Whistleblower at UAL

derg

Apparently a "terse" writer
Staff member
[ QUOTE ]
I am a whistle blower at United Airlines. I have been fired doing my job. I am
now back to work at United Airlines.
United has done everything possible to keep mechanics away from the aircraft.
They now have ramp personnel receiving and dispatching the aircraft from the
gates. They now have the ramp personnel doing "walk arounds" on the aircraft -
this is a maintenance function.
The qualification for a ramp person is a 10th grade education. No drug and
alcohol testing is done on these people. A matter of fact, just the other day a
mechanic reported to the supervisors that some ramp people were stealing liquor
from liquor carts on the aircraft and drinking them in the gatehouse.
As said earlier the company does not want mechanics near the aircraft. This is
so we don't find maintenance problems. Although 90 percent of mechanics will
not walk around an aircraft unless called out to do so, I continue to walk
around aircraft at every arrival. I am well known for finding maintenance
problems.
Another issue is the outsourced maintenance to 3rd party stations such as
Timco. We have been getting aircraft back with many problems that United
mechanics have to correct. I personally seen a B767 come in where an engines
boroscope plugs were laying on the inside of the engine cowl. This aircraft
flew many flights before this was found. This could of been catastrophic. That
aircraft just came out of a 3rd party maintenance station.
If you are not aware, Aircraft mechanics are required to have a license to work
on aircraft. All 3rd party stations hire employees that have no aircraft
experience. They have one A&P mechanic supervise 10 to 15 non-experienced and
sometimes non-English speaking employees who do the maintenance. There are
former United mechanics who tried working at these places and don't last a week
because of the pressure to do bad maintenance.
I hope I didn't scare you too much, but the truth is the truth. You could
probably get a lot of documented info from our union, AMFA. Just go to
AMFA8.org That is our local here in Denver. Good Luck with your research.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yow.
 
[ QUOTE ]
They now have ramp personnel receiving and dispatching the aircraft from the gates. They now have the ramp personnel doing "walk arounds" on the aircraft -
this is a maintenance function.

[/ QUOTE ]

So what? In the majority of the Southwest cities the rampers do this and have been for decades. In the outstations without mx personnel "ramp personnel receiving and dispatching the aircraft from the gates" is normal ops. Walk arounds are not required on quick turns, so the ramp is to be alert for any abnormaities, like fluids in the wrong places, and alert the crew.
 
yeahthat.gif


Same deal at XJT. We have 15 minutes to look the plane over as soon as it gets into the gate. Why the heck would we wait 30 minutes for contract mx to show just to look at the a/c. If there's a problem (like the wing tip hit a baggage cart.....), we tell the crew and they look at it. The CA makes the decision to call mx or not.

[ QUOTE ]
The qualification for a ramp person is a 10th grade education. No drug and
alcohol testing is done on these people.

[/ QUOTE ]

Now this is what pisses me off. I don't know what United's quals are, but EVERY ramper I know is required to have a HS diploma or GED to get the job. I'm pretty sure the DOT requires drug testing as a screening measure, and if you EVER get in an accident, it's the first thing the airport authority is going to want. I'm just sick of everyone assuming rampers are these uneducated, blithering idiots that only know how to stack bags. Just b/c some pissed in this guy's Cheerios does not alter reality......
 
[ QUOTE ]
Now this is what pisses me off. I don't know what United's quals are, but EVERY ramper I know is required to have a HS diploma or GED to get the job. I'm pretty sure the DOT requires drug testing as a screening measure, and if you EVER get in an accident, it's the first thing the airport authority is going to want. I'm just sick of everyone assuming rampers are these uneducated, blithering idiots that only know how to stack bags. Just b/c some pissed in this guy's Cheerios does not alter reality......

[/ QUOTE ]


This guy does have problems with UAL, thus the tone in his message, but I didn't see in his statement saying rampers are dumb. He is just saying the requirement to be one is to have a 10th grade education.

You don't have to be educated to be a ramper, which I think was this guy's point. No special schooling, just a willingness to work and to put up with heavy lifting. Having said that, I am sure many rampers are highly educated but choose to work there for the benefits (ie. networking, flight bennies, outdoor work, etc).
 
[ QUOTE ]
but I didn't see in his statement saying rampers are dumb. He is just saying the requirement to be one is to have a 10th grade education.


[/ QUOTE ]

Last time I checked, you needed to finish 12th grade to get the diploma......
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I didn't see in his statement saying rampers are dumb. He is just saying the requirement to be one is to have a 10th grade education.


[/ QUOTE ]

Last time I checked, you needed to finish 12th grade to get the diploma......

[/ QUOTE ]


Not entirely true. There is the GED, and from what I've heard from those that have taken it, BIG JOKE.

I am not discrediting anyone or anything about being a ramper. Obviously this guy feels safety is being compromised by UAL and their procedure. And he isn't too happy about it. So the way he wrote this piece was to exaggerating the lack of education it requires to work on the ramp so more people would take to what he wrote.
 
Rampers doing walkarounds? Is this the same as the folks doing wing walking while not looking at the wings?
 
[ QUOTE ]

Another issue is the outsourced maintenance to 3rd party stations such as
Timco. We have been getting aircraft back with many problems that United
mechanics have to correct.

[/ QUOTE ]

America West had the same problems when it decided just before Christmas in '94/'95 to lay off 500 mechs and outsource it's heavy maintenance to TRAMCO in Seattle. Planes were coming back from depot with all sorts of problems and incomplete work, worse than when they left. Mechs had a great opportunity for a "told you so" to AW management.
 
I think you can complete the 11th grade in FL and test out of the 12th. But considering my source was one of the talking heads on cable news, chances are he was full of dookie.
 
[ QUOTE ]
All 3rd party stations hire employees that have no aircraft
experience. They have one A&P mechanic supervise 10 to 15 non-experienced and
sometimes non-English speaking employees who do the maintenance. There are
former United mechanics who tried working at these places and don't last a week
because of the pressure to do bad maintenance.

[/ QUOTE ]


I work at a 3rd party maintence shop, and I can say for certian that SAA isn't like this.

Most of our stuctures mechanics have many years of experiance, & most have thier A&P.

All of our QC inspectors must have thier A&P and a ton of experiance. About 85% of all maintence tasks must be checked of by a QC inspector after the mechanic has finished.

Many of the mechanics here are Mexican and speak Spanish as well as English (which is something I can't do
blush.gif
).

I have never been pressured by anybody above me to sign of on something I felt was unsafe.

Anytime a problem occurs with a customers plane, top management look at the problem very carefully for several reasons. 1st safety, nobody wants a plane crash. 2nd money, if the customer is unhappy with how we do maintence, they will take their planes elsewhere.


I'm just about finished with my A&P (I already have the airframe half). I can say for certian, that just because somone has their liscense, dosen't automaticly make them a good mechanic.
 
FL education system, you probably don't even have to show up to pass the 12th. Hell, Mississippi's got higher test scores.

My point was I'm pretty tired of people looking down on rampers, especially those at airlines (often the SAME airline) that are in "better" positions. For some reason we're all drooling idiots that can't do basic math, have no career goals, and dropped out of high school. All this because we throw bags for a living. TECHNICALLY, you can be a pilot without graduating HS. You just need the FAA ratings. So, if I were to suggest that pilots fit into the same category as rampers, I'd probably spring a few veins in people's foreheads. I've been called things like "just a ramper," "uneducated slob," and (my favorite) "worthless bag monkey." Now, I can take good natured ribbing as good or better than the next person, but sometimes it's NOT good natured. That was one of the major problems at SWA, some CSAs and Ops people thought they were better than rampers. What they failed to notice in all of their jabbering, name calling and down talking was that all three positions have the exact same application qualifications.

Sorry for the rant. It just pisses me off to no end when some bitter guy at a barely hanging on airline decides to lash out and degrade people that have absolutely nothing to do with what's going on in his life.
 
[ QUOTE ]
That was one of the major problems at SWA, some CSAs and Ops people thought they were better than rampers.

[/ QUOTE ]

I spoke to a SWA pilot that reminded me that the rampers are the most important employes when it comes to customer service.

No matter how skilled the Pilots, no matter how freindly the FAs and CSAs were. If I get to my destination and my bag dosen't, I didn't get the basic service that I paid for.
mad.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
I spoke to a SWA pilot that reminded me that the rampers are the most important employes when it comes to customer service.

[/ QUOTE ]

Get his name, and he's got a frosty beverage on me for that.
 
Agreed, you guys (rampers) are awesome. It's hard work! Heck I didn't even know you guys did walkarounds! I thought I was the only one haha.

Now if we can just get more of you guys at IAH.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
That was one of the major problems at SWA, some CSAs and Ops people thought they were better than rampers.

[/ QUOTE ]

I spoke to a SWA pilot that reminded me that the rampers are the most important employes when it comes to customer service.

No matter how skilled the Pilots, no matter how freindly the FAs and CSAs were. If I get to my destination and my bag dosen't, I didn't get the basic service that I paid for.
mad.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

But if a Pilot doesnt do his job, you or your bag doesnt get there!
spin2.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
Now if we can just get more of you guys at IAH.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well, Tues is my last day in MEM anyway. Kinda hard to work here and finish training in ORL.
 
In ATL at Delta when a plane arrives the load agent responsible for that flight does a walk around looking for anything unusual. We are not mtc guys but a hole is a hole no matter who finds it. By doing this sometimes we catch stuff before the F/O gets there and call mtc out early. Its a time saver. We dont fix it just call the guys who can to avoid a delay. We dont relieve the F/O from the walkaround. Some guys out here may only have a high school education but until you have worked outside in 20 degree weather with the wind blowing at 15 kts and it raining you have no idea about the job of a ramp agent. Its not the most glamourous but you dang sure want me to make sure you plane is balanced and not overgrossed.
 
[ QUOTE ]
until you have worked outside in 20 degree weather with the wind blowing at 15 kts and it raining you have no idea about the job of a ramp agent.

[/ QUOTE ]

Dude, you just described my whole morning.
tongue.gif


Oh, and both the lav and water carts froze overnight. We tried to borrow carts from United and American, but their's froze, too. So, the first IAH flight went out with no water and Mesa's rear lav was iffy.......
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Now if we can just get more of you guys at IAH.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well, Tues is my last day in MEM anyway. Kinda hard to work here and finish training in ORL.

[/ QUOTE ]


Aftert you finish your pilot training, will you still be working for Express Jet?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Aftert you finish your pilot training, will you still be working for Express Jet?

[/ QUOTE ]

I really wish I could keep the XJT job and CFI. Unfortunately, MCO is handled by mainline CAL, so transferring wasn't an option. Living at home with my parents is not so good for my sanity, and it's even worse for my wife. I felt I was getting distracted from my main focus of FLYING the planes, and I was spinning my wheels LOADING the planes. I'd love to go back (XJT is my #1 choice for a regional airline job), and I'm keeping all the doors and connections open. Right now, I think it's better if I throw myself into it full force and get everything done. With the kid on the way in April I don't have time to screw around anymore.
 
Back
Top