Captain relieved of her command

USMCmech

Well-Known Member
It must have been REALLY bad if they relived her and did so in such a public manner.

http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1969602,00.html


The more important issue is how do officers with ZERO leadership skills keep getting promoted? The problem is bad in all the branches of the military.

Chesty Puller, Bull Halsey, Jimmy Dolitle, Patton, and Chuck Yeager would never have been promoted past O-3 in today's military. It's truly sad.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

The more important issue is how do officers with ZERO leadership skills keep getting promoted. The problem is bad in all the branches of the military.

It's usually screw up, move up......ie- get rid of them in order to make them someone else's problem. Now, WHY they tend to get moved UP to get them out of the way is something I haven't figured out yet.

Chesty Puller, Bull Halsey, Jimmy Dolitle Patton, and Chuck Yeager would never have been promoted past O-3 in today's military. It's truly sad.


When I was getting promoted to O-4, The Wing Commander giving my reccomendation for promotion warned me that I had "too much combat time" and that "I don't see any record of you having done any staff work, or anything that would show a well rounded candidate?"

Sorry, sir, for having my ass gone all this time doing my freaking job of dropping bombs and killing the enemy. Jackass.

He then proceeded to tell me how guys like Robin Olds (famed Vietnam commander) would never make it in today's USAF. I couldn't figure out what was worse: that he seemed to accept this as somehow "normal", or that he didnt seem to give a rats ass to try and change it since he was part of the problem himself.

I told him that I had come to this meeting not only to get promotion feedback, but I also wanted him to give me reasons why I should stay in the USAF, what with my Active Duty Service Committment being nearly up. Instead, he sealed the deal on why I should leave the corporation.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Doesn't surprise me at all about the Captain. Certainly the military is big today about promoting those who do the staff tours, the joint tours, etc. As an aviator, I say you lead from the cockpit but not anymore. Hell, my last operational CO was a staff and sure as , he couldn't lead children to the bathroom but he was CO. Medicore pilot, leader and manager but I he got those checks in the box, JMPE I and II, joint tour, etc. Where has these men gone:

sto0-012.jpg


060509af_numbers_olds800.jpg
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Chesty Puller, Bull Halsey, Jimmy Dolitle, Patton, and Chuck Yeager would never have been promoted past O-3 in today's military. It's truly sad.

This...although Yeager is a nozzle, the sentiment is correct.

Bunk, is that Stockdale?
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

He then proceeded to tell me how guys like Robin Olds (famed Vietnam commander) would never make it in today's USAF. I couldn't figure out what was worse: that he seemed to accept this as somehow "normal", or that he didnt seem to give a rats ass to try and change it since he was part of the problem himself.

Truth is.. Olds barely made it in the OLD USAF. Olds came out of WWII as a Lt. Col or at best, a full Colonel at a time when there were 'full bulls' in their mid 20s. It was not until AFTER Vietnam that he got his star. The 'warrior' class has always been held in some disdain by the 'professionals'. Some things don't change.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

I would add that with her response
Graf told the IG she had "no recollection" of making such comments, and the report says she "appeared incredulous at the accusations." She "repeatedly" emphasized her "very high standards for [her] crew" and "repeatedly" spoke of a "groupthink mentality" aboard her vessel. Graf said a "small group of disgruntled officers in the Cowpens wardroom were spreading rumors throughout the crew and convincing others that the command climate and [her] demeanor were far worse than they actually were."
..she may have a bright future in politics.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Women like her make me want to hurl. :rolleyes:

There will be those who say she got to where she was because she's a woman (which may or may not be true). What she's done has poisoned the well and will make life much difficult for the women coming after her.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

There are always one or two who slip through. In my time in the military the vast majority of the leaders where okay. Not spectacular, but they were okay. About 10% were great. Then, there were the 5%. I had one who would call me in at 0200 to ask me about aircraft status. Once threw an aircraft fire extinguisher at me (it left a dent in the wall), because the safety could be pulled with a finger and he did not like it when I told him "That's the point". Saw him hit a crew chief. Would fly his kids around in Army aircraft. Used motor pool parts to have his POV fixed. Took off with an aircraft for several days and never told anyone except the top where he was. I even got escorted to my hooch and placed under house arrest one time. The guy was so bad no one else wanted him but the upper CO was afraid of him and would not just relieve him of the command.
It happens. At least in this case leadership recognized a problem and took care of it.
Probably my only gripe is that in combat LTs and CPTs get relieved on a fairly regular basis. Not so much for COLs and above, although it does happen.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Some random thoughts...

What interests me about this is that, this kind of personality is somewhat encouraged in the military. Perhaps a better way to say it is that the military takes young men and women and actively trains, or at least contributes, to their being these kinds of tough, gung-ho, go-get-'em personalities. And I would imagine that there are times when that is exactly what is needed. But then everyone expects them to turn that off at the end of the day; we act surprised when they can't or don.t. I don't know, maybe the ability to turn it off an on is what makes a "well-rounded" soldier.

And whose to say she was "incompetent?" It's the Peter Principle. You rise to the level of your incompetence. She may have been a very fine junior officer who just finally rose her level of incompetence; the "bad behavior" emerged as a result of her frustation/stress/whatever of not being able to handle her new job" I have a hard time believing an truly incompetent officer could rise that high.

Also interesting to me is the emphasis on airmanship that many seem to value as the the most important qualification of rank. Certainly it's important, but it's not the end-all/be-all of competence. I have known many fine airmen that I wouldn't want anywhere near any kind of management position.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Women like her make me want to hurl. :rolleyes:

There will be those who say she got to where she was because she's a woman (which may or may not be true). What she's done has poisoned the well and will make life much difficult for the women coming after her.

You can argue the affirmative action/gender bias case, but I think it's more broad than that. Some might claim it was because she was a woman, but I think military commanders are all just too scared to pull the trigger on another officer these days. It doesn't matter the demographic- nobody wants to be the bad guy anymore, and sadly, that's part of what command IS.

"I'd relieve them, but I don't want the responsibility of having ruined their career."

The U.S. Military culture is rotten with this sort of nonsense these days. Apparently the criteria for decorations is now rank-specific, too. If you're a platoon sergeant or higher, you'll get Bronze Star (for Merit) or now maybe a Meritorious Service Medal (MSM for Merit) for completion of a combat tour. If you don't hold those ranks, it doesn't matter.

I served with a three striper- just a buck sergeant, who stepped up into a position slotted for a grade higher than he held, kicked ass, and made no bones. He really did an amazing job of a hugely complex, vital task.

He was put in for a Bronze Star for Merit. It was denied. Why? He was just a Sergeant, and even though he warranted by his actions, somebody thought his rank excluded him.

Meanwhile, a much more senior individual sat in his tent all year and did college courses on the internet. An official Army internet satellite connection, I might add.

He got a Bronze Star.

Not to mention- this Navy Captain's got two Admirals in the family? Nobody's greasing her skids, me arse. I'd wager there was pure nepotism keeping her out of trouble, even if there's no backtrail.

Nobody- of either gender.. would get away with that kind of behavior for long otherwise.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Also interesting to me is the emphasis on airmanship that many seem to value as the the most important qualification of rank. Certainly it's important, but it's not the end-all/be-all of competence. I have known many fine airmen that I wouldn't want anywhere near any kind of management position.

Not rank specifically, but moreso rank and position. As an Air Force leader (I would asume the same for Army/Navy/MC aviation too), especialy one of a flying Squadron/Group/Wing, much of your baseline credibility as a leader of airborne combat professionals comes from how well you yourself are able to do the job and lead from the front. If you can't do the job well, or can't lead the combat missions, how can you now critique your troops who do perform the job, when you lack the credibility to do so?

I was in one squadron where the Commander, an O-5 had 1800 hours of jet time in our type, and 18 years in. I was a freaking O-3 at time with 1400 or so and 10 years less as a military pilot. Turns out, this guy.....while not necessarily a bad guy personally.....was one of those who simply did a touch and go at each assignment, spent only the amount of time needed to check the box for promotion needs, and spent minimal time flying. However he did all the great staff tours, intermediate level schools and working on the senior level schools, but only flew the non-complicated sorties in order to remain a little better than current. From an officer/leader standpoint, that's hard to "look up" to this guy, even though he wasn't personally a bad guy. He could do the staff work with the best of them, but should've remained in that career route, IMHO.

There's where the difference is.

There are those who are the warriors.....the "break glass in time of war" guys. And there are those who are the staff types who do great working the D.C. cocktail party circuit in their Mess Dress. Rarely....extremely rare.....are they one and the same person.
 
lol idk why but that part about putting a master chief in "time out" was kinda funny :D I'm not hating, we love our master chiefs in the navy lol
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Not rank specifically, but moreso rank and position. As an Air Force leader (I would asume the same for Army/Navy/MC aviation too), especialy one of a flying Squadron/Group/Wing, much of your baseline credibility as a leader of airborne combat professionals comes from how well you yourself are able to do the job and lead from the front. If you can't do the job well, or can't lead the combat missions, how can you now critique your troops who do perform the job, when you lack the credibility to do so?

Fair point.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

Fair point.

Its a good and fair question to ask though too, since it's one of the areas where leadership / flying ability and their relationship to one another differs between the civilian and military flying communities.
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

No so much in the Army community. Somewhat, but it's not as important as Air Force or Navy aviation where the commissioned officers do all the flying.

In the Army (very generally) if you become a PIC qualified for day/night and NVGs you are respected. Once you're a Major it's pretty common to expect they have senior wings (1000 hours of military flying) and by LTC you have master wings (2000 hours).

In the 101st, the unit I flew the most with, most Captains were at least day/night PICs if not also NVG PICs. But that was the culture of an aviation-dominant unit. I had to interview for a Guard position here and the COL I spoke with was over-impressed with my flight hours and my NVG PIC designation.
 
Re: the pilot proficiency vice leadership question....

I'm not a fleet guy yet, so take what I say accordingly, but this advice was offered to me a while back by a senior IP (former Marine Hornet type, recently crossed into the dark side of the ANG tanker business) who I have a lot of respect for both in the air and on the ground:

"There are 3 things your squadronmatte's and leadership will look for in you as a JO and beyond (in no particular order of importance):

1) Your ability to fly the jet, your tactical proficiency, and whether you can be trusted in the air.

2) Your performance in your ground job(s)

3) Whether or not you are someone who likes to hang out, be with the guys during liberty/off-duty time, and generally be with the team. Ability to hold your liquour is strongly encouraged, but if you don't drink, they still want to see if you will at least hang out regularly.

If you can meet at least 2 of these requirements, you will succeed and more than likely promote accordingly. If not, your career will be limited"

Like I said, I don't have any operatonal experience yet, but I'd say this even holds true to some extent in flight school, and I agree with the fact that I would hold my peers to these standards. My current front office is a great example of this. Both CO and XO are both great aviators in my opinion and have my uptmost respect in the air. On the ground, they are great guys to hang out with, and are always eager to come have a drink with us, be it on det, a winging party, on the beach after we all CQ'd, etc. I'm not familiar firsthand with their leadership of the IP side of the ready room, but they have been outstanding mentors to us studs and I have no question in my mind that our success is their bottom line. Good examples of the criteria above IMHO. (/brownnosing session :) )
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

No so much in the Army community. Somewhat, but it's not as important as Air Force or Navy aviation where the commissioned officers do all the flying.

In the Army (very generally) if you become a PIC qualified for day/night and NVGs you are respected. Once you're a Major it's pretty common to expect they have senior wings (1000 hours of military flying) and by LTC you have master wings (2000 hours).

.

I'd run into an O-6 last week, aviator type with only a star on his wings, but his branch was Infantry....not aviation or medical service corps? Also was wearing an EIB above the wings.

Think he was late-trained as an aviator, possibly?
 
Re: Captian relived of her comand.

I'd run into an O-6 last week, aviator type with only a star on his wings, but his branch was Infantry....not aviation or medical service corps? Also was wearing an EIB above the wings.

Think he was late-trained as an aviator, possibly?

Dunno - I have an EIB above my wings though. An EIB is a higher class badge so it always goes above the wings. I was enlisted first so maybe the O-6 was too.
 
Back
Top