61.129 revision Oct 2009

Seriously, though, if you NEED a CFI along on the 300nm X-county, are you really prepared to be a commercial pilot?
OK, I get your point here, and I agree that the commercial long solo x/c, the one and only requirement for a private pilot to fly solo more than 250 miles away, should have remained solo, and I would require more than that.

But...since the FAA is going to allow that one to be with an instructor, I am encouraging all instructors to actually use the time to simulate emergencies, and other real life flight management problems, instead of sitting like a log and destroying any experience value from the flight. He cannot pretend that the flight is solo...that just won't work. The main value of solo is the mental and psychological process that occurs when the student pilot encounters flight management problems, and solves them on his own. Since he won't be alone, the instructor must 'make up stuff' to counter the lack of the experience of being solo.

That isn't hand-holding. That's what I'm trying to discourage.
 
But...since the FAA is going to allow that one to be with an instructor, I am encouraging all instructors to actually use the time to simulate emergencies, and other real life flight management problems, instead of sitting like a log and destroying any experience value from the flight. He cannot pretend that the flight is solo...that just won't work. The main value of solo is the mental and psychological process that occurs when the student pilot encounters flight management problems, and solves them on his own. Since he won't be alone, the instructor must 'make up stuff' to counter the lack of the experience of being solo.
There's a thin line here. The full CFI role is there for the two required dual cross countries, and the intent of the "performing the duties" is to make it as much a PIC experience as possible.

As John Lynch said in the orphaned FAQ:

==============================
And the instructor shall confine their activities to only giving training on performing the duties of pilot in command and putting more emphasis on acting like an SIC so the applicant gets the benefit and experience of performing the duties of a pilot in command in a crew concept setting. Since the flight’s purpose is for meeting the requirements of § 61.129(b)(4)(i), the instructor shall not be giving training on basic instruments, navigation, etc. etc. The aeronautical experience must be confined to “. . . performing the duties of pilot in command . . . on the areas of operation listed in § 61.127(b)(2) . . .” (italics in the original)

***

As I previously stated, the requirements of § 61.129(b)(4)(i) are for the purpose of “. . . performing the duties of pilot in command . . .” Keep in mind, if this training was for any of the other categories and classes of aircraft ratings, the aeronautical experience is required to be performed solo.
==============================

I agree that's not necessarily the role of baggage, and I think your concept of creating emergencies is a good one. But, at least as the author envisioned it, it is the job of the CFI to create a scenario in which the pilot is either PIC in charge of a crew or is on a simulated simulated as much as possible given the circumstances rather than it becoming just another dual flight.

I think we're all ultimately saying the same thing. The issue is where the emphasis should lie and how creative the CFI is when balancing those concepts. I think, as in other situations, you tend to gravitate toward "I'm the CFI so I'm boss" while I tend to gravitate toward "take me on this flight an bore me to death."
 
I think, as in other situations, you tend to gravitate toward "I'm the CFI so I'm boss" while I tend to gravitate toward "take me on this flight an bore me to death."
...ahh so,...now I understand a little better.

While the CFI is "the boss", as you put it, I didn't mean it to come across that way. Not only in this scenario, but in other discussions of training objectives that I have given opinions on.

To be specific, I have always followed the general structure of teaching in gradually increasing levels of difficulty; starting off in kindergarten mode: "take this hand and put it on this lever" kind of thing until that action has developed well enough to progress to "take this hand and put it on this lever and move it to slot B". And be prepared to repeat that action until the movement is as precise and accurate as is necessary to proceed to a third instruction.

Most initial flight instructors have the fundamental moves so crammed together that most students never get enough time in the basics before being pushed into learning new stuff before the really important basic moves have become sufficiently trained.

That's when the instructor is openly being the boss. The student expects it and it is the job of the instructor to be visibly in command.

But, as I say to all my students, somewhere during the cross-country training, "It is my job to talk myself out of a job with you." By the time the student is signed off for solo x/c, he/she has flown a dual x/c, or portion thereof, with me as a silent observer. I do the same on the checkride prep. The student will do a simulated checkride with me or another instructor giving no instruction, but only directing the PTS.

That's when I try not to appear to be the boss.

The student pilot is carrying his or herself as the sole responsible pilot on a solo x/c or when going up for a checkride.

This new reg allowing the CFI to substitute for the solo x/c requirement, along with the justifications, (not counting insurance) makes the CFI more responsible to act as a teacher in CRM and emergency procedures. (EP)

The instructor should continue to structure the flight so that the student is acting as PIC, and the instructor is creating EP's and/or acting as SIC, but also making mistakes as a junior SIC to keep the student-acting-as-PIC constantly on the ball and in the position of PIC.

The instructor should not appear to be the boss.

The instructor will have to be pro-active in creating flight management scenarios that keep the student pro-active in acting as PIC, otherwise if the instructor is passive, or visibly being in command, the flight will devolve into a dull dual flight that both parties will see as a waste.

I think the other 2 required dual flights have devolved into that mindset already. I see a lot of questioning the other required dual, as if it is 'hand-holding'.

Well, it would be if the instructor just 'rides along' on a typical usual x/c, but there is always some area of x/c that a pilot with only 40 or so hours of x/c can learn. Mostly, at that stage, when they have just finished IR, they need a brush-up, or even some initial, training on pilotage and dead reckoning. Or finding a grass strip. A 135 charter pilot should be able to navigate to a grass strip, don'ch think?

Anyway, there's lots to teach, and yes, it should be done in a manner that is receptive to the student; that's a basic FOI.
 
Mike's working on his CFI. The pressure is enormous :)

Much truth in that. Plenty of it self-imposed

My apolgies if I sounded overly strident here. It never was my intention to slam anyone's abilities. My point has more to do with the direction the thread has taken in terms of "Who's Boss" in the airplane.

When you're flying with a CFI, no matter what level pilot you are, there's a student/teacher relationship that can't be dismissed; it's there. The student is invariably going to be looking for direction from the instructor, and it's nearly impossible for the instructor to not want to provide input, or instruction. It's a phenomenon I was reminded of the day my instructor & I were heading to the practice area and I asked " OK, what do you want me to start with?" and he replied with "You're the instructor, you tell me what we're going to do"

So back to the topic of allowing a CFI on the long X-country for multi-commercial initial, the best lesson the CFI could teach on that particular flight might be "What do we do next? You tell me- you're the PIC"
 
Back
Top