Why bigger and more airplanes at Regionals?

Sure I understand the friction, but that seems to be a spat between Comair and DAL. Comair got support from mainline during their strike so you wanted some courtesy when you had to furlough. Fine, but what happened there can hardly be projected at other carriers across the country. I don't think I follow your argument if you're trying to say that flow through/back agreements and furlough protection for mainline will somehow increase the QOL and or pay at regionals. I think those things are nice to have, but it seems that they're fading out of fashion. You say you want to see RJ flying at mainline. I'd like to see that too. In reality, the regionals as they exist today would not exist if their pilots were compensated at the same level as mainline narrowbody crews. Does that make it wrong to take a job flying an RJ with a regional wrong? In my opinion, no, especially now that we're seeing mainline carriers (USAirways) flying "RJs" at pseudo-regional rates.
 
Alchemy said:
This forum is slowly becoming little more than an RJ bashing EXTRAVAGANZA. YAY, whoopee. Can't tune into jetcareers without another post by a mainline pilot blaming RJ's for the demise of the profession.

I really can't agree with the statement. It's almost like saying 757's are the cause of industry strife. However, it's the utilization, not the aircraft type.

Using a 767-300ER on PHX-TUS is as crazy, in a competitive market, of using a CRJ on DFW-JFK.

(767-300ER - you're not going to be able to price it competitively with the driving option and have to operate a mostly empty aircraft. CRJ because it's a high CASM aircraft that you're not going to be able to operate profitably with a full load, especially with pricing pressure from competing carriers with more pax-friendly larger gauge aircraft with a lower CASM)

There's nothing wrong with "thinking aloud" to see what sticks to the wall and what doesn't. Management, industry-wide, wants the "drama" of an us-versus-them situation.
 
B767Driver said:
Can someone present a cogent, unemotional argument

It was proposed years ago and they refused anything other than date of hire.

Do you know why there are hard feelings between mainline and rj groups? ........we initiated discussions on one list staple....and in return we were sued ...... and we saw 4000 jobs disappear while CMR grew by over 1000.

I'd rather not hear how your feelings are hurt. ....................our careers have been ruined and all the while the rj guys have crapped in our bed while we tried to assist in making theirs. How would you feel if you wrote me a check every month to support the betterment of my company...then when you lost your job and turned to me for assistance...I told you to get lost?

Can you understand the friction?

Keep in mind this is from someone who wanted an unemotional response.

Confrontation was inevitable after scope was implemented and later ALPA came to represent pilots on both sides of a wall built for the sole purpose of protecting one of the groups.

There will be peace between those groups when there is no more wall and no more splintered pilot groups. And man it isn't going to happen (or not) without lots of emotion. Not long after 9/11 I made my final appeal to an ALPA rep I had known for years. I suggested that since management needed lots from us, maybe it was time to get the scope house in order and bring the pilot groups together. (This would have been a concession from management because they now well know what a union busting gift ALPA handed them with scope.) This usually mild-mannered guy exhibited a couple of veins I had never seen before and let me know very clearly that it would never happen on his watch. I knew then this would only get resolved when ALPA was utterly ruined and rebuilt again from the ground up.

Unemotional? Good luck.
 
"$2800 per month that means you are earning around $45,000 annually."

How do you figure that? last time I checked $2800 x 12mo was $33,600


The problem is in my opinion is, that most pilots are in this career because they like to fly, and don't wanna get out cause it would be a waste off all that money they spent on flight training. You don't see coal miners making minimum wage, why? cause no one wants to be a coal miner! As long as the airlines are aware that pilots will work for peanuts cause they enjoy flying, they will continue to do so. And you can't even strike anymore, as soon as you do, joe pilot with 600hrs will gladly take your job by crossing the line.
 
Snow said:
"$2800 per month that means you are earning around $45,000 annually."
How do you figure that? last time I checked $2800 x 12mo was $33,600

If you are bringing home $2800 per month that means you are earning around $45,000 annually

It's all in the details here. "Bringing home" traditionally means "take home" pay, or after taxes. At least that's the way I took it. So, I agree with the statement.

And you can't even strike anymore, as soon as you do, joe pilot with 600hrs will gladly take your job by crossing the line.

I don't think most CFI's are that stupid. If any pilots went on strike, I'd put my money on no one crossing the line. Even MAPD grads weren't enticed to go to Freedom when that stuff was going on. People aren't as naive (sp?) as one would think.

ALPA is working on this issue. Hopefully they will be able to figure something out, and hopefully pilots will start to become more solidified toward a common goal. I think Mesa's upcoming contract neogotiations will be interesting to watch. On march first I will lose out on an additional $2/hr payraise because of the mesa rates...:(.

For the most part, the regionals are done expanding. That should help fight the face to the bottom as well.
 
What I find interesting is that the prevailing attitude is that large jets "belong" at the majors. Says who? Pilots? ALPA? Management? God? Large jets, small turboprops, whatever the airplane, "belong" at any company that can operate them safely, efficiently and most importantly, PROFITABLY. That is the problem the majors have. They cannot seem to operate any airplane profitably. There are all sorts of opinions as to why that is so, but that is not relevant to this discussion.

Like everything else in this world, the airline industry is constantly evolving. Evolution is an attempt by a creature, or a company, to adapt to a constantly changing environment. The environment that the airlines and their employees currently find themselves in is one of high fuel costs and price conscious consumers. Those that can adapt will survive, those that cannot will perish.

What that means for you and I is that we may have to evolve our expecations. We may not get to fly 767's for 250K a year, and instead will have to settle for CRJ's at 65K a year. I am not happy about it, but it is what it is.

But to get back the the original questions: People always look out for their own interests. That is human nature, and there is nothing wrong with that. People have to live in the present, while preparing for the future. Like everything else, "scope clauses" will have to evolve, or die.
 
Back
Top