I saw the man in the terminal in SFO when he was on his way home after the Superbowl. I was standing at the gate counter when he got off the plane. I was a little surprised that he walked about 5 feet away from me but didn't even glance my way, even though I was in uniform and a fellow USAir pilot. I figured it was probably because he was tired and just focused on getting home. I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt that it had nothing to do with the fact I am with the America West half of the company.
As an fellow airline pilot I have respect for him even if he didn't land a crippled plane in the river. As a fellow USAir employee, regardless of which side of the Mississippi he's from, I would be pleasant and courteous to him. His distinguished former military record is enviable and I think service to one's country as about the most honorable thing a person can do. I also think, as a professional pilot he has brought a little dignity to this industry that has been riddled with stories of professional failures such as showing up at the airport intoxicated, improper identification of a stall and subsequent improper recovery which led to the loss of the aircraft and the death of all on board, just to name a few. Aviation desperately needed the "feel good" story he delivered. Also, he has used his "star power" to lobby for some much needed improvements with politicians who like to be seen with a man of his caliber. For these reasons, I have the utmost respect for him as a professional.
But...
Then he showed up in court in Phoenix last Spring and basically said the entire America West pilot group didn't have any integrity. He said the federally arbitrated seniority plan for integrating the pilots also lacked integrity. Either he tried, or allowed the newly created union that represented East and ONLY East USAir pilots, to use his star power to try to convince a jury that the "rookies" at America West had no right to "steal" the jobs of the highly experienced USAir pilots, regardless of what a federal Arbiter said. As a person, I think the man is a piece of crap.
Let's recap. As a professional, I have the utmost respect for the man. As a person, I wouldn't urinate on him if he was on fire.
Let the flaming begin.