Airwork rant.

Re: Airwork ran.t

True, but you also have to remember that a lot of VFR guys don't know the first thing about what the waypoints are for an instrument approach. It helps if they do, but it's not really required knowledge. The whole reason I broke myself out of the habit of calling inbound over approach fixes and just listed mileage.
Forgot to mention. This will not be the last time you encounter dumb pilots in your career. They are EVERYWHERE! Almost had a head-on collision in Kansas City at night because the dumb Cessna pilot blended in the with city lights and ATC thought he was a bird. I had my landing light on, and just saw this silhouette bank hard to my left. I queried ATC and he said he thought it was a bird or something.

So, be vigilant and watch out cause like I said, it won't be the last dumb pilot.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

This is the main reason for all the confusion IMHO. Why would you tell a VFR pilot, that you are holding on the 120R? Tell him you are maneuvering at X thousand feet between point X and X. When I was a freshly minted PPL, and folks would say they are holding over the X vor on the 120 radial, I had no idea what they were talking about. When they said they were procedure turn inbound, I thought to my self, "were do I start looking?"

List distances, and cardinal directions, and you will have less problems.


Edit: Hood job avoiding the other guy. And as an instructor, the instructor in the other airplane should have known better. Ignorance is no excuse.

That's one thing I have always made sure to do because as a student pilot, I didn't know the differences in approach were or what an outer-marker was. If I want people to realize they aren't the only ones flying, I have to act the same.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

From 3,000 AGL to the surface, anything is fair game. I'd imagine the surface wasn't at sea level, so 3,000 MSL would be a good altitude. Why do people always forget about that?
Oh, I know it very well. LEGALLY, yes it's fine.

Practically?

Not so much.

Like I said, with the IFR MEAs in the area, plus approach vectoring people for approaches at 3000... 3500 and up were mo' betta. As a CFI based at a particular airport, that is the kind of stuff you HAVE to know and SHOULD be passing on to your students.
 
How's a guy supposed to do chandelles and maintain the same altitude? :confused: Either way you're likely to be at both an IFR and VFR cruising altitude at some point in the maneuver.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Oh, I know it very well. LEGALLY, yes it's fine.

Practically?

Not so much.

Like I said, with the IFR MEAs in the area, plus approach vectoring people for approaches at 3000... 3500 and up were mo' betta. As a CFI based at a particular airport, that is the kind of stuff you HAVE to know and SHOULD be passing on to your students.

Yes, but you should be telling them why that is, not just "because it's so". Nothing bugs me more than people who tell students things, and the students think that what they were told, is the law.

There is a difference between safe & legal. Shouldn't it be a goal to teach both, not just one or the other?
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Forgot to mention. This will not be the last time you encounter dumb pilots in your career. They are EVERYWHERE! Almost had a head-on collision in Kansas City at night because the dumb Cessna pilot blended in the with city lights and ATC thought he was a bird. I had my landing light on, and just saw this silhouette bank hard to my left. I queried ATC and he said he thought it was a bird or something.

So, be vigilant and watch out cause like I said, it won't be the last dumb pilot.

Was the Cessna pilot dumb because he blended in with the lights or because he took the appropriate action by turning away from your aircraft?
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Yes, but you should be telling them why that is, not just "because it's so". Nothing bugs me more than people who tell students things, and the students think that what they were told, is the law.

There is a difference between safe & legal. Shouldn't it be a goal to teach both, not just one or the other?
Where did I imply that I didn't tell them why?
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Where did I imply that I didn't tell them why?

Didn't say you did. Just wanted to make sure you weren't. I got fed the "we do it this way" line too many times by a certain flight school in Daytona Beach, with no reasoning behind it.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

No he was dumb for not operating his transponder inside a Mode C veil.
Good Lord, you have no idea. Really. Come hang out in my FBO for a few weeks, you'll hear enough dumb pilot tales to keep you on the ground for a solid year.
 
There is a local college around here that does lazy eights in the final approach course of a very popular approach (that they even use) at the approach altitude. Also had a Seminal fly the exact opposite direction of the procedure turn at the approach altitude while i was flying the procedure.

Safety? Who needs that?
People seem to have a short memory about stuff like midairs over VORs....
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Am I making it up that you can't do maneuvers on an airway?

I did a half hearted look through the blue book.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Didn't say you did. Just wanted to make sure you weren't. I got fed the "we do it this way" line too many times by a certain flight school in Daytona Beach, with no reasoning behind it.
Rajah. I shouldn't say I told them... I had them work it out. At least the commercial students.

"We'll go up to 3000 today."

"Really? You sure about that?"

"Uh yeah, why?"

"What altitude did you get all your approach vectors at when you were doing instrument last semester?"

"Uh.... 3000...."

"Where do they vector people/where are the DME arcs?"

"...in...the practice areas?" (actually, this is a stretch...most of them couldn't correllate the approaches they'd done with the practice area boundaries on the sectional...assuming they actually had a sectional)

"Yup...so maybe we should go to oh say...3500."

"Yeah...I guess we should".
 
I fell on the other side of this rant a couple days ago. We were doing holding procedures 15 DME from a VOR. I was monitoring the local approach frequency. While the student was making a turn, I spotted another plane converging but level about 400' below us according to our TIS.

The guy apparently didn't see us until much closer because all of a sudden he calls up ATC and angrily describes a plane that "almost flew into him." Since I was listening anyway, I told ATC that we were the target in question and got a discrete code for our orbits.

Not like we were over a VOR at an IFR altitude, or anywhere near an approach course. 400' is plenty separation for VFR good visibility in my book. ATC didn't say anything but I thought from their tone they thought this guy was a little "excitable."
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Good Lord, you have no idea. Really. Come hang out in my FBO for a few weeks, you'll hear enough dumb pilot tales to keep you on the ground for a solid year.

No, I don't. I haven't been up a lot and now that I fly in DC and deal with the SFRA everyone I've met seems to be paranoid about busting something. :( wait a second...the only pilot people I've met in person were the CFI's I flew with....nope, guess I'm the only paraonid one.

Thank goodness for JC. I get my FBO fix online. :D
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

No, I don't. I haven't been up a lot and now that I fly in DC and deal with the SFRA everyone I've met seems to be paranoid about busting something. :( wait a second...the only pilot people I've met in person were the CFI's I flew with....nope, guess I'm the only paraonid one.

Thank goodness for JC. I get my FBO fix online. :D
I'm building up a good store of tales to pass on once I've moved up in the world and don't need to worry about incriminating anyone.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

In controlled airspace, an aircraft equipped with an operable transponder must have the transponder "on":

§ 91.215 ATC transponder and altitude reporting equipment and use.
(c) Transponder-on operation. While in the airspace as specified in paragraph (b) of this section or in all controlled airspace, each person operating an aircraft equipped with an operable ATC transponder maintained in accordance with §91.413 of this part shall operate the transponder, including Mode C equipment if installed, and shall reply on the appropriate code or as assigned by ATC.


Actually, it is illegal to fly with your xponder turned off.


Sorry my wording wasn't the best, maybe i should have said mode c but regardless this isn't about the regs, tell all that to the guys that fly around with their transponders off or forget them on SBY and don't talk to ATC around busy airspace. It happens all the time back home. I get 'type\alt unknown' all the time which doesn't mean the xponder is off of course, but I've also gotten plenty of 'im showing a primary target type\alt unknown'. Gets very frustrating.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Actually, it is illegal to fly with your xponder turned off.

not necessarily

as far as people doing manuvers near VOR's or segments of instrument approaches, as long as the conditions are VFR, they have just as much right to be there as anyone else. If you don't want to have to worry about that, take the time & trouble to contact ATC and get vectors (and traffic seperation) for your practice approaches. If you're going to practice instrument procedures VFR, you have to expect to deal with other VFR traffic. You might as well complain about other people practicing the very same instrument approaches under VFR rules at the same time you are.
 
Back
Top