Why I don't trust helicopters

Most helicopter accidents begin with the phrase "hey watch this." Helicopters are fun and agile to fly so people push them more and it will bite them in the behind sometime. Case in point the NTSB report about the OKC Eagle Med crash is about to be released and should be a good lesson for us all that turn rotors.
Shane
 
:eek:

:eek: 20ftlbs is high torque. IIRC the diesel heads I used to install on a Cummins diesel were 180ftlbs. It's been a while and I could be wrong, but I do remember being tired after torquing down a head.
Are you referring to it being in a class that is called high torque? Or are you saying you think it is high torque?
Considering lug nuts on cars get torqued to way more I don't consider it high at all. Plus there were many other components that were torqued much higher.

edit:Now that I think about it, it was inch/lbs not foot lbs. Torque the entire ring to 20, then 30 and then like 32
 
Why I don't trust helicopters: Jesus Bolts. Nothing I fly will ever have a bolt called the Jesus Bolt.

You do know that there are hundreds of "single point of failure" in a modern airliner? In other words, if that bolt, rod, electrical connection, hydraulic line, gives out, everybody aboard is dead.

A helicopter has quite a few more, but don't think you're "safe" because you've got two engines.

J nuts are seriously overbuilt for the loads they are under, and most of the failures are due to improper instalation by MX.


That crash has happened the exact same way by fixed wing aircraft hundreds of times.
 
even PA28's have a Jesus nut, it is the single bolt/nut that mounts the stabilator to the control linkage. if you lose that you are just about boned.
 
In the Iraqi AF, it's a mohammad nut.

Ha!

Seriously though guys, MikeD, ScottyBoy and I really do understand why you guys are afraid of helicopters... and we will still try to respect you even though you all drink appletinis.
 
I'm pretty sure this wasn't pilot error...
[YT]UGSMe58GTZk[/YT]

I suppose the closest situation that compares would be a total hydraulic failure in a FBW fixed wing aircraft.
 
You do know that there are hundreds of "single point of failure" in a modern airliner? In other words, if that bolt, rod, electrical connection, hydraulic line, gives out, everybody aboard is dead.

When I was in the AF, and they showed me an F-4 that blew up because of the failure of a single resistor.

Resistor burned out, causing the fuel pump not to shut off, causing it to overheat and explode, killing the crew.

The loss of an entire aircraft and crew all due to a 2 cent part.
 
I suppose the closest situation that compares would be a total hydraulic failure in a FBW fixed wing aircraft.

Or a mechanics screwdriver stuck in a flight control

Or a broken flap actuator

Or a fuel leak into the APU compartment

Or a fatigue crack in the fuselage

Or a design flaw in the windows

Or dirty hydraulic fluid

Or a jackscrew that hasn't been greased in a decade

Any of those ring a bell?
 
If helicopters are just as reliable as fixed wing, why do they require more maintenance? Why is their operating cost so much higher than an equal fixed-wing? Isn't it because they are more complex? Not more than a 757 but certainly a Robinson R-22 is more complex than a C152 right?
 
If helicopters are just as reliable as fixed wing, why do they require more maintenance? Why is their operating cost so much higher than an equal fixed-wing? Isn't it because they are more complex? Not more than a 757 but certainly a Robinson R-22 is more complex than a C152 right?

Because nearly everything is life limited on a helo, hence the higher MX and operating costs.

I defer to USMCmech for the exact details.
 
If helicopters are just as reliable as fixed wing, why do they require more maintenance?

They are not.

Nobody disputes the fact that helos have more complex systems, creating more places for things to go wrong. When things do go wrong in a helo, they usually go very wrong very fast.

However to say that fixed wing airplanes are immune to such problems is incorrect.

Furthermore, the helo's ability to "glide" to a landing spot smaller than a basketball court can be an advantage in rough or urban terrain. A fixed wing airplane can't do that if your engine quits.


Regardless, the weak point in both types of aircraft is the loose nut in the pilot seat. Always has been, always will be.
 
Why I trust helicopters

Fixed the title for ya....

ED: having youtube issues. HERE is the link.

San Antonio PD Schweizer 330/333 had an engine failure at low altitude over the city. BOTH officer walked away from this. Had this been a fixed-wing, how much room would it have taken from touchdown to reaching a complete stop?
 
I admit my understanding of helicopters is very limited. I am curious about the whole aspect of helicopter aviation and how they manage such complexity. You basically confirmed what I thought though, many moving parts = wear, which in turn means more maintenance. Although I do think that means more risk, it can be managed properly.

Honestly helicopters fascinate me. I think more fixed-wing guys would fly them if not for the relatively high cost of training and operation. I doubt I'll get my license to fly one any time soon because of that but if I hit the lotto, bet on it.

I think at the very least I'm going to take a short flight in one, I've never even been up in one.
 
Back
Top