61.129 revision Oct 2009

green hornet

New Member
With the current revision of 61.129 (4) listed in regulations change Vol. 74 No. 201 Oct 2009 that adds an authorized instructor may be on board, can the 300 nm cross country then be combined with the dual 2 hour 100nm dvfr and nvfr cross countries in 61.129 (3) (iii) and (iv) ?
 
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the long X-country still must be done solo-

What would be the point of requiring a 2 hour, 100nm day-vfr dual instruction flight, AND allowing the 300nm flight to be dual?

I'm also pretty sure a lot of people are going to read the change as allowing exactly that.

Seriously, though, if you NEED a CFI along on the 300nm X-county, are you really prepared to be a commercial pilot?
 
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the long X-country still must be done solo-


Nope, they changed it with that last NPRM. Basically, prior to the change, you could do the supervised solo PIC thing in a multi, but not in anything else. The way it reads now, allows for supervised solo in either a multi or a single. After looking at it, I'm not sure if you could log the 300 nm "solo" flight as the dual day and night cross countries. They did drop the VFR portion from the 100 mile/2 hour flights. Might be worth asking FAA legal on this question.
 
Just trying to kill two birds with one stone and save some dough, it was not a question of needing a cfi on the 300nm, but the 2 hour 100nm trips are required to be dual. Why not knock em both out at one time since the change allows a cfi to be on board the 300nm for less cost. I know there is alot of guys out there training right now that can relate to that concept.
 
Thanks for your input guys it is much appreciated. As in any other government run program confusion and ability to split hairs is the norm.
 
Just trying to kill two birds with one stone and save some dough, it was not a question of needing a cfi on the 300nm, but the 2 hour 100nm trips are required to be dual. Why not knock em both out at one time since the change allows a cfi to be on board the 300nm for less cost. I know there is alot of guys out there training right now that can relate to that concept.

The difference is on the 300 nm trip, the student is supposed to be performing the duties of PIC, and thus probably shouldn't be logging dual. If the instructor has to do something or teach, the student probably didn't do his/her duty as a PIC. The way I understand it, is the instructor is there to satisfy insurance companies, not the FAA.

You can always ask FAA legal, in the form of a letter, but I'm not sure that you'd get the answer in a time frame you want it in.
 
Had to have an instructor with me on my long XC in the twin 'cos the insurance co wouldn't let anyone solo in it that didn't have 250ME.

Bp244
 
Just trying to kill two birds with one stone and save some dough, it was not a question of needing a cfi on the 300nm, but the 2 hour 100nm trips are required to be dual. Why not knock em both out at one time since the change allows a cfi to be on board the 300nm for less cost.
No, you can ask, but you will find that you will not be able to do that.

The two dual flights are instructional flights. The CFI is there to act as an instructor - to create scenarios, toss in "emergencies", invent a diversion - those things that instructors do when they instruct.

The "solo replacement" is different. It was originally created for the multi - where insurers would simply not permit solo flight - and expanded in the recent change to other aircraft. Primarily a matter of recognizing that insurance issues can arise with some high performance technically advanced singles as well (not everyone does these in a Cutlass or Arrow). The ride-along CFI in this case is there as baggage and to satisfy insurance requirements, not to act as a flight instructor.

Your initla post mentions the volume of the Federal Register that has the Final Rule for the change. If you have it, go look for the explanatory material in the Final Rule.
 
The ride-along CFI in this case is there as baggage and to satisfy insurance requirements, not to act as a flight instructor.
This is a sticky point for me. I agree that the the 2 duals are different; they are specifically instructional flights where the CFI should be instructing specific additional commercial-level x/c training, whereas the x/c that used to be required solo can now have an instructor who requires the student to act as PIC.
This does not mean he is to sit as a bump on a log, or dead weight, or baggage. He is a required crewmember. The student is logging dual.

The instructor is an instructor, not a passenger. The regulations require either solo or with an instructor. See the definition of flight instructor.

Nowhere in the regs does it say the instructor should be passive.

It's up to the instructor as to what he does.

...and this is not specific to your post, Mike. I see it all over the board, ever since the ME solo change, this rumor has been spreading around.
 
This is a sticky point for me. I agree that the the 2 duals are different; they are specifically instructional flights where the CFI should be instructing specific additional commercial-level x/c training, whereas the x/c that used to be required solo can now have an instructor who requires the student to act as PIC.
This does not mean he is to sit as a bump on a log, or dead weight, or baggage. He is a required crewmember. The student is logging dual.
I'm not sure about the logging dual part, but yes, the CFI isn't really baggage (although that's certainly one option).

But the "student" is to take the role as (pretend) PIC on the flight with the CFI's role is as a supportive crewmember – an "SIC" if you will, so that the "PIC" can practice CRM. The FAA's explanatory information in Final Rule points to three rationales: insurance, applicant's being more comfortable practicing emergencies, and the opportunities to practice CRM.
 
The FAA's explanatory information in Final Rule points to three rationales: insurance, applicant's being more comfortable practicing emergencies, and the opportunities to practice CRM.

Except for insurance, I can see that rationale being applied to the PPL only. A commercial pilot shouldn't need hand-holding to fly cross country or practice skills.
 
Except for insurance, I can see that rationale being applied to the PPL only. A commercial pilot shouldn't need hand-holding to fly cross country or practice skills.
I think the CRM rationale applies also. If indeed the commercial is a stepping stone to a job, the addition of a co-pilot is not a particularly bad idea.

But, between you and me (don't tell anybody else), I agree that the whole thing was insurance driven and the proper role of the CFI is to simply ride along and allow the pilot to do his "solo."
 
I'm not sure about the logging dual part
So how is it supposed to be logged? It has to be solo or with an instructor. It can't be logged solo. If it is logged PIC only, without including the solo part, where is the evidence of satisfying the regulation?

Yes, I do realize it is insurance driven, but the instructor's name is used as evidence, and therefore carries the same liability as any of the other dual flights, as far as the regulations go.

And, like any other dual flight across the country, what the instructor does is up to that instructor and student, within the parameters of the regulations and subsequent referenced materiel. As it should be. All I'm saying is that the flight should still be a learning experience, which is what the Final Rule explanatory information points to in the basic terms of CRM and emergency procedures.
 
If the long X-Country is the last requirement that needs to be met before scheduling the checkride, the applicant is about to become a commercial pilot who still needs hand-holding
 
You should maybe lay off the viagra Mike H, it seems to be clouding your ability to answer a valid question without slamming someone else's abilities. You got hand holding on the brain. Thanks everyone else for your genuine input to my question, I do appreciate it.
 
You should maybe lay off the viagra Mike H, it seems to be clouding your ability to answer a valid question without slamming someone else's abilities. You got hand holding on the brain. Thanks everyone else for your genuine input to my question, I do appreciate it.
Mike's working on his CFI. The pressure is enormous :)
 
Back
Top