would and could this work

ahsmatt7

Well-Known Member
after seeing a post in the Lav about the barfer, i continued to read other stories on the website named...www.flightsfromhell.com. I must say that i have been xtremely lucky to only sit by one individual of high weight. The man was the nicest guy around. We talked about sports me wanting to be a pilot and how he had narcolepsy...hope that is spelled right. Well we talked until he fell asleep lol. Anyways, my point being, those who are morbidly obese, should they be allowed to fly? I mean not everyone is fit to fly, lets face it.

My qeustion is this. Would it be too much of a hassle to make everyone get a pre flight check up by their Dr. to make sure they are " fit to fly?"

Hell with all the paperwork we have to show to get through boarding, whats one more peice of paper saying we are A OK?

Would it work or just be discrimination?
 
What would the requirements be? What doctors would be accepted to perform these test? And do you want to take a physical prior to boarding any aircraft? (Not like we don't right now but EVERY FLIGHT?)
 
If you're talking about the pax, I would have to think that the ACLU would be all over that before it ever went into effect. It's a good point, though. You could come up with a probability function that determines someone's risk of having a medical condition inflight, and perhaps limit them to trips of less than 2-hours.
 
What would the requirements be? What doctors would be accepted to perform these test? And do you want to take a physical prior to boarding any aircraft? (Not like we don't right now but EVERY FLIGHT?)
it wouldnt be a rigorous exam. Just to see if there are not any blaring health issues along with the fact that they may just be too big..
 
In each carrier's Contract of Carriage there already are requirements for flying. Certain communicable diseases, within some timeframe of childbirth (I forget what exactly it is...) babies have to be at least 7 days old.... etc.

I really can't see anything much stricter being allowed....
 
. . . those who are morbidly obese, should they be allowed to fly? I mean not everyone is fit to fly, lets face it.

WTF?

What about people that are too thin to fly?

People that are too tall/short to fly?

People that aren't "smart" enough to fly?

People that can't hear/see well enough to fly?

It might work better if you first worked on your personal dislike of people that are "morbidly obese".
 
If you're talking about the pax, I would have to think that the ACLU would be all over that before it ever went into effect. It's a good point, though. You could come up with a probability function that determines someone's risk of having a medical condition inflight, and perhaps limit them to trips of less than 2-hours.
I was thinking the same thing about the ACLU. Its like this, not everyone is made for a ferrari. Likewise some people are way too big to fly end of story. When you buy the ferrari, your buying the luxury of havign a fast car and so on. That doesnt mean that you can fit into it. When you buy a plane ticket, you buy the luxury of getting to Point B quickly and safely, that doesnt mean you can fit into the seats.

People are way to dense these days to realize flying may not be for them. If you get motion sickness really easily, your an idiot to think you can fly. If you have problems getting into a regular car....what makes you think you can fly.
 
WTF?

What about people that are too thin to fly?

People that are too tall/short to fly?

People that aren't "smart" enough to fly?

People that can't hear/see well enough to fly?

It might work better if you first worked on your personal dislike of people that are "morbidly obese".
actualyl if you read the post, I had quite a pleasent experiecne with a big person. I dont mind them at all. Im really thin with a lazy eye, its not like im perfect by any means. Dotn put words in my mouth and dont act like your so happy with every person in the world..please.

Me and YOU both know that not all people are fit to fly. Your reasoning would imply that anyone can fly whether they are perfectly fine or if they are on their deathbed as long as they have the money. NOT TRUE
 
I was really hoping someone would come up with a new way for our betters to hold our hands and tell us what our own level of risk ought to be. I was sort of tired of making my own decision in life and being treated like an adult. As far as I know I'm already free to get a doctors checkup before a flight if I want one.

It would be a huge inconvenience for people traveling on short notice or if they don't happen to be in a city where they know a doctor.
 
I was thinking the same thing about the ACLU. Its like this, not everyone is made for a ferrari. Likewise some people are way too big to fly end of story. When you buy the ferrari, your buying the luxury of havign a fast car and so on. That doesnt mean that you can fit into it. When you buy a plane ticket, you buy the luxury of getting to Point B quickly and safely, that doesnt mean you can fit into the seats.

People are way to dense these days to realize flying may not be for them. If you get motion sickness really easily, your an idiot to think you can fly. If you have problems getting into a regular car....what makes you think you can fly.

True, but this is America, and we tend not to tell people what they can and can't do. Hell, we let centurions drive our streets without as much as a vision test!
 
I was really hoping someone would come up with a new way for our betters to hold our hands and tell us what our own level of risk ought to be. I was sort of tired of making my own decision in life and being treated like an adult. As far as I know I'm already free to get a doctors checkup before a flight if I want one.

It would be a huge inconvenience for people traveling on short notice or if they don't happen to be in a city where they know a doctor.
yeah but some people dont have the commen sense to analyze the reality of situations.

It wont have to be before every flight lol. I mean have it be like a medical. Every six months is good enough. Any doctor can do them. It would be like a yearly check up of sorts, something you would get for school or to play school sports. The FAA could mandate the price to be like 20 bucks.
 
yeah but some people dont have the commen sense to analyze the reality of situations.

It wont have to be before every flight lol. I mean have it be like a medical. Every six months is good enough. Any doctor can do them. It would be like a yearly check up of sorts, something you would get for school or to play school sports. The FAA could mandate the price to be like 20 bucks.
Why should I be treated like a child because a few people in our society don't make resposible choices?

I can picture the discussion at the counter now...
"oh i'm sorry sir your medical is expired so we can't let you board this flight"

"but my father is dieing this is my last chance to see him!"

"too bad but your government really knows what's best for you"
 
Why should I be treated like a child because a few people in our society don't make resposible choices?

I can picture the discussion at the counter now...
"oh i'm sorry sir your medical is expired so we can't let you board this flight"

"but my father is dieing this is my last chance to see him!"

"too bad but your government really knows what's best for you"

That would suck big time. Point made and a good one as well. If the govt. gave you a time period like six months. ppl should be on top of that if there someone in their family is sick.

Prepare for the future, Plan for the worst....it always works.

and to answer your question...One bad apple spolis the bunch.
 
From the Flight From Hell Website.

I usually cut people some slack when they don't strictly adhere to the "Remain in your seats while the fasten seatbelt light is illuminated." When you have to go...right? However, a flight from Nashville to Miami completely changed my mind. I was seated in an aisle seat; a mid-30's gentleman (I'll refer to him as "Window") was seated at the window. The middle seat was vacant. Window kept to himself throughout the flight, which is always appreciated. The only problem was his choice of reading material. Playboy? On a plane? At 8 a.m.? I ignored both Window and his "girlie mag" during the flight.
As we began our descent into Miami, and after the seat belt light had turned on, Window turns to me and asks if I think he has time to go use the restroom before we land. I said no since we were within 20 or so minutes before landing. End of story? Hardly. Suddenly, I hear a zipper and some rustling of a plastic bag. Yep, Window was peeing in the plastic bag his Playboy came in. I didn't look, I promise. I was too horrified at the thought that this guy was urinating in his seat while I sat next to him. When he finished, he tied the top of the bag and held it until we landed. He deplaned like holding a bag of pee was the most natural thing to do. I told the flight attendants what had happened. Strangely, I don't think they were that surprised.​

:rotfl:​
 
True, but this is America, and we tend not to tell people what they can and can't do. Hell, we let centurions drive our streets without as much as a vision test!

We need to start...

Personally, I haven't seen any of these guys driving on our streets.
centurions-pause.jpg


Were they driving one of these:
roman-chariot1.jpg
 
matt it seems like this is flamebait! :dunno:. i will agree that a obese person that takes up 2 seats should pay for 2 seats. However, there would be so many lawsuits about discrimnation. oh yeah matt the PENS suck!:insane:
 
Back
Top