is the faa to know if you actually received the weather?
 
Out of four schools, one has required w&b and a flight plan prior to every flight.

I have only had one flight school that had something like that. If you didn't do a flight plan or get a wx briefing they made you sign a waiver of liability, that they would not be held responsible if anything went wrong. I guess it was for insurance purposes.
 
I guess the W&B thing is more habit than anything. I just feel better having all the info with me for each flight. I always want to be prepared for whatever happens.

Like you need to spit out your gum and need something to put it in?
 
I first started flying at a small FBO in michigan. I recently got a job with a flight school in Daytona. Up north in michigan at this FBO, there was no weight/balance requirement. I was required to know how to do it and why and all that, but it was not required before every flight. At the flight school down here, im required to do a weight and balance before every flight, as long as takeoff/landing distances, and current weather.

So i've seen both sides of the fence. personally i think its a good idea to do w/b and get weather before each flight. Especially down here in central Florida where the weather can build up to nasty storms and poor visibility in just a few minutes.

I think at small FBO'S and mom and pop places its a little less common and at the bigger pilot mills (riddle, UND, etc.) its probably more common to do w/b and all that before each flight.
 
I disagree withonly using aviationweather.gov. It doesn't record a n number so how is the faa to know if you actually received the weather?

The FAA doesn't care if you get a weather briefing or not.
For a local flight you can pretty much get all the info you need from local news channel weather. Plus, being able to just look up at the sky and see what type of clouds are there, humidity, wind direction and speed will serve you better than some Duats briefings.
 
The FAA doesn't care if you get a weather briefing or not.
For a local flight you can pretty much get all the info you need from local news channel weather. Plus, being able to just look up at the sky and see what type of clouds are there, humidity, wind direction and speed will serve you better than some Duats briefings.

not something i would tell a DPE though.
 
I disagree withonly using aviationweather.gov. It doesn't record a n number so how is the faa to know if you actually received the weather?

....Show me in the regs where it says the FAA has to be able to tell whether or not you received a weather briefing.

There is FAA published material that even suggests using The Weather Channel and Skyvector for the "big picture" in regard to weather (FAA's Instrument Proficiency Check Guide)...no way to track an N-number using those sources.
 
....Show me in the regs where it says the FAA has to be able to tell whether or not you received a weather briefing.

There is FAA published material that even suggests using The Weather Channel and Skyvector for the "big picture" in regard to weather (FAA's Instrument Proficiency Check Guide)...no way to track an N-number using those sources.
You think the faa will take your word for it? The faa has better lawyers than you, they dont need a specific reg for everything.
 
Nope, didn't say that at all. Still wouldn't tell a DPE that though.

Fair enough. I'm all for doing what's practical for a flight. Do I really need to spend 20+ minutes on DUAT to get a weather brief to pound out an hour of touch and goes? Probably not


ORLY? You are really making that snap decision based on that comment?

You don't have to be the white knight of flight instruction just yet.

Never said I was. But, when shown a statement saying "Wouldn't tell a DPE that", with nothing else accompanying it, some people would infer that to mean teaching for a checkride. Teach what's practical, not what is going to work to please a single person, on a single day.
 
FDX:
Weather,Known ATC delays,Runway length,Alternates,Fuel,Take'off and landing distance.

These are the things you must know before every x-c.
You need to prove that you had a weather brief via your N number on file.

The AWC Homepage "Standard Briefing" is intended as a tool to help pilots better visualize weather and weather-related hazards. It is not intended as a substitute for a weather briefing obtained from a Flight Service Station (1-800-WXBRIEF). Currently, the information contained here does not meet the FAA requirements for a pre-flight weather brief. Therefore, it's important that pilots still call and obtain a briefing from an FAA Flight Service Specialist
 
not something i would tell a DPE though.


I did

On my last 135 checkride (from the FSDO guy himself) I was asked, "when do you need an official weather briefing and where can you get one?"

I answered "not required for 91 flights or 135 VFR flights, Required on all IFR 135 flights (according to our op-specs) and you can get one from anyone that is QCIP qualified (which includes aviationweather.gov)"

he said, "your exactly right"

I would rather tell a DPE the difference between legal and smart, then to say that an official briefing is required for ALL flights, which is totally incorrect.
 
Back
Top