Airwork rant.

DPApilot

GUYSH! GUYSH! GUYSH!
Sorry, just venting.

But if you're VFR and going up to do things like chandelles, please don't do them at an ifr altitude over a VOR. Especially if said VOR is part of an (the only)approach to an airport. I really don't like having to climb at my best rate when I'm doing a procedure turn outbound because you are unfamilar or just dont care about the airspace you fly in. Remember, there are other pilots out there. It was nice seeing you 40 seconds later 200 feet below me, continuing your chandelle or poorly flown lazy 8. Getting a collision aviodance alert or whatever from ATC was just fun!

End rant. Sorry again.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Truth.

Were they making any sort of "advisory" position reports? Should try to track down the plane through flightaware, find out who the instructor was, and then bust his knees.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Sort of unrelated, but a few days ago I was out over the PDZ VOR area and there was a dude doing a hold over the station. Problem? His transponder wasn't working.

A ton of people had to get vectored around him. :(
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Truth.

Were they making any sort of "advisory" position reports? Should try to track down the plane through flightaware, find out who the instructor was, and then bust his knees.
Nope, which is probably why ATC freaked seeing him just start to climb into me while changing directions...
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Good, i needed a rant thread...One more thing for the weekend warriors. Please if you don't like talking to ATC at LEAST turn on your xponders! I routinely get 'traffic 12 to 1oclock 1 mile type\alt unknown'. Just because the regs say you can fly around with out a xponder on or fly without talking to ATC in a busy area, doesn't mean you should! hell i could go wander in the middle of a 4 lane road but just because i can doesn't mean I will!
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Just because the regs say you can fly around with out a xponder on or fly without talking to ATC in a busy area, doesn't mean you should!

In controlled airspace, an aircraft equipped with an operable transponder must have the transponder "on":

§ 91.215 ATC transponder and altitude reporting equipment and use.
(c) Transponder-on operation. While in the airspace as specified in paragraph (b) of this section or in all controlled airspace, each person operating an aircraft equipped with an operable ATC transponder maintained in accordance with §91.413 of this part shall operate the transponder, including Mode C equipment if installed, and shall reply on the appropriate code or as assigned by ATC.
 
There is a local college around here that does lazy eights in the final approach course of a very popular approach (that they even use) at the approach altitude. Also had a Seminal fly the exact opposite direction of the procedure turn at the approach altitude while i was flying the procedure.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Truth.

Were they making any sort of "advisory" position reports? Should try to track down the plane through flightaware, find out who the instructor was, and then bust his knees.

Why? Was what he was doing illegal? Sure, it was stupid, but illegal, I doubt it.

Its called See AND Avoid for a reason. You saw him, avoid him, which sounds like is what happened.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Why? Was what he was doing illegal? Sure, it was stupid, but illegal, I doubt it.

Its called See AND Avoid for a reason. You saw him, avoid him, which sounds like is what happened.
I had to avoid before seeing. I only saw him after said avoidance and if it were not for ATC, he would have probably flown into me.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

At my old school, a favorite altitude for students to maneuver at in the practice area was 3000. Anyone who flew with me got the speech about a) that's an IFR altitude, let's at least start our maneuvers at a normal VFR altitude and b) that's the altitude approach vectors people at on their way to the final approach courses. Right through the practice areas...
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

At my old school, a favorite altitude for students to maneuver at in the practice area was 3000. Anyone who flew with me got the speech about a) that's an IFR altitude, let's at least start our maneuvers at a normal VFR altitude and b) that's the altitude approach vectors people at on their way to the final approach courses. Right through the practice areas...

From 3,000 AGL to the surface, anything is fair game. I'd imagine the surface wasn't at sea level, so 3,000 MSL would be a good altitude. Why do people always forget about that?
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

User fees!!!!
brick.jpg

"LOUUUUUUD NOISES!"
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

From 3,000 AGL to the surface, anything is fair game. I'd imagine the surface wasn't at sea level, so 3,000 MSL would be a good altitude. Why do people always forget about that?
For VFR that is. For IFR, according to 91.179

(1) When operating below 18,000 feet MSL and --
(i) On a magnetic course of zero degrees through 179 degrees, any odd thousand foot MSL altitude (such as 3,000, 5,000, or 7,000); or
(ii) On a magnetic course of 180 degrees through 359 degrees, any even thousand foot MSL altitude (such as 2,000, 4,000, or 6,000).
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Good, i needed a rant thread...One more thing for the weekend warriors. Please if you don't like talking to ATC at LEAST turn on your xponders! I routinely get 'traffic 12 to 1oclock 1 mile type\alt unknown'. Just because the regs say you can fly around with out a xponder on or fly without talking to ATC in a busy area, doesn't mean you should! hell i could go wander in the middle of a 4 lane road but just because i can doesn't mean I will!

Actually, it is illegal to fly with your xponder turned off.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Wasn't this guy VFR?
Yeah, but the argument is, just because you can, doesn't mean you should. Anyway, since he wasn't cruising, you could say that doesn't even apply. It's just pretty stupid to do a maneuver like that in said location.
3,000 AGL, even then, it's the responsibility of both pilots to see and avoid. Sure, you were on a VOR approach and yeah maybe it was dumb for a VFR guy to be out there practicing his maneuvers. But ultimately, it's both your responsibility. I always preach about getting VFR flight following where ever I go, whether on a long XC or just up practicing maneuvers just so people know I'm there. But this is really a non-issue. You lived to fly another day and most people learn from their mistakes. Most.
Yes but again, it is hard to see and avoid someone coming up from under you. If I hadn't gotten the alert, he would have flown into me. I didnt see him until after i climed 1400 ft and he was about 2-300 feet below me.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

From 3,000 AGL to the surface, anything is fair game. I'd imagine the surface wasn't at sea level, so 3,000 MSL would be a good altitude. Why do people always forget about that?

3,000 AGL, even then, it's the responsibility of both pilots to see and avoid. Sure, you were on a VOR approach and yeah maybe it was dumb for a VFR guy to be out there practicing his maneuvers. But ultimately, it's both your responsibility. I always preach about getting VFR flight following where ever I go, whether on a long XC or just up practicing maneuvers just so people know I'm there. But this is really a non-issue. You lived to fly another day and most people learn from their mistakes. Most.

brick.jpg

"LOUUUUUUD NOISES!"

:clap:
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

Yeah, but the argument is, just because you can, doesn't mean you should. Anyway, since he wasn't cruising, you could say that doesn't even apply. It's just pretty stupid to do a maneuver like that in said location.

Yes but again, it is hard to see and avoid someone coming up from under you. If I hadn't gotten the alert, he would have flown into me. I didnt see him until after i climed 1400 ft and he was about 2-300 feet below me.
True, but you also have to remember that a lot of VFR guys don't know the first thing about what the waypoints are for an instrument approach. It helps if they do, but it's not really required knowledge. The whole reason I broke myself out of the habit of calling inbound over approach fixes and just listed mileage.
 
Re: Airwork ran.t

The whole reason I broke myself out of the habit of calling inbound over approach fixes and just listed mileage.


This is the main reason for all the confusion IMHO. Why would you tell a VFR pilot, that you are holding on the 120R? Tell him you are maneuvering at X thousand feet between point X and X. When I was a freshly minted PPL, and folks would say they are holding over the X vor on the 120 radial, I had no idea what they were talking about. When they said they were procedure turn inbound, I thought to my self, "were do I start looking?"

List distances, and cardinal directions, and you will have less problems.


Edit: Hood job avoiding the other guy. And as an instructor, the instructor in the other airplane should have known better. Ignorance is no excuse.
 
Back
Top