Re: the pilot proficiency vice leadership question....
I'm not a fleet guy yet, so take what I say accordingly, but this advice was offered to me a while back by a senior IP (former Marine Hornet type, recently crossed into the dark side of the ANG tanker business) who I have a lot of respect for both in the air and on the ground:
"There are 3 things your squadronmatte's and leadership will look for in you as a JO and beyond (in no particular order of importance):
1) Your ability to fly the jet, your tactical proficiency, and whether you can be trusted in the air.
2) Your performance in your ground job(s)
3) Whether or not you are someone who likes to hang out, be with the guys during liberty/off-duty time, and generally be with the team. Ability to hold your liquour is strongly encouraged, but if you don't drink, they still want to see if you will at least hang out regularly.
If you can meet at least 2 of these requirements, you will succeed and more than likely promote accordingly. If not, your career will be limited"
Like I said, I don't have any operatonal experience yet, but I'd say this even holds true to some extent in flight school, and I agree with the fact that I would hold my peers to these standards. My current front office is a great example of this. Both CO and XO are both great aviators in my opinion and have my uptmost respect in the air. On the ground, they are great guys to hang out with, and are always eager to come have a drink with us, be it on det, a winging party, on the beach after we all CQ'd, etc. I'm not familiar firsthand with their leadership of the IP side of the ready room, but they have been outstanding mentors to us studs and I have no question in my mind that our success is their bottom line. Good examples of the criteria above IMHO. (/brownnosing session

)